Limitations of RCMs

Despite the ability of RCMs to give a rapid account of potential separation designs, they are, however, derived from a batch experiment and only have applicability to 

With that said, there is one final aspect of RCMs that needs to be looked at the analysis of topological behavior of profiles in the space surrounding the MET. