Reference Materials in Isotopic Analysis

In addition to the apphcations mentioned above, isotopic variations can in general be relied on to assess whether two samples are identical or of the same origin or not. However, it is only possible to determine indisputably that they are not identical, that is, when obtaining significantly different values for the isotope amount ratios - often referred to in short as isotope ratios - for the two samples. If both samples show the same isotope amount ratio(s), one can only assume that they are identical with a certain probability, because they could have been affected 

First Edition. Edited by Frank Vanhaecke and Patrick Degryse. 

In all these applications, isotope ratio data are produced, which are interpreted on an absolute or relative basis and which have an impact on our daily life, whether this is in science (e.g., age of an artifact), in society (e.g., provenance of food), or in public safety (e.g., neutron shielding in nuclear power plants). To ensure that these data are reliable and accurate, some specific requirements have to be fulfilled. The main requirement is that all these measurement results are comparable, which means that the corresponding results can be compared and differences between the measurement results can be used to draw further conclusions. This is only possible if the measurement results are traceable to the same reference [25]. This in turn can only be realized by applying isotopic reference materials (IRMs) for correction for bias and for validation of the analytical procedure. Whereas in earlier days only experts in mass spectrometry were able to deliver reproducible isotope ratio data, nowadays many laboratories, some of which may even have never been involved with mass spectrometry before, produce isotope ratio data using inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS). Especially for such users, IRMs are indispensable to permit proper method validation and reliable results. The rapid development and the broad availability of ICP-MS instrumentation have also led to an expansion of the research area and new elements are under investigation for their isotopic variations. In this context, all users require IRMs to correct for instrumental mass discrimination or at least to allow isotope ratio data to be related to a commonly accepted basis. 

A broad overview of the application of ICP-MS in isotopic analysis was given in a tutorial review by Vanhaecke et al. [26]. 

Applied Chemistry, and others). The VIM is mainly focused on basic expressions in metrology, the science of measurements. As the core subject of analytical chemistry and isotopic analysis is measurements, they belong to metrology and, consequently, the metrological terminology should be used. 

---

I 6 Reference Materials in Isotopic Analysis Certified reference material... 

In 2005, De Laeter discussed the role of isotope reference materials for the analysis of non-traditionaT stable isotopes. At present, no isotopically certified reference materials exist for a large number of elements, including Cu, Zn, Mo and Cd, and it is important that this situation be rectified as soon as practicable. Before the isotopically certified reference materials become available for selected elements, suitable reference materials can be created as a standard if sufficient and reliable isotope data have been obtained by interlaboratory comparisons. For example, the Hf/ Hf isotope ratio was measured using hafnium oxide from Johnson Matthey Chemicals, JMC-475, for hafnium isotope ratio measurements with different multi-collector mass spectrometers (ICP-MS and TIMS) as summarized in Table 8.1. However, no isotope SRM is certified for the element Mo either. Mo isotope analysis is relevant, for example, for studying the isotope fractionation of molybdenum during chemical processes or the isotope variation of molybdenum in nature as the result of the predicted double (3 decay of Zr or 18.26-28 spectroscopically pure sample from Johnson Mattey Specpure is proposed as a laboratory standard reference material if sufficient and reliable isotope data are collected via an interlaboratory comparison. 

TABLE 7.6 Typical Analysis (pg/g) of Selected Elements in National Institute of Standards and Technology 1643a and 1643b Trace Elements in Water Standard Reference Materials by Isotope Dilution Quantitation... 

The use of a definitive analytical method can also be used to establish standard reference materials. Definitive methods are ones that can produce exacting quantitative data without the need to compare measurements to a calibration standard. The gravimetric analysis method is a definitive technique. Isotope-dilution mass spectrometry, which is extensively used by NIST and other agencies producing certified standard reference materials, is also considered to be a definitive method of analysis. As discussed in Chapter 7, isotope dilution quantitation can be effectively used with ICP-MS. Therefore, a laboratory with ICP-MS instrumentation can produce reference materials in specific sample matrices for selected elements by using the isotope dilution technique.These standard reference materials still must be considered secondary standards, because they are usually not traceable to existing certified standards. 

Valles Mota, J. R, Ruiz Encinar, J., Fernandez de la Campa, M. R., and Garcia Alonso, J. I. (1999). Determination of cadmium in environmental and biological reference materials using isotope dilution analysis with a double focusing ICP-MS A comparison with quadrupole ICP-MS./. Anal. At. Spectrom. 14(9), 1467. 

Applications The application of the isotope dilution technique is especially useful in carrying out precise and accurate micro and trace analyses. The most accurate results in mass spectrometry are obtained if the isotope dilution technique is applied (RSDs better than 1 % in trace analysis). Therefore, application of IDMS is especially recommended for calibration of other analytical data, and for certification of standard reference materials. The technique also finds application in the field of isotope geology, and is used in the nuclear industry for quantitative isotope analysis. 

Quantification is usually achieved by a standard addition method, use of labeled internal standards, and/or external calibration curves. In order to allow for matrix interferences the most reliable method for a correct quantitation of the analytes is the isotope dilution method, which takes into account intrinsic matrix responses, using a deuterated internal standard or carbon-13-labeled internal standard with the same chemistry as the pesticide being analyzed (i.e., d-5 atrazine for atrazine analysis). Quality analytical parameters are usually achieved by participation in interlaboratory exercises and/or the analysis of certified reference materials [21]. 

Flow-injection sample introduction has been successfully applied in the analysis of standard reference materials and in the measurement of accurate and precise isotope ratios, and, hence, isotope dilution analysis. The rapid sample throughput possible with FI should allow a four-fold increase in the sampling rate compared with conventional nebufization techniques. Also, the amount of sample consumed per analytical measurement by FI is considerably less than continuous nebufization. TTiese considerations are of particular importance for the cost-effective operation of ICP-MS. 

Some of the methods commonly used for the determination of thorium in biological materials are given in Table 6-1. The colorimetric methods are not capable of isotope-specific determination of thorium isotopes. Alpha spectrometric and neutron activation analysis are useful in the quantification of isotope-specific thorium and thorium-232, respectively, and have better sensitivities than colorimetric methods. Alpha spectrometry is the commonly used isotope-specific analysis for the determination of thorium-232 and the thorium-230 derived from the decay of uranium-238 (Wrenn et al. 1981). Standard reference materials (SRMs) containing thorium in human liver (SRM-4352) and human lung (SRM-4351) necessary for the determination of absolute recovery in a given sample are available from the National Institute of Standards and Technology (Inn 1987). 

The fundamentals and several applications of isotope dilution mass spectrometry requiring accurate isotope ratio measurements are reviewed by Heumann.50,51 Today isotope dilution mass spectrometry (IDMS) is recognized as a primary measurement method, by means of which accurate results with sufficiently small uncertainties can be achieved and therefore it has been used in certifying the composition of reference materials. A requirement of isotope dilution analysis in mass spectrometry is to achieve equilibration of spike and sample so that very careful sample preparation steps, especially in solid mass spectrometry, are necessary when a homogeneous sample spike mixture is to be prepared. 

The certification procedure for seven trace metals (Ba, Ca, Li, Mg, Mn, Na and Sr) in the certified reference material FEBS-1 (National Research Council Canada, Institute for National Measurement Standards, Ottawa, Canada) based on fish otolith matrix by isotope dilution - ICP-MS in comparison to ICP optical emission spectrometry and X-ray fluorescence analysis, is described by Sturgeon et al4X The isotope dilution technique is also employed for species analysis in biological systems,46 e.g., for the determination of mercury species in tuna material,54 or in aquatic systems using cold vapour ICP-MS.55... 

---