Selection positive

If, on the other hand, the encounter pair were an oriented structure, positional selectivity could be retained for a different reason and in a different quantitative sense. Thus, a monosubstituted benzene derivative in which the substituent was sufficiently powerfully activating would react with the electrophile to give three different encounter pairs two of these would more readily proceed to the substitution products than to the starting materials, whilst the third might more readily break up than go to products. In the limit the first two would be giving substitution at the encounter rate and, in the absence of steric effects, products in the statistical ratio whilst the third would not. If we consider particular cases, there is nothing in the rather inadequate data available to discourage the view that, for example, in the cases of toluene or phenol, which in sulphuric acid are nitrated at or near the encounter rate, the... 

In unsaturated molecules electronic effects can be transmitted by mesomerism as well as by inductive effects. As with the latter, the mesomeric properties of a group are described by reference to hydrogen. Groups which release electrons to the unsaturated residue of the molecule are said to exert a +Af effect, whereas groups which attract electrons are said to exert a —Af effect. In aromatic structures the important feature of an M-substituent is that it influences the 0- and p-positions selectively. 

Reactions via organometallic intermediates achieve position selectivity on the basis of prior substitution, for example through halogen-metal e.xchange... 

Aromatic solvents or polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAFI) in water, e.g. can be detected by QCM coated with bulk-imprinted polymer layers. Flere, the interaction sites are not confined to the surface of the sensitive material but are distributed within the entire bulk leading to very appreciable sensor responses. Additionally, these materials show high selectivity aromatic solvents e.g. can be distinguished both by the number of methyl groups on the ring (toluene vs. xylene, etc.) and by their respective position. Selectivity factors in this case reach values of up to 100. 

Other limitations of the reaction are related to the regioselectivity of the aryl radical addition to double bond, which is mainly determined by steric and radical delocalization effects. Thus, methyl vinyl ketone gives the best results, and lower yields are observed when bulky substituents are present in the e-position of the alkene. However, the method represents complete positional selectivity because only the g-adduct radicals give reductive arylation products whereas the a-adduct radicals add to diazonium salts, because of the different nucleophilic character of the alkyl radical adduct. ... 

In this mechanism, a complexation of the electrophile with the 7t-electron system of the aromatic ring is the first step. This species, called the 7t-complex, m or ms not be involved directly in the substitution mechanism. 7t-Complex formation is, in general, rapidly reversible, and in many cases the equilibrium constant is small. The 7t-complex is a donor-acceptor type complex, with the n electrons of the aromatic ring donating electron density to the electrophile. No position selectivity is associated with the 7t-complex. 

Because nitration has been studied for a wide variety of aromatic compounds, it is a useful reaction with which to illustrate the directing effect of substituent groups. Table 10.3 presents some of the data. A variety of reaction conditions are represented, so direct comparison is not always valid, but the trends are nevertheless clear. It is important to remember that other electrophiles, while following the same qualitative trends, show large quantitative differences in position selectivity. 

The position selectivity for electrophilic substitution in the simple five-membered heteroaromatic rings is usually 2 > 3. This reflects the more favorable conjugation in intermediate A than in intermediate B. In structure A the remaining C=C bond can delocalize the positive charge more effectively than in B. Substituents on the ring can easily override this directive influence, however. 

The identification of a specific nitrating species can be approached by comparing selectivity with that of nitration under conditions known to involve the nitronium ion. Examination of part B of Table 10.7 shows that the position selectivity exhibited by acetyl nitrate toward toluene and ethylbenzene is not dramatically different from that observed with nitronium ion. The data for i-propylbenzene suggest a lower ortho para ratio for acetyl nitrate nitrations. This could indicate a larger steric factor for nitration by acetyl nitrate. 

Absolute rate data for Friedel-Crafts reactions are difficult to obtain. The reaction is complicated by sensitivity to moisture and heterogeneity. For this reason, most of the structure-reactivity trends have been developed using competitive methods, rather than by direct measurements. Relative rates are established by allowing the electrophile to compete for an excess of the two reagents. The product ratio establishes the relative reactivity. These studies reveal low substrate and position selectivity. 

Toluene/benzene selectivity decreases in the order X = CH3 > H Cl > NO2, in agreement with the expectation that the least stable (and most reactive) carbocation would be least selective. The reactions also show low position selectivity. 

Table 10.9. Substrate and Position Selectivity in Friedel-Crafts Alkylation Reactions...

A good deal of experimental care is often required to ensure that the product mixture at the end of a Friedel-Crafts reaction is determined by kinetic control. The strong Lewis acid catalysts can catalyze the isomerization of alkylbenzenes, and if isomerization takes place, the product composition is not informative about the position selectivity of electrophilic attack. Isomerization increases the amount of the meta isomer in the case of dialkylbenzenes, because this isomer is thermodynamically the most stable. ... 

One other feature of the data in Table 10.10 is worthy of further comment Notice that alkyl substituted acylium ions exhibit a smaller ortho para ratio than the various arpyl systems. If steric factors were dominating the position selectivity, one would expect the opposite result A possible explanation for this feature of the data could be that the aryl compounds are reacting via free acylium ions, whereas the alkyl systems may involve more bulky acyl chloride-catalyst complexes. 

Because of the limited range of aromatic compounds that react with diazonium ions, selectivity data comparable to those discussed for other electrophilic substitutions are not available. Because diazotization involves a weak electrophile, it would be expected to reveal high substrate and position selectivity. 

The table below gives first-order rate constants for reaction of substituted benzenes with w-nitrobenzenesulfonyl peroxide. From these data, calculate the overall relative reactivity and partial rate factors. Does this reaction fit the pattern of an electrophilic aromatic substitution If so, does the active electrophile exhibit low, moderate, or high substrate and position selectivity ... 

