Nickel stress corrosion cracking

Ferritic stainless steels have inferior corrosion resistance compared with austenitic grades of equivalent chromium content, because of the absence of nickel. Stress corrosion cracking can occur in strong alkali. 

Stainless steel alloys show exceUent corrosion resistance to HCl gas up to a temperature of 400°C. However, these are normally not recommended for process equipment owing to stress corrosion cracking during periods of cooling and shut down. The corrosion rate of Monel is similar to that of mild steel. Pure (99.6%) nickel and high nickel alloys such as Inconel 600 can be used for operation at temperatures up to 525°C where the corrosion rate is reported to be about 0.08 cm/yr (see Nickel and nickel alloys). 

Duplex stainless steels (ca 4% nickel, 23% chrome) have been identified as having potential appHcation to nitric acid service (75). Because they have a lower nickel and higher chromium content than typical austenitic steels, they provide the ductabdity of austenitic SS and the stress—corrosion cracking resistance of ferritic SS. The higher strength and corrosion resistance of duplex steel offer potential cost advantages as a material of constmction for absorption columns (see CORROSION AND CORROSION CONTROL). 

Many instances of intergranular stress corrosion cracking (IGSCC) of stainless steel and nickel-based alloys have occurred in the reactor water systems of BWRs. IGSCC, first observed in the recirculation piping systems (21) and later in reactor vessel internal components, has been observed primarily in the weld heat-affected zone of Type 304 stainless steel. 

Materials of Construction. GeneraHy, carbon steel is satisfactory as a material of construction when handling propylene, chlorine, HCl, and chlorinated hydrocarbons at low temperatures (below 100°C) in the absence of water. Nickel-based aHoys are chiefly used in the reaction area where resistance to chlorine and HCl at elevated temperatures is required (39). Elastomer-lined equipment, usuaHy PTFE or Kynar, is typicaHy used when water and HCl or chlorine are present together, such as adsorption of HCl in water, since corrosion of most metals is excessive. Stainless steels are to be avoided in locations exposed to inorganic chlorides, as stainless steels can be subject to chloride stress-corrosion cracking. Contact with aluminum should be avoided under aH circumstances because of potential undesirable reactivity problems. 

These alloys have extensive applications in sulfuric acid systems. Because of their increased nickefand molybdenum contents they are more tolerant of chloride-ion contamination than standard stainless steels. The nickel content decreases the risk of stress-corrosion cracking molybdenum improves resistance to crevice corrosion and pitting. 

Steel is the most common constructional material, and is used wherever corrosion rates are acceptable and product contamination by iron pick-up is not important. For processes at low or high pH, where iron pick-up must be avoided or where corrosive species such as dissolved gases are present, stainless steels are often employed. Stainless steels suffer various forms of corrosion, as described in Section 53.5.2. As the corrosivity of the environment increases, the more alloyed grades of stainless steel can be selected. At temperatures in excess of 60°C, in the presence of chloride ions, stress corrosion cracking presents the most serious threat to austenitic stainless steels. Duplex stainless steels, ferritic stainless steels and nickel alloys are very resistant to this form of attack. For more corrosive environments, titanium and ultimately nickel-molybdenum alloys are used. 

Flange face areas experience stagnant conditions. Additionally, some gasket materials, such as asbestos fiber, contain leachable chloride ions. This creates crevice and stress corrosion cracking problems on sealing surfaces. Where necessary, flange faces that are at risk can be overlaid with nickel-based alloys. Alternatively, compressed asbestos fiber gaskets shrouded in PTFE may be used. 

Nickel-chromium alloys can be used in place of austenitic stainless steels where additional corrosion resistance is required. These alloys are still austenitic but are highly resistant to chloride-induced stress corrosion cracking when their nickel content exceeds 40 per cent. 

Plain chromium, ferritic steels are much more resistant and for a time were considered virtually immune to stress-corrosion cracking. It is now known that failure can be caused, especially if the steels contain addition of copper, cobalt or nickel. Even so, resistance is superior to that of the standard austenitics, and ferritics are used where stress-corrosion cracking of the austenitic grades could be a possibility . 

In tests lasting for 14 days, Copson found that the susceptibility of steel to stress-corrosion cracking in hot caustic soda solutions increased with increase in nickel content up to at least 8-5%. Alloys containing 28% and more of nickel did not fail in this period. In boiling 42% magnesium chloride the 9% nickel-iron alloy was the most susceptible of those tested to cracking (Table 3.38). Alloys containing 28 and 42% nickel did not fail within 7 days. 

Table 3.38 Resistance of iron-nickel alloys to stress corrosion cracking in boiling 421 0...

The corrosion rate of nickel in sodium hydroxide is adversely affected by heat transfer by small amounts of oxidisable alkaline sulphur-containing salts, e.g. Na2SOj, NajS Oj, Na S and, at high temperatures, by alkaline oxidising agents, viz. NaClOj and NajOj. In the former circumstance Alloy 600 is more resistant than nickel, but not in the latter. When Alloy 600 is used for service in caustic alkalis, it should be stress relieved after fabrication to minimise the possibility of stress-corrosion cracking. 

As with alloys of other metals, nickel alloys may suffer stress-corrosion cracking in certain corrosive environments, although the number of alloy environment combinations in which nickel alloys have been reported to undergo cracking is relatively small. In addition, intergranular attack due to grain boundary precipitates may be intensified by tensile stress in the metal in certain environments and develop into cracking. Table 4.28 lists the major circumstances in which stress corrosion or stress-assisted corrosion of nickel and its alloys have been recorded in service and also shows the preventive and remedial measures that have been adopted, usually with success, in each case. 

With regard to stress-corrosion cracking in the Ni-Cr-Fe system, including both nickel-base alloys and stainless steels, a vast number of papers has been published. A detailed review of work published before 1969 is available and the authors have since published additional data . 

Fig. 8.2S Long-time constant-load tests demonstrating a distinct stress-corrosion cracking threshold stress in the case of a straight l3Cr martensitic SS as opposed to a nickel-bearing SS...

The fracture mode of stress-corrosion cracks in austenitic stainless steels can be transgranular, intergranular or a mixture of both. One of the earliest environments found to cause problems was solutions containing chlorides or other halides and the data due to Copson (Fig. 8.30) is very informative. The test solution for that data was magnesium chloride at 154°C the alloys contained 18-20alloy with a composition of approximately 18Cr-8Ni has the least resistance to cracking in this environment. 

Fig. 8.30 Effect of nickel content on the susceptibility to stress-corrosion cracking of stainless steel wires containing 18-20% chromium in a magnesium chloride solution boiling at 154°C...

For aggressive conditions it may be advantageous to use one of the many high-nickel alloys available. The high cost of such alloys may be economically beneficial although some of the alloys are subject to stress-corrosion cracking, but in a more restricted range of environments than the lower nickel alloys that they would replace. 

Alloys of high nickel content also have improved chloride stress-corrosion cracking resistance and Incolloy 825 has replaced type 321 stainless steel for steam bellows on some plants. Occasionally cracking of the latter was experienced due to chloride-contaminated steam condensing in the convolutions on shut-down and being re-evaporated at start-up. 

Low-carbon and chromium-nickel steels, certain copper, nickel and aluminium alloys (which are all widely used in marine and offshore engineering) are liable to exhibit stress-corrosion cracking whilst in service in specific environments, where combinations of perhaps relatively modest stress levels in material exposed to environments which are wet, damp or humid, and in the presence of certain gases or ions such as oxygen, chlorides, nitrates, hydroxides, chromates, nitrates, sulphides, sulphates, etc. 

---