Reaction Orders Experimentally

Reaction Order Terminology Determining Reaction Orders Experimentally Determining the Rate Constant... 

How do the following hydrides react with water NaH, CH4, SiH4 and HI Comment on these reactions in terms of the nature of the chemical bonds in these compounds. Suggest reasons for the increase in acidity in the series PH3, HjS, HCl. How would you seek to establish this order experimentally ... 

Experimental tests of this mechanism can determine the reaction order with respect to each component and verify the molecularities assumed, but are unable to separate even the factors k K, let alone measure / and as long as the assumption of pre-equihbrium remains vaUd. Better time resolution in the experiment captures the approach of [i] toward equihbrium and, consequently, violates that assumption. 

Related to the preceding is the classification with respect to oidei. In the power law rate equation / = /cC C, the exponent to which any particular reactant concentration is raised is called the order p or q with respect to that substance, and the sum of the exponents p + q is the order of the reaction. At times the order is identical with the molecularity, but there are many reactions with experimental orders of zero or fractions or negative numbers. Complex reactions may not conform to any power law. Thus, there are reactions of ... 

This ability to reduce the reaction order by maintaining one or more concentrations constant is a veiy valuable experimental tool, for it often permits the simplification of the reaction kinetics. It may even allow a complicated rate equation to be transformed into a simple rate equation. 

The isolation experimental design can be illustrated with the rate equation v = kc%CB, for which we wish to determine the reaction orders a and b. We can set Cb >>> Ca, thus establishing pseudo-oth-order kinetics, and determine a, for example, by use of the integrated rate equations, experimentally following Ca as a function of time. By this technique we isolate reactant A for study. Having determined a, we may reverse the system and isolate B by setting Ca >>> Cb and thus determine b. 

The order of a reaction must be determined experimentally it cannot be deduced from die coefficients in the balanced equation. This must be true because there is only one reaction order, but there are many different ways in which the equation for the reaction can be balanced. For example, although we wrote... 

In the case of stoichiometric reactions the overall order can be readily estimated from the plot of the fraction a of the reactants, remaining at time t, against logm t304,330). For a d 11 order reaction the experimental plot of a vs. logi0t can be superimposed on the dft curve of the following theoretical set of functions ad ... 

If only narrow ranges of conversion are studied it is impossible to discriminate between close values of reaction orders unless very accurate experimental data have been... 

However, in most cases, relation (48) does not account for results obtained under experimental conditions used in industry, i.e. high reactant concentrations. Othmer carried out a detailed study in this field and suggested second-order reactions for the esterifications of n-butanol with acetic acid245 and monobutyl terephthalate246 catalyzed by sulfuric acid. Since such relations cannot be established in all cases, no reaction order could be found for the esterification of 2,3-butanediol with acetic arid247 in the presence of sulfuric add. Moreover, Othmer s reaction orders were obtained for very concentrated media and in our opinion cannot be connected to a mechanism. In fact, this was not Othmer s objective who established these relations for practical use in industrial esterifications. 

Fiery1 252-254) studied only the last stage of the reactions, i.e. when the concentration of reactive end groups has been greatly decreased and when the dielectric properties of the medium (ester or polyester) no longer change with conversion. Under these conditions, he showed that the overall reaction order relative to various model esterifications and polyesterifications is 3. As a general rule, it is accepted that the order with respect to acid is two which means that the add behaves both as reactant and as catalyst. However, the only way to determine experimentally reaction orders with respect to add and alcohol would be to carry out kinetic studies on non-stoichiometric systems. 

Solomon s results13 on the reaction of 1-dodecanol with dodecanoic add in dodecyl dodecanoate and on the completion of the polyesterification of an oligo(l,10-decanediyl adipate) prepared under mild experimental conditions confirm Flory s conclusions (reaction order 3) and invalidate other interpretations of Flory s results. 

Table 3 shows that the activation enthalpies determined by various authors can be very different. These differences cannot be correlated to discrepancies in reaction orders since, even when these are the same, activation energies can vary. Since the theoretical difference between activation enthalpy and activation energy is low (2RT = 3kJ mol"1) with regard to the differences found in experimental determinations, the values discussed below are either enthalpies or energies of activation (For more detailed information see Table 3). 

