Smoluchowski approach

J. Troe Professor Marcus, you were mentioning the 2D Sumi-Marcus model with two coordinates, an intra- and an intermolecu-lar coordinate, which can provide saddle-point avoidance. I would like to mention that we have proposed multidimensional intramolecular Kramers-Smoluchowski approaches that operate with highly nonparabolic saddles of potential-energy surface [Ch. Gehrke, J. Schroeder, D. Schwarzer, J. Troe, and F. Voss, J. Chem. Phys. 92, 4805 (1990)] these models also produce saddle-point avoidances, but of an intramolecular nature the consequence of this behavior is strongly non-Arrhenius temperature dependences of isomerization rates such as we have observed in the photoisomerization of diphenyl butadiene. 

This value of K ff) is silently transferred in the Smoluchowski approach to any bimolecular reactions, including three basic processes discussed above A+B— B,A+B—>0 and A+A —> B (for the first time it was applied to the latter reaction describing the colloid formation in liquids). Such an approach... 

They have demonstrated that the Smoluchowski approach could indeed be derived rigorously as a cut-off of the set of rigorous kinetic equations discussed in Chapter 4. However, the accuracy of this approximation and the range of applicability of the Smoluchowski approach remained unclear until recently [16],... 

A new principal element of the Waite-Leibfried theory compared to the Smoluchowski approach is the relation between the effective reaction rate K(t) and the intermediate order parameter x = Xab (r,i). In its turn, the Smoluchowski approach is just an heuristic attempt to describe the simplest irreversible bimolecular reactions A + B- B,A + B- B and A + B -> 0 and cannot be extended for more complicated reactions. The Waite-Leibfried approach is not limited by these simple reactions only it could be applied to the reversible reactions and reaction chains. However, in the latter case the particular linearity in the joint correlation function x = Xab (r, ) does not always mean linearity of equations since additional non-linearity caused by particle densities can arise. 

Despite the fact that (5.3.3) reveals the same asymptotic behaviour (nA(t) oc f-1/2, as t —> oo), the relative concentration is always smaller than predicted by the Smoluchowski theory for nA — l/2nA(0), the discrepancy is 9%. In other words, the Smoluchowski approach slightly underestimates a real reaction rate due to its neglect of reactant density fluctuations stimulating. (Note that in the case of second reaction, A + A — A, the reaction rate K(t) in the Smoluchowski approach has to be corrected by a factor 1/2... 

There is essentially a single modeling approach that has been developed, referred to here as the von Smoluchowski approach, and this method will be presented first. The von Smoluchowski approach requires analytical expressions to represent particle collision rates, to calculate collision efficiencies, and to dictate aggregate structure formation. These individual components are discussed in the subsequent sections, followed by analytical and numerical techniques of solving the von Smoluchowski equation. 

The von Smoluchowski approach is developed by first considering that Ny, the number of particle collisions occurring per unit time per unit volume between particles of volume v, and vj, is proportional to the product of the number concentrations... 

These effects are illustrated in a comparison of the rectilinear and curvilinear approaches to differential sedimentation presented in Figure 8, adapted from Han and Lawler (24). In both approaches, the upper, larger, faster particle is settling by gravity toward the lower, smaller, slower particle. In the rectilinear or Smoluchowski approach, all small particles with size di that reside below the larger particle (size dp within the area Ar with diameter (d, + dj) come into contact with the larger particle ( DS(ij) is given by equation 3c. 

Assumptions. The first assumption in the Smoluchowski approach, that of rectilinear particle motion, can lead to significantly overestimated collision rates in some aggregation processes. The second assumption, that of volume conservation or the formation of coalesced spheres, can lead to an underestimation of collision opportunities and aggregation rates. As the co-... 

In the absence of better information, it is sometimes assumed that errors from the two assumptions in the Smoluchowski approach compensate for each other. Reductions in collisions resulting from hydrodynamic effects are assumed to be offset by increases in collision rates as aggregate volume increases while coagulation proceeds. The Smoluchowski approach modified to include hydrodynamic interactions is useful at the onset of aggregation processes, when the inclusion of fluid within aggregate pores is small. 

Proton transfer dynamics of photoacids to the solvent have thus, being reversible in nature, been modelled using the Debye-von Smoluchowski equation for diffusion-assisted reaction dynamics in a large body of experimental work on HPTS [84—87] and naphthols [88-92], with additional studies on the temperature dependence [93-98], and the pressure dependence [99-101], as well as the effects of special media such as reverse micelles [102] or chiral environments [103]. Moreover, results modelled with the Debye-von Smoluchowski approach have also been reported for proton acceptors triggered by optical excitation (photobases) [104, 105], and for molecular compounds with both photoacid and photobase functionalities, such as lO-hydroxycamptothecin [106] and coumarin 4 [107]. It can be expected that proton diffusion also plays a role in hydroxyquinoline compounds [108-112]. Finally, proton diffusion has been suggested in the long time dynamics of green fluorescent protein [113], where the chromophore functions as a photoacid [23,114], with an initial proton release on a 3-20 ps time scale [115,116]. 

An important improvement in Smoluchowskis approach was to consider hydrodynamic interactions between two particles as they approach each other. These interactions are of two types and result in curvilinear models. First are deviations from rectilinear flow paths that occur as two particles approach each other. Second is the increasing hydrodynamic drag that occurs as two particles come into close proximity. 

Velocity profiles across the capillary have a Poisseuille shaped flow and the expression predicts that the electroosmotic coefficient of permeability should vary with the square of the radius. In practice, it is found generally that this law is not as satisfactory as the Helmholtz-Smoluchowski approach for predicting electroosmotic behavior in soils. The failure of small pore theory may be because most clays have an aggregate structure with the flow determined by the larger pores [6], Another theoretical approach is referred to as the Spiegler Friction theory [25,6]. Its assumption, that the medium for electroosmosis is a perfect permselective membrane, is obviously not valid for soils, where the pore fluid comprises dilute electrol d e. An expression is derived for the net electroosmotic flow, Q, in moles/Faraday,... 

Jones [20] used a Smoluchowski approach to examine interacting spherical polymers. Jones predicted that, if one polymer species is dilute and labelled, the measured diffusion coefficient from QELSS is determined only by hydrodynamic interactions of the tagged polymers and their untagged matrix neighbors, and is the single-particle diffusion coefficient. The hydrodynamic approach culminated in analyses of Carter, et al. [21] and Phillies [22] of mutual and tracer diffusion coefficients, including hydrodynamic and direct interactions and reference frame issues. 

Figure 3.8 shows some examples in which full numerical results are compared with Smoluchowski equation. Note that, as mentioned, the Smoluchowski approach is less valid, the higher the zeta potential and the thicker the double layer. 

The results of three ultrasonic investigations on lanthanide salts have been reported. The studies on erbium(iii) perchlorate in aqueous methanol suggest that inner-sphere perchlorate complexes occur at water mole fractions of less than 0.9. On that basis, the rate constant for the formation of the inner-sphere complex from the outer-sphere complex at 25 °C is 1.2 x 10 s. The case of erbium(m) nitrate in aqueous methanol is more complicated and it is suggested that the mechanism involves the existence of two forms of the solvated lanthanide ion, differing in coordination number, in equilibrium with the outer- and inner-sphere complexes. The results for aqueous yttrium nitrate, on the other hand, represent a simplification over those of previous ultrasonic studies on the lanthanides. The authors reject the normal multistep mechanism in favour of a single diffusion-controlled process. Unfortunately, the computed value for the formation rate constant kt of 1.0 x 10 1 mol s is at least two orders of magnitude lower than the value calculated on the Debye-Smoluchowski approach, but the discrepancy is attributed to steric effects. 

Russell et al. (14) have developed theories for the upper and lower bounds for residual termination based upon the Smoluchowski approach to diffusion controlled chemical reactions. For the upper bound, termed the flexible limit, the value of kj was calculated assuming that the chain end to which the free... 

---