Reflux ratio simple columns

Porter and Momoh have suggested an approximate but simple method of calculating the total vapor rate for a sequence of simple columns. Start by rewriting Eq. (5.3) with the reflux ratio R defined as a proportion relative to the minimum reflux ratio iimin (typically R/ min = 1-D- Defining Rp to be the ratio Eq. (5.3) becomes... 

Consider again the simple process shown in Fig. 4.4d in which FEED is reacted to PRODUCT. If the process usbs a distillation column as separator, there is a tradeofi" between refiux ratio and the number of plates if the feed and products to the distillation column are fixed, as discussed in Chap. 3 (Fig. 3.7). This, of course, assumes that the reboiler and/or condenser are not heat integrated. If the reboiler and/or condenser are heat integrated, the, tradeoff is quite different from that shown in Fig. 3.7, but we shall return to this point later in Chap. 14. The important thing to note for now is that if the reboiler and condenser are using external utilities, then the tradeoff between reflux ratio and the number of plates does not affect other operations in the flowsheet. It is a local tradeoff. 

The dominance of distiHation-based methods for the separation of Hquid mixtures makes a number of points about RCM and DRD significant. Residue curves trace the Hquid-phase composition of a simple single-stage batch stiHpot as a function of time. Residue curves also approximate the Hquid composition profiles in continuous staged or packed distillation columns operating at infinite reflux and reboil ratios, and are also indicative of many aspects of the behavior of continuous columns operating at practical reflux ratios (12). 

In Chapter 9, it was shown how the Underwood Equations can be used to calculate the minimum reflux ratio. A simple mass balance around the top of the column for constant molar overflow, as shown in Figure 11.3, at minimum reflux gives ... 

Equations, determine sequences of simple and complex columns that minimize the overall vapor load. The recoveries will be assumed to be 100%. Assume the actual to minimum reflux ratio to be 1.1 and all the columns, with the exception of thermal coupling and prefractionator links, are fed with saturated liquid. Neglect pressure drop through columns. Relative volatilities can be calculated from the Peng-Robinson Equation of State with interaction parameters set to zero. Pressures are allowed to vary through the sequence with relative volatilities recalculated on the basis of the feed composition for each column. Pressures of each column are allowed to vary to a minimum such that the bubble point of the overhead product is 10°C above the cooling water return temperature of 35°C (i.e. 45°C) or a minimum of atmospheric pressure. 

Continuous multicomponent distillation simulation is illustrated by the simulation example MCSTILL, where the parametric runs facility of MADONNA provides a valuable means of assessing the effect of each parameter on the final steady state. It is thus possible to rapidly obtain the optimum steady state settings for total plate number, feed plate number and column reflux ratio via a simple use of sliders. 

Floquet et al. (1985) proposed a tree searching algorithm in order to synthesize chemical processes involving reactor/separator/recycle systems interlinked with recycle streams. The reactor network of this approach is restricted to a single isothermal CSTR or PFR unit, and the separation units are considered to be simple distillation columns. The conversion of reactants into products, the temperature of the reactor, as well as the reflux ratio of the distillation columns were treated as parameters. Once the values of the parameters have been specified, the composition of the outlet stream of the reactor can be estimated and application of the tree searching algorithm on the alternative separation tasks provides the less costly distillation sequence. The problem is solved for several values of the parameters and conclusions are drawn for different regions of operation. 

Remark 2 The separators are sharp and simple distillation columns (i.e., sharp splits of light and heavy key components without distribution of component in both the distillate and bottoms one feed and two products). The operating conditions of the distillation columns (i.e., pressure, temperature, reflux ratio) are fixed at nominal values. Hence, heat integration options are not considered, and the hot and cold utilities are directly used for heating and cooling requirements, respectively. 

Robinson (1970) considered an industrial 10-component batch distillation operation. The feed condition is shown in Table 5.3. The distillation column was currently producing the desired product using constant reflux ratio scheme. Table 5.4 summarises the results of the application of minimum time problem using simple model with and without column holdup. 

For single separation duty, Farhat et al. (1990) considered the operation of an existing column for a fixed batch time and aimed at maximising (or minimising) the amount of main-cuts (or off-cuts) while using predefined reflux policies such as constant, linear (with positive slope) and exponential reflux ratio profile. They also considered a simple model with negligible liquid holdup, constant molar overflow and simple thermodynamics, but included detailed plate to plate calculations (similar to Type III model). 

For single separation duty, Bernot et al. (1991) presented a method to estimate batch sizes, operating times, utility loads, costs, etc. for multicomponent batch distillation. The approach is similar to that of Diwekar et al. (1989) in the sense that a simple short cut technique is used to avoid integration of a full column model. Their simple column model assumes negligible holdup and equimolal overflow. The authors design and, for a predefined reflux or reboil ratio, minimise the total annual cost to produce a number of product fractions of specified purity from a multicomponent mixture. 

Open loop strategy A simple control strategy is adopted operate the column at constant reflux ratio (r), reboiler heat duty (QR) and terminate when the reboiler liquid level falls below a threshold level (H,hreshoid) to avoid reboiler running dry. This gives three operating parameters to be chosen. 

Figure 1 Scheme for a distillation system. These systems can be built by simple glass blowing (a) source solvent (b) first fraction bulb (c) collection bulb (d) fractionating column (e) condenser (f) reflux ratio valve (g) regulator Teflon valve (h) O ring connector. 

This effect is best explained by a simple illustration. Suppose we feed a column with 50 mol/h of A and 50 moVh of B, and A is the more volatile component. Suppose the distillate contains 49 mol/h of A and 1 mol of B, and the bottoms contains 1 mol/h of A and 49 mol/h of B, Thus the distillate flowrate is D = 50 mol/h and the purity of the distillate is xDA = 0.98. Now we attempt to fix the distillate flowrate at 50 mol/h and also hold the distillate composition at 0.98 mole fraction A. Suppose the feed composition changes to 40 mol/h of A and 60 mol/ h of B. The distillate will now contain almost all of the A in the feed (40 mol/h), but the rest of it (10 mol/h) must be components. Therefore the purity of the distillate can never be greater than xD A = 40/50 = 0.80 mole fraction A. The overall component balance makes it impossible to maintain the desired distillate composition of 0.98. We can go to infinite reflux ratio and add an infinite number of trays, and distillate composition will never be better than 0.80. 

For example, let us consider a simple distillation column in which we have specifications on both the distillate and bottoms products (v-ahK and x b lk We go through the design procedure to establish the number of trays and the reflux ratio required to make the separation for a given feed composition. This gives us a base case from which to start. Then we establish what disturbances will affect the system and over what ranges they will vary. The most common disturbance, and the one that most affects the column, is a change in feed composition. Next we propose a partial control structure. By partial we mean we must decide what variables will be held constant. We do not have to decide what manipulated variable is paired with what controlled variable. We must fix as many variables as there are degrees of freedom in the system of equations. 

We shall determine the limiting behavior for simple distillation columns by discovering all the products of such a column, regardless of the number of stages it has or the reflux ratio used in operating it. We present and extend here the ideas advanced in Wahnschafft (1992) and Wahnschafft et al. (1992). 

The TEA-Chlorex azeotrope consists of approximately 1 part of TEA and 1 part of Chlorex. The presence of Chlorex increases the relative volatility between dodecene and TEA from 1.4 to 11.0 as measured in a Colburn equilibrium still. Separation of dodecene from TEA thus becomes a relatively simple matter. Most of the dodecene can be removed with little TEA contamination in a column with five to ten theoretical plates operating at a reflux ratio of 1 to 1. 

To redistribute the stages in the remaining sections, a shortcut simulation is used to find out the required number of trays, the feed tray location and the minimum reflux ratio for each column in the sequence. To make use of the existing column with the same number of trays (24 trays) iterations are required to adjust the sum of the rectifying sections in each column equal to 24 (number of trays in the main column). Finally, the sequence of the simple columns is merged into a complex column. The main column is not changed, but the side strippers and pump arounds need to be relocated or adjusted. 

Studying the interdependence between column variables is important when attempting to select parameter pairs for specifying the performance of a conventional column. The reflux ratio and product rate are generally considered the most independent pair. The other extreme may be illustrated by a situation where both product rates are specihed. These are two-column variables that are totally dependent since specifying one of them hxes the other by simple material balance. Once one product rate is known, no additional information about the column performance is acquired by providing the other product rate. This fact is indicated by the horizontal line for the bottoms rate shown in Figure 7.1. 

To begin the calculations the column variables must be first initialized to some estimated values. Simple methods can be used for this purpose, based on the column specifications and possibly supplemented by shortcut methods. The column temperature profile may be assumed linear, interpolated between estimated condenser and reboiler temperatures. The values for Lj and Vj may be based on estimated reflux ratio and product rates, assisted by the assumption of constant internal flows within each column section. The compositions Xj- and T, may be assumed uniform throughout the column, set equal to the compositions of the liquid and vapor obtained by flashing the combined feeds at average column temperature and pressure. The other variables to be initialized are Rf,Rj, and Sj, which are calculated from their defining equations. The values for Qj may either be fixed at given values (zero on most stages) or estimated. 

---