1,4-Malonate addition, asymmetric

SCHEME 31.30. 1,4-Malonate addition followed by asymmetric protonation of chiral calcium... 

Park and coworkers proposed that mesoporous silica having L-proline could enhance the chiral enhancement in asymmetric catalysis. The use of r-proline as active site would be useful for the asymmetric diethyl malonate addition reaction and asymmetric epoxidation reaction of a,p-unsaturated aldehydes. In addition, the plugged mesoporous sihca as a support certainly allowed the formation of dual mesoporosities. In particular, they can provide confinement effect for better enantiomeric excess in the asymmetric catalysis [63]. 

The chiral center would be installed from either Unear carbamate 15 or branched carbamate 16 via the asymmetric addition of malonate anion to the 7i-allyl Mo complex reported by Trost et al. [11] to afford the branched chiral malonate derivative 17. Decarboxylation of 17 should provide the mono-carboxylic acid 18. Masa-mune homologation with 18 affords our common precursor 14. Linear carbamate 15 was obtained from the corresponding cinnamic acid, and branched 16 was prepared in one pot from the corresponding aldehyde. 

A newly developed asymmetric nucleophilic addition of malonate to 7i-allyl Mo complex was the cornerstone for this preparative campaign. 

When we used asymmetric nucleophilic addition of malonate to the Mo tt-allyl complex in our first delivery, the Mo chemistry was not so clearly understood, and our application would be the first large scale example, to the best of our knowledge. Initially our contributions to Mo chemistry were two-fold (i) replacement of non-commercially available (EtCN)3Mo(CO)3 or (C7H8)Mo(CO)3 by more stable and inexpensive Mo(CO)6 by incorporation of proper pre-activating time (ii) simplified preparation of the chiral ligand. Even after we completed the project, we still had a strong interest in Mo chemistry. 

Although Helmchen et al. showed that asymmetric iridium-catalyzed allylic substitution could be achieved, the scope of the reactions catalyzed by iridium complexes of the PHOX ligands was limited. Thus, they evaluated reactions catalyzed by complexes generated from [lr(COD)Cl]2 and the dimethylamine-derived phosphoramidite monophos (Scheme 8) [45,51]. Although selectivity for the branched isomer from addition of malonate nucleophiles to allylic acetates was excellent, the highest enantiomeric excess obtained was 86%. This enantiomeric excess was obtained from a reaction of racemic branched allylic acetate. The enantiomeric excess was lower when linear allylic acetates were used. This system catalyzed addition of the hthium salts of A-benzyl sulfonamides to aUylic acetates, but the product of the reaction between this reagent and an alkyl-substituted linear aUylic acetate was formed with an enantiomeric excess of 13%. 

At around the same time, other groups further reported the deprotonation-activation of malonates for the asymmetric addition to imines. Various malonates and aromatic V-acyl imines produced high yielding adducts with excellent stereoselectivities [87, 88]. 

Barbas developed this procedure further by introducing an asymmetric three-component Michael reaction that should be applicable to many other conjugate addition reactions. He used a Wittig olefmation to prepare, in situ, an a,P-unsatu-rated ketone that subsequently underwent a conjugate addition with malonates (Scheme 21) [94]. The rate of the conjugate addition process was observed to be considerably faster than the analogous reaction reported by Jprgensen which was attributed to the presence of triphenylphosphine oxide within the reaction mixture. 

A chiral phase transfer catalyst was dissolved in ionic liquid media for the enantioselective Michael reaction of dimethyl malonate with l,3-diphenylprop-2-en-l-one with K2CO3 203). The phase-transfer catalyst was a chiral quininium bromide (Scheme 20). The reaction proceeded rapidly with good yield and good enantioselectivity at room temperature in all three ionic liquids investigated, [BMIM]PF6, [BMIM]BF4 and [BPy]BF4. In the asymmetric Michael addition, the enantioselectivity or the reaction in [BPy]Bp4 was the same as in conventional organic solvents. 

Figure 6.18 Chiral amine 56 and thiourea derivatives (10mol% loading) screened in the asymmetric Michael addition of diethyl malonate to trcms-P-nitrostyrene in toluene.

Scheme 6.56 Typical products of the asymmetric Michael addition of dialkyl malonates to frans-P-nitrostyrenes in the presence of 12.