Substitution, addition, and group transfer reactions can occur intramolecularly. Intramolecular substitution reactions that involve hydrogen abstraction have some important synthetic applications, since they permit functionalization of carbon atoms relatively remote from the initial reaction site. ° The preference for a six-membered cyclic transition state in the hydrogen abstraction step imparts position selectivity to the process ... 

Positional Selectivity. Selective attachment of a group by a reaction at only one of several possible locations. Synonymous with "rcgioselectivity. ... 

The low position selectivity in the epoxide opening step of this early synthesis was improved in a later study (Ref. 2). 

Tnflic acid is an excellent catalyst for the nitration of aromatic compounds [.S7]. In a mixture with nitnc acid, it forms the highly electrophilic nitronium inflate, which can be isolated as a white crystalline solid Nitronium inflate is a powerful nitrating reagent in inert organie solvents and in tnflic acid or sulfuric acid. It nitrates benzene, toluene, chlorobenzene, nitrobenzene, m-xylene, and benzotn-fluoride quantitatively in the temperature range of-110 to 30 °C with exeeptionally high positional selectivity [87],... 

As noted in Chapter 18, the enzymes that require nicotinamide coenzymes are stereospecific and transfer hydride to either the pro-i or the pro-S positions selectively. The table (facing page) lists the preferences of several dehydrogenases. 

All these methods demonstrate that the 2-positions of pyridine, pyrimidine, and other azines are the most electron deficient in the ground state. However, considerably greater chemical reactivity toward nucleophiles at the 4-position is often observed in syntheses and is supported by kinetic studies. Electron deficiency in the ground state is related to the ability to stabilize the pair of electrons donated by the nucleophile in the transition state. However, it is not so directly related that it can explain the relative reactivity at different ring-positions. Certain factors which appear to affect positional selectivity are discussed in Section II, B. 

Alteration of positional selectivity will result from built-in solvation of the transition state by an adjacent carboxyl-related function.Aminations will be so affected by carboxyl, carboxylate ion, carboalkoxy and less so by carboxamido groups (cf. Section I,D,2,b, structure 12.) Other substitutions such as alkoxylations can be so affected by carboxamido and amidino groups (cf. Section I,D, 2,b, structure 14). The effect of the cyclic hydrogen-bonded form (63) of 2-carboxamidopyridine on the reactivity of a leaving group is not known. 

It should be noted that positional selectivity is never complete even when a clean reaction gives only one isolated product.Reaction occurs at all positions in proportion to the ratio of the rate constants. The difference between a clean reaction (e.g., rate 9 times that of a competing reaction) and one giving a troublesome mixture can be merely a moderate quantitative increase in one rate (e.g., to a 9 7 rate ratio) or a change in both rates (e.g., to a 3 4 ratio). Work such as that of Kauffmann and Boettcher on heteroarynes illustrates the potential of modern forms of chromatography for determining the true proportion of even very minor products. 

Relative reactivity of ring-positions based on positional selectivity of polychloro-azines must be regarded with caution because of the unequal activating effects of the chlorine substituents on each other. Also, it should be emphasized that one cannot use the positional selectivity in di- and tri-substitutions to assess relative reactivity of different positions. In such substitutions, the reactivity is determined by a complex combination of activating and deactivating effects which are unequal at the ring-positions (cf. Sections II, E, 1, II, E, 2,c, and II,E,2,e). 

Chlorination. Electrophilic chlorination of quinoline (66) in neutral medium showed a positional selectivity order of 3 > 6 > 8. The 5- and 8-positions should be sterically hindered to some extent. Hammett cr+ values predict an order for electrophilic substitution of 5 > 8 = 6 > 3. Treatment with chlorine at 160-190°C converted quinoline into a mixture of 3-chloro-, 3,4-dichloro-, 3,4,6- and 3,4,8-trichloro-, 3,4,6,8-tetrachloro-, and 3,4,6,7,8-pentachloro-quinolines. At lower temperatures ( 100°C) the major product was 3-chloroquinoline, albeit in low yield. The 4-substituted species may have arisen from an addition-elimination or radical process (70JHC171). 

Studies have established that the partition between transition states 3 and 4 depends on the nature of the diol unit bound to boron and on the steric and electronic effects of the a-sub-stituent X23. The data shown below demonstrate that the reactions of2-(l-methyl-2-propenyl)-4,4,5,5-tetramethyl-l,3,2-dioxaborolane proceed with a moderate preference for transition state 3 with the C2 methyl group in an axial position. Selectivity diminishes with 2-(l-methyl-2-propenyl)-l,3,2-dioxaborolane and reverses with dimethyl (l-methyl-2-propenyl)boronale, suggesting that steric interactions (gauche interactions in the case of the tetramethyl-1,3,2-diox-aborolane) between X and the diol unit on boron are capable of destabilizing transition state 4 relative to 3. 

Low substrate selectivity accompanying high positional selectivity was also found in isopropylation of a range of alkyl and halogenobenzenes by /-propyl bromide or propene in nitromethane, tetramethylene sulphone, sulphur dioxide, or carbon disulphide, as indicated by the relative rates in Table 86. The toluene benzene reactivity ratio was measured under a wide range of conditions, and varied with /-propyl bromide (at 25 °C) from 1.41 (aluminium chloride-sulphur... 

Given this behavior (little selectivity in distinguishing between different substrate molecules), the selectivity relationship would predict that positional selectivity should also be very small. However, it is not. For example, under conditions where nitration of p-xylene and 1,2,4-trimethylbenzene takes place at about equal rates, there was no corresponding lack of selectivity at positions within the latter. Though... 

---