Mechanical hypothesis

The real world of Sn reactions is not quite as simple as the discussion has so far suggested. The preceding treatment in terms of two clearly distinct mechanisms, SnI and Sn2, implies that all substitution reactions will follow one or the other of these mechanisms. This is an oversimplification. The strength of the dual mechanism hypothesis and its limitations are revealed by these relative rates of solvolysis of alkyl bromides in 80% ethanol methyl bromide, 2.51 ethyl bromide, 1.00 isopropyl bromide, 1.70 /er/-butyl bromide, 8600. Addition of lyate ions increases the rate for the methyl, ethyl, and isopropyl bromides, whereas the tert-butyl bromide solvolysis rate is unchanged. The reaction with lyate ions is overall second-order for methyl and ethyl, first-order for tert-butyl, and first- or second-order for the isopropyl member, depending upon the concentrations. Similar results are found in other solvents. These data show that the methyl and ethyl bromides solvolyze by the Sn2 mechanism, and tert-butyl bromide by the SnI mech-... 

For acetoacetic ester, the mystery lay in the two rather different forms the "ester" took the so-called enol (hydroxy) form CH3C(OH) = CH-COOC2H5 and the keto (ketone) form CH3COCH2COOC2H5.37 (See fig. 6.) As mentioned briefly in chapter 5, in 1885, Laar at Bonn coined the word "tautomerism" for the behavior of acetoacetic ester, (tautos, the same meros, part), hypothesizing that the phenomenon of two structures in one is due to a continual oscillation of a hydrogen atom between two positions in the molecule, with an accompanying change in the bonds between the atoms. Of course, this hypothesis appears to have been influenced by Kekule s earlier mechanical hypothesis. 

Further work by Cornish and Watt ( ) and Silvernail and Goet-zinger ( ) established the active role played by the presence of water, and these authors concluded that a chemical-mechanical hypothesis would fit the observed data. In the case of ceric oxide polishing of glass, Cornish and Watt suggest the formation of a "CeO-Si" activated complex which permits the rupture of the O-Si-0 bonds by hydrolysis. The complex "CeO-Si" then breaks apart, the hydrated silica is swept away along with alkalis released from the glass surface, and the process repeats. 

It may be best to consider this bacterial-mechanical hypothesis for the formation of laminated aragonitic odids as a precursor to more recent models, where adsorption of organic matter on odid surfaces influences the precipitation of CaC03. 

Fig, 3a and b. Rolling mechanism hypothesis at the surface of ceshm ions in the course of intramolecular cycli-... 

Waksmundzki et al. extensively examined the surface areas and microporosities of imprinted silica surfaces [44]. It was found that although the template itself had little effect on the total surface area, the sizes of the micropores were positively correlated to the size of the template. Subsequent studies on the sorption of template to silicas imprinted with pyridine [45-50], quinoline and acridine [45-47], and 2-picoline, 2,4-lutidine and 2,4,6-collidine [50], combined with thermodynamic studies on the heat of wetting of template or methanol/water sorption [47,51-53], led to the conclusion that these templates were adsorbed as multilayers to the silica. This observation supported the association mechanism hypothesis. The possibility of a footprint mechanism and an association mechanism coexisting in a concentration dependent fashion does not appear to have been considered. 

The indirect mechanism hypothesis is based largely on the observation that linewidths for a variety of systems are within an order of magnitude of each other. The data in Figure 2 shows that there is, however, a clear dependence of linewidth on cluster structure. In any case, we are not convinced that an indirect photodissociation mechanism would lead to a uniform set of linewidths any more than would a direct mechanism. Clearly, more work will be required to understand which of the two pictures is more accurate. 

Methionine and Vitamin E. Combinations of methionine and vitamin E have been found to be antagonistic to selenium toxicity. In one study, selenium concentrations in the liver and kidneys of rats fed selenium-containing diets with methionine and vitamin E were less than the concentrations found in the livers and kidneys of rats fed selenium with either methionine or vitamin E alone (Levander and Morris 1970). The results are compatible with the hypothesis that methionine detoxifies selenium by forming methylated derivatives of selenium that are eliminated in the urine and in expired air (see Section 3.4.4) or that methionine and selenomethionine are in the same pool of amino acids and that by increasing the amount of methionine relative to selenomethionine, the probability of selenomethionine being randomly inserted into proteins during synthesis decreases (Stadtman 1977,1980,1983,1987, 1990). As discussed in Section 3.11, methionine administered as an antidote for acute selenium toxicity in rats was ineffective (Lombeck et al. 1987). This result supports a mechanism of action involving protein synthesis rather than a methylation mechanism hypothesis. 

As described above, L-CPT I contains two hydrophobic transmembrane s ments. The first import mechanism hypothesis which can be formulated is that either of the transmembrane segments could function as a signal anchor sequence. Whether HI and H2 play an equivalent role or only one of them acts as a specific signal anchor sequence still remains to be elucidated. Alternatively, HI or H2 could function as a stop-transfer sequence in cooperation with a matrix-signd sequence which could be ensured by either al, o2 or a3. Thus, further studies will be required to determine whether OMM insertion of L-CPT I follows the signal anchor sequence or stop-transfer model. 

Exposure of blood to various surfaces during in vitro testing and subsequent clotting has produced a contact activation mechanism hypothesis in respect of clotting which has been found to be different from the in vivo tissue factor activation mechanism. It was observed long ago that the clotting of blood is... 

Straightforward references to the reductio ad pristinum statum may be found in Boyle, Excellency of the Mechanical Hypothesis, in Hunter and Davis, Works, vol. 8, p. 113 (mercury and gold) The Sceptical Chymist, in Hunter and Davis, Works, vol. 2, pp. 2 30-2 31 (gold and mercury) Forms and Qualities, in Hunter and Davis, Works, vol. 5, p. S326 (mercury, camphor), pp. 395-398 (camphor). 

L. K. Nash suggested that it was in thinking over the solubility results that Dalton arrived at the chemical atomic theory. Nash discussed in detail the alternative explanations of Roscoe and Harden and of Meldrum, and concluded that the atomic weight table is introduced logically into the solubility paper in order to provide some explanation of the fact, difficult to understand on the mechanical hypothesis, that different gases have different solubilities. The experiments on solubility were begun early in 1803, perhaps in January, but the first mention of atomic weights was on 6 September 1803. 

Scheme 2.8 Mechanism hypothesis concerning the formation of the different products from 1,6-enynes and carbonyl compounds...

Hdjek, P. and Havranek, T. (1978). Mechanizing Hypothesis Formation, Springer, Berlin,... 

First, we must propose a possible mechanism satisfying a certain number of mles (five in total, see sections 9.3.2 to 9.3.6). Once the mechanism hypothesis is proposed, all the consequences including kinetics are drawn. Thereafter, we can come up with complementaty experiments to prove the mechanism incorrect. A mechanism can never be proved correct. We can only prove the opposite, hence discarding a mechanism that would not be consistent with observations. 

---