Reactions between oligomers to-hydroxypolyoxyethylene and experimental data with the established kinetic law230. This is presumably due to the hydrophilicity of polyoxyethylene which retains the reaction water and therefore favours the hydrolysis of the catalyst. Consequently, it is not surprising that only low values of rate constants were obtained. The best fit was found for an overall reaction order close to 2.5. 

Let us now assume that these matters have been attended to properly. At this stage we can but assume that the reaction orders were correctly identified and correct mathematical procedures followed. During the course of the work, the investigator should make the occasional quick calculation to show the values are roughly correct. (Does the rate constant yield the correct half-time ) Also, one should examine the experimental data fits to see that the data really do conform to the selected rate equation. Deviations signal an incorrect rate law or complications, such as secondary reactions. 

Such a model should be as simple as possible, without however missing any of the underlying thermodynamic and physicochemical factors which cause electrochemical promotion. In particular it will be shown that even the use of Langmuir-type adsorption isotherms, appropriately modified due to the application of potential (or equivalently by the presense of promoters) suffice to describe all the experimentally observed rules G1 to G7 as well as practically all other observations regarding electrochemical promotion including the effect of potential on heats of adsorption as well as on kinetics and reaction orders. 

EXAMPLE 13.2 Determining the reaction orders and rate law from experimental data... 

These results have been fit to experimental data obtained for the reaction between a diisocyanate and a trifunctional polyester polyol, catalyzed by dibutyltindilaurate, in our laboratory RIM machine (Figure 2). No phase separation occurs during this reaction. Reaction order, n, activation energy, Ea, and the preexponential factor. A, were taken as adjustable parameters to fit adiabatic temperature rise data. Typical comparison between the experimental and numerical results are shown in Figure 7. The fit is quite satisfactory and gives reasonable values for the fit parameters. Figure 8 shows how fractional conversion of diisocyanate is predicted to vary as a function of time at the centerline and at the mold wall (remember that molecular diffusion has been assumed to be negligible). 

The curves in Figure 7.2 plot the natural variable a t)laQ, versus time. Although this accurately portrays the goodness of fit, there is a classical technique for plotting batch data that is more sensitive to reaction order for irreversible Hth-order reactions. The reaction order is assumed and the experimental data are transformed to one of the following forms ... 

The kinetic parameters associated with the synthesis of norbomene are determined by using the experimental data obtained at elevated temperatures and pressures. The reaction orders with respect to cyclopentadiene and ethylene are estimated to be 0.96 and 0.94, respectively. According to the simulation results, the conversion increases with both temperature and pressure but the selectivity to norbomene decreases due to the formation of DMON. Therefore, the optimal reaction conditions must be selected by considering these features. When a CSTR is used, the appropriate reaction conditions are found to be around 320°C and 1200 psig with 4 1 mole ratio of ethylene to DCPD in the feed stream. Also, it is desirable to have a Pe larger than 50 for a dispersed PFR and keep the residence time low for a PFR with recycle stream. 

Example treats a reaction of this kind. The experimental rate law for the reaction of H2 gas with Br2 gas depends on the square root of the Bf2 concentration, and the reaction also is first order in H2 H2+Br2 2HBr Rate =. "[H2] [Br2] Despite the simple 1 1 stoichiometry of the overall reaction, this experimental rate law cannot be explained by a simple mechanism. For the first step of the mechanism for this reaction to be rate-determining, it would have to include a half-molecule of Bf2. There is no... 

This may be understood more fully by reference to Fig. 11.2. Curve A shows the type of response which would be obtained if the lethal process followed precisely the pattern of a first-order reaction. Some experimental curves do, in fact, follow this pattern quite closely, hence the genesis of the original theory. 

There might be various reasons that lead to finding an apparent instead of the true activation energy. The use of power-law kinetic expressions can be one of the reasons. An apparent fractional reaction order can vary with the concentration, i.e. with conversion, in one experimental run. Depending upon the range of concentrations or, equivalently, conversions, different reaction orders may be observed. As an example, consider the a simple reaction ... 

Based on the experimental data kinetic parameters (reaction orders, activation energies, and preexponential factors) as well as heats of reaction can be estimated. As the kinetic models might not be strictly related to the true reaction mechanism, an optimum found will probably not be the same as the real optimum. Therefore, an iterative procedure, i.e. optimization-model updating-optimization, is used, which lets us approach the real process optimum reasonably well. To provide the initial set of data, two-level factorial design can be used. 

---