Transition Metal Catalysis in Ionic Liquids

Many transition metal complexes dissolve readily in ionic liquids, which enables their use as solvents for transition metal catalysis. Sufficient solubility for a wide range of catalyst complexes is an obvious, but not trivial, prerequisite for a versatile solvent for homogenous catalysis. Some of the other approaches to the replacement of traditional volatile organic solvents by greener alternatives in transition metal catalysis, namely the use of supercritical CO2 or perfluorinated solvents, very often suffer from low catalyst solubility. This limitation is usually overcome by use of special ligand systems, which have to be synthesized prior to the catalytic reaction. 

In the case of ionic liquids, special ligand design is usually not necessary to obtain catalyst complexes dissolved in the ionic liquid in sufficiently high concentrations. 

However, it should be mentioned that the dissolution process of a solid, crystalline complex in an (often relatively viscous) ionic liquid can sometimes be slow. This is due to restricted mass transfer and can be speeded up either by increasing the exchange surface (ultrasonic bath) or by reducing the ionic liquid s viscosity. The latter is easily achieved by addition of small amounts of a volatile organic solvent that dissolves both the catalyst complex and the ionic liquid. As soon as the solution is homogeneous, the volatile solvent is then removed in vacuo. 

Since no special ligand design is usually required to dissolve transition metal complexes in ionic liquids, the application of ionic ligands can be an extremely useful tool with which to immobilize the catalyst in the ionic medium. In applications in which the ionic catalyst layer is intensively extracted with a non-miscible solvent (i.e., under the conditions of biphasic catalysis or during product recovery by extraction) it is important to ensure that the amount of catalyst washed from the ionic liquid is extremely low. Full immobilization of the (often quite expensive) transition metal catalyst, combined with the possibility of recycling it, is usually a crucial criterion for the large-scale use of homogeneous catalysis (for more details see Section 5.3.5). 

However, a number of limitations are still evident when tetrafluorohorate and hexafluorophosphate ionic liquids are used in homogeneous catalysis. The major aspect is that these anions are still relatively sensitive to hydrolysis. The tendency to anion hydrolysis is of course much less pronounced than that of the chloroalu-minate melts, hut it still occurs and this has major consequences for their use in transition metal catalysis. For example, the [PF ] anion of l-hutyl-3-methylimida-2olium ([BMIM]) hexafluorophosphate was found (in the author s laboratories) to hydrolyze completely after addition of excess water when the sample was kept for 8 h at 100 °C. Gaseous HF and phosphoric acid were formed. Under the same conditions, only small amounts of the tetrafluorohorate ion of [BMlMjjBFJ was converted into HF and boric acid [10]. The hydrolytic formation of HF from the anion of the ionic liquid under the reaction conditions causes the following problems with 

The potential of ionic liquids as novel media for transition metal catalysis received a substantial boost by the work of Wilkes group when they described, in 1992, the 

However, we have to be aware of a number of limitations when applying tetrafluoroborate and hexafluorophosphate ionic fiquids as reaction media in homogeneous catalysis. The major problem is that these anions are sensitive to hydrolysis. The 

With the dual approach of Sections 5.3.1 and 5.3.2 we would like to share our experience in particular with readers working in the field of transition metal catalysis, but so far inexperienced in using ionic liquids. Our section aims to provide some guidelines and is intended to encourage these scientists to test and develop ionic liquids as parts of a tool box for their future research. 

Wasserscheid, B. Ellis, H. Fabi-enne, World Patent, WO 0041809, 2000. 

---

Scheme 5.2-1 Early examples of transition metal catalysis in ionic liquids.

The author anticipates that the further development of transition metal catalysis in ionic liquids will, to a significant extent, be driven by the availability of new ionic liquids with different anion systems. In particular, cheap, halogen-free systems combining weak coordination to electrophilic metal centers and low viscosity with high stability to hydrolysis are highly desirable. 

Probably the most prominent property of an ionic liquid is its lack of vapor pressure. Transition metal catalysis in ionic liquids can particularly benefit from this on economic, environmental, and safety grounds. 

Obviously, with the development of the first catalytic reactions in ionic liquids, the general research focus turned away from basic studies of metal complexes dissolved in ionic liquids. Today there is a clear lack of fundamental understanding of many catalytic processes in ionic liquids on a molecular level. Much more fundamental work is undoubtedly needed and should be encouraged in order to speed up the future development of transition metal catalysis in ionic liquids. 

However, research into transition metal catalysis in ionic liquids should not focus only on the question of how to make some specific products more economical or ecological by use of a new solvent and, presumably, a new multiphasic process. Since it bridges the gap between homogeneous and heterogeneous catalysis, in a novel and highly attractive manner, the application of ionic liquids in transition metal catalysis gives access to some much more fundamental and conceptual questions for basic research. 

In comparison with traditional biphasic catalysis using water, fluorous phases, or polar organic solvents, transition metal catalysis in ionic liquids represents a new and advanced way to combine the specific advantages of homogeneous and heterogeneous catalysis. In many applications, the use of a defined transition metal complex immobilized on a ionic liquid support has already shown its unique potential. Many more successful examples - mainly in fine chemical synthesis - can be expected in the future as our loiowledge of ionic liquids and their interactions with transition metal complexes increases. 

In contrast, we intend to demonstrate the principle aspects of catalyst recycling and regeneration using the ionic liquid methodology. These aspects will be explored in more detail for the example of Rh-catalysed hydroformylation (see Section 7.2). First, however, we will briefly introduce important general facts concerning transition metal catalysis in ionic liquids (see Section 7.1.2). This will be followed by a consideration of liquid-liquid biphasic reactions in these media from an engineering point of view (see Section 7.1.3). 

INTRODUCTION TO TRANSITION METAL CATALYSIS IN IONIC LIQUIDS... 

In comparison to traditional biphasic catalysis using water, fluorous phases or polar organic solvents, transition metal catalysis in ionic liquids represents a new and advanced way of combining the specific advantages of homogeneous and heterogeneous catalysis. 

---