Superacid carbocations

My work on long-lived (persistent) carbocations dates back to the late 1950s at Dow and resulted in the first direct observation of alkyl cations. Subsequently, a wide spectrum of carbocations as long-lived species was studied using antimony pentafluoride as an extremely strong Lewis acid and later using other highly acidic (superacidic) systems. 

My research during the Cleveland years continued and extended the study of carbocations in varied superacidic systems as well as exploration of the broader chemistry of superacids, involving varied ionic systems and reagents. I had made the discovery of how to prepare and study long-lived cations of hydrocarbons while working for Dow in 1959-1960. After my return to academic life in Cleveland, a main... 

Over a decade of research, we were able to show that practically all conceivable carbocations could be prepared under what became known as stable ion conditions using various very strong acid systems (see discussion of superacids) and low nucleophilicity solvents (SO2, SO2CIF, SO2F2, etc.). A variety of precursors could be used under appropriate conditions, as shown, for example, in the preparation of the methylcyclopentyl cation. 

Nonbonded electron pair donors (w-donors) are expectedly readily protonated (or coordinated) with superacids. Remarkably, this includes even xenon, long considered an inert gas. The protonation of some 7T-, (T- and -bases and their subsequent ionization to carbocations or onium ions is depicted as follows ... 

The key initiation step in cationic polymerization of alkenes is the formation of a carbocationic intermediate, which can then interact with excess monomer to start propagation. We studied in some detail the initiation of cationic polymerization under superacidic, stable ion conditions. Carbocations also play a key role, as I found not only in the acid-catalyzed polymerization of alkenes but also in the polycondensation of arenes as well as in the ring opening polymerization of cyclic ethers, sulfides, and nitrogen compounds. Superacidic oxidative condensation of alkanes can even be achieved, including that of methane, as can the co-condensation of alkanes and alkenes. 

Under superacidic, low nucleophilicity so-called stable ion conditions, developing electron-deficient carbocations do not find reactive external nucleophiles to react with thus they stay persistent in solution stabilized by internal neighboring group interactions. 

The discovery of a significant number of hypercoordinate carboca-tions ( nonclassical ions), initially based on solvolytic studies and subsequently as observable, stable ions in superacidic media as well as on theoretical calculations, showed that carbon hypercoordination is a general phenomenon in electron-deficient hydrocarbon systems. Some characteristic nonclassical carbocations are the following. 

The isomerization of butane to iso butane in superacids is illustrative of a protolytic isomerization, where no intermediate olefins are present in equilibrium with carbocations. 

A fundamental difference exists between conventional acid-catalyzed and superacidic hydrocarbon chemistry. In the former, trivalent car-benium ions are always in equilibrium with olefins, which play the key role, whereas in the latter, hydrocarbon transformation can take place without the involvement of olefins through the intermediacy of five-coordinate carbocations. 

The reaction of trivalent carbocations with carbon monoxide giving acyl cations is the key step in the well-known and industrially used Koch-Haaf reaction of preparing branched carboxylic acids from al-kenes or alcohols. For example, in this way, isobutylene or tert-hutyi alcohol is converted into pivalic acid. In contrast, based on the superacidic activation of electrophiles leading the superelectrophiles (see Chapter 12), we found it possible to formylate isoalkanes to aldehydes, which subsequently rearrange to their corresponding branched ketones. 

To be able to prepare and study these elusive species in stable form, acids billions of times stronger than concentrated sulfuric acid were needed (so called superacids). Some substituted carbocations, however, are remarkably stable and are even present in nature. You may be surprised to learn that the fine red wine we drank tonight contained carbocations which are responsible for the red color of this natural 12% or so alcoholic solution. I hope you enjoyed it as much as I did. 

In superacidic media, the carbocationic iatermediates, which were long postulated to exist duting Friedel-Crafts type reactions (9—11) can be observed, and even isolated as salts. The stmctures of these carbocations have been studied ia high acidity—low nucleophilicity solvent systems usiag spectroscopic methods such as nmr, ir, Raman, esr, and x-ray crystallography. 

All lation with Alkanes. Superacids such as HF-SbF abstract hydride ion from alkanes to form carbocations at low temperatures. The... 

These reactions involve the intermediate formation of thiols, followed by condensation to the sulfides. The observation of isomerized products in suitable cases indicates the intermediate formation of carbocations, either by protolysis of alkanes by the superacid or reversible ionisation of the thiol products (149). 

Carbocations generated from alkanes using superacids react with carbon monoxide under mild conditions to form carboxyUc acid (188). In this process isomeric carboxyUc acids are produced as a mixture. However, when the reaction is mn with catalytic amounts of bromine (0.3 mmol eq) in HF-SbF solution, regio-selective carboxylation is obtained. / -Propane was converted almost exclusively to isobutyric acid under these conditions. 

The extent to which rearrangement occurs depends on the structure of the cation and foe nature of the reaction medium. Capture of carbocations by nucleophiles is a process with a very low activation energy, so that only very fast rearrangements can occur in the presence of nucleophiles. Neopentyl systems, for example, often react to give r-pentyl products. This is very likely to occur under solvolytic conditions but can be avoided by adjusting reaction conditions to favor direct substitution, for example, by use of an aptotic dipolar solvent to enhance the reactivity of the nucleophile. In contrast, in nonnucleophilic media, in which fhe carbocations have a longer lifetime, several successive rearrangement steps may occur. This accounts for the fact that the most stable possible ion is usually the one observed in superacid systems. 

Strong acids or superacid systems generate stable fluorinated carbocations [40, 42] Treatment of tetrafluorobenzbarrelene with arenesulfonyl chlorides in nitro-methane-lithium perchlorate yields a crystalline salt with a rearranged benzo barrelene skeleton [43] Ionization of polycyclic adducts of difluorocarbene and derivatives of bornadiene with antimony pentafluonde in fluorosulfonyl chloride yields stable cations [44, 45]... 

The use of antimony pentafluoride as a component of superacids for the generation of carbocations from various organic compounds was reviewed recently [16],... 

Additional evidence for the SnI mechanism, in particular, for the intermediacy of carbocations, is that solvolysis rates of alkyl chlorides in ethanol parallel carbocation stabilities as determined by heats of ionization mea.sured in superacid solutions (p. 219). It is important to note that some solvolysis reactions proceed by an Sn2 mechanism." ... 

It is likely that protonated cyclopropane transition states or intermediates are also responsible for certain non-1,2 rearrangements. For example, in superacid solution, the ions 14 and 16 are in equilibrium. It is not possible for these to interconvert solely by 1,2 alkyl or hydride shifts unless primary carbocations (which are highly unlikely) are intermediates. However, the reaction can be explained " by postulating that (in the forward reaction) it is the 1,2 bond of the intermediate or transition state 15 that opens up rather than the 2,3 bond, which is the one that would open if the reaction were a normal 1,2 shift of a methyl group. In this case, opening of the 1,2 bond produces a tertiary cation, while opening of the 2,3 bond would give a secondary cation. (In the reaction 16 14, it is of course the 1,3 bond that opens). 

---