Scheme 6.61 Mechanistic proposals of the 12-catalyzed asymmetric Michael addition of diethyl malonate to trans-P-nitrostyrene proposed by the Takemoto group (A, B, and C) and initial enolate complex (D) with the ammonium group as additional hydrogen-bond donor initiating an alternative mechanism suggested by Sods, Ptipai, and coworkers.

Dixon et al. screened cinchonine-derived thioureas 117-120 for their performance in the dimethyl malonate Michael addition to tra s-(5-nitrostyrene in dichlo-romethane at room temperature and at -20°C [274]. As shown in Figure 6.38, all candidates revealed comparable activity, but monodentate hydrogen-bond donor 118 exhibited very low asymmetric induction producing the desired Michael... 

Figure 6.40 (Thio)urea catalysts derived from dihydroquinine and dihydroquinidine screening results obtained from the asymmetric Michael addition of dimethyl malonate to frans-p-nitrostyrene.

In the presence of thiourea catalyst 122, the authors converted various (hetero) aromatic and aliphatic trons-P-nitroalkenes with dimethyl malonate to the desired (S)-configured Michael adducts 1-8. The reaction occurred at low 122-loading (2-5 mol%) in toluene at -20 to 20 °C and furnished very good yields (88-95%) and ee values (75-99%) for the respective products (Scheme 6.120). The dependency of the catalytic efficiency and selectivity on both the presence of the (thio) urea functionality and the relative stereochemistry at the key stereogenic centers C8/C9 suggested bifunctional catalysis, that is, a quinuclidine-moiety-assisted generation of the deprotonated malonate nucleophile and its asymmetric addition to the (thio)urea-bound nitroalkene Michael acceptor [279]. 

Scheme 6.120 Michael adducts prepared from the 122-catalyzed asymmetric addition of dimethyl malonate to trans-P-nitroalkenes.

Scheme 6.123 Spectrum of adducts of the 122-catalyzed asymmetric Mannich addition of dimethyl malonate to acylated aldimines.

Scheme 6.126 Mannich adducts obtained from the 121- and 124-catalyzed asymmetric addition of dialkyl malonates to N-Boc aldimines. The product configurations were not determined.

Asymmetric conjugate addition is a powerful method for the construction of ternary stereogenic centers. Erick Carreria of the ETH-Honggerberg, Zurich reports (Organic Lett. 2004,6,2281) the chiral-auxiliary mediated conjugate addition of alkynes to alkylidene malonate derivatives such as 1, to give, after hydrolysis and decarboxylation, the enantiomerically-enriched acid 3. 

Enolase type activity is displayed in the efficient supramolecular catalysis of H/D exchange in malonate and pyruvate bound to macrocyclic polyamines [5.32]. Other processes that have been studied comprise for instance the catalysis of nucleophilic aromatic substitution by macrotricyclic quaternary ammonium receptors of type 21 [5.33], the asymmetric catalysis of Michael additions [5.34], the selective functionalization of doubly bound dicarboxylic acids [5.35] or the activation of reactions on substituted crown ethers by complexed metal ions [5.36]. 

Shibasaki made several improvements in the asymmetric Michael addition reaction using the previously developed BINOL-based (R)-ALB, (R)-6, and (R)-LPB, (R)-7 [1]. The former is prepared from (R)-BINOL, diisobutylaluminum hydride, and butyllithium, while the latter is from (R)-BINOL, La(Oz -Pr)3, and potassium f-butoxide. Only 0.1 mol % of (R)-6 and 0.09 mol % of potassium f-butoxide were needed to catalyze the addition of dimethyl malonate to 2-cy-clohexenone on a kilogram scale in >99% ee, when 4-A molecular sieves were added [15,16]. (R)-6 in the presence of sodium f-butoxide catalyzes the asymmetric 1,4-addition of the Horner-Wadsworth-Emmons reagent [17]. (R)-7 catalyzes the addition of nitromethane to chalcone [18]. Feringa prepared another aluminum complex from BINOL and lithium aluminum hydride and used this in the addition of nitroacetate to methyl vinyl ketone [19]. Later, Shibasaki developed a linked lanthanum reagent (R,R)-8 for the same asymmetric addition, in which two BINOLs were connected at the 3-positions with a 2-oxapropylene... 

---