Solid superacids acidity measurements

Solid acid catalysts such as mixed oxides (chalcides) have been used extensively for many years in the petroleum industry and organic synthesis. Their main advantage compared with liquid acid catalysts is the ease of separation from the reaction mixture, which allows continuous operation, as well as regeneration and reutilization of the catalyst. Furthermore, the heterogeneous solid catalysts can lead to high selectivity or specific activity. Due to the heterogeneity of solid superacids, accurate acidity measurements are difficult to carry out and to interpret. Up until now, the most useful way to estimate the acidity of a solid catalyst is to test its catalytic activity in well-known acid-catalyzed reactions. 

Figure 2. Acidity ranges for several common superacids. The solid bars are measured using indicators, while the broken bar is estimated by kinetics measurements in (%) mol Lewis acid.

Another area of difficulty is measuring the acid strength of solid superacids. Since solid superacid catalysts are used extensively in the chemical industry, particularly in the petroleum field, a reliable method for measuring the acidity of solids would be extremely useful. The main difficulty to start with is that the activity coefficients for solid species are unknown and thus no thermodynamic acidity function can be properly defined. On the other hand, because the solid by definition is heterogeneous, acidic and basic sites can coexist with variable strength. The surface area available for colorimetric determinations may have acidic properties widely different from those of the bulk material this is especially true for well-structured solids such as zeolites. 

Although the super acidity of sulphated zirconium oxide is widely accepted, Farca iu indicated that traditional acidity measurements, i.e. Hammett type, can not be applied to solid acids. He showed that the exceptional catalytic activity of sulphated zirconia and other sulphated metal oxides (SMO) is not justified by their acid strength and that they are in fact not superacidic at all. He argues that sulphated zirconium exhibits a bifunctional character in which oxidation in the initiation step is combined with acid catalysed reaction of the intermediates formed. Oxidation is normally achieved through the reduction of the sulphate or added redox promotors, which increases the catalytic activity but not the acid strength. 

The acidity strength of solid acids is still not well known and is difficult to measure. Claims of superacidity in solids are numerous and will be discussed later in Chapter 2. Among the reviews related to acidity characterization of solids, those of Corma, Farneth and Gorte, and Fripiat and Dumesic are quite significantly representative.30... 

Zeolites such as HZSM-5 were considered as superacids on the basis of the initial product distribution in accord with C-H and C-C bond protolysis when isoalkanes were reacted at 500°C (the Haag and Dessau mechanism).135 The reactivity was assigned to superacidic sites in the zeolite framework.136 The superacid character of other solid acids was claimed on the basis of Hammett indicator color change137,138 or on the basis of UV spectrophotometric measurements.139,140 In 2000, a special issue of Microporous and Mesoporous Materials141 was devoted to the superacid-type hydrocarbon chemistry taking place on solid acids as suggested by the late Werner Haag. 

Many types of solid acid and base catalysts are known.11 Superacids are those that are at least as strong as 100% sulfuric acid.12 The acid strengths are measured using basic indicators and are assigned a Hammett acidity function, H0- Table 6.1 lists some superacids, with the strongest at the top. 

What makes Nafion so useful for catalytic purposes is the superacidity of the acidic form of the polymers. Because the sulfonic acid group is attached to a highly electron-withdrawing perfluoroalkyl backbone, a relatively high polarization of the -OH bond results. Because methods for measuring solution acidity cannot be directly applied to heterogeneous solid materials, determination of the acidity of Nafion-H is difficult. Nevertheless, studies indicate that the acidic character of Nafion-H resin is comparable with that of 100% sulfuric acid, because the estimated Hammett Hq acidity function value of Nafion-H, approximately —12, is comparable with that of 100% sulfuric acid [1]. 

Besides the above reactions, any kind of acid-catalyzed reactions such as cracking of cumene, alkylation of benzene with propene, hydration of olefins, isomerization of cyclopropane, esterification of acetic acid with ethanol, etc. can be used for the estimation of the acidic property of solid acids. Skeletal isomerization of li-butane to -butane is used to check whether a solid acid has superacidity, since the isomerization is known not to be catalyzed even by 100% sulfuric acid. However, it should be noticed that the differentiation between acid strength and acid amount is not easy from the measurement of catalytic activity for an acid-catalyzed reaction. Characterization of acid catalysts by use of model reactions has been reviewed recently by Guisnet. ... 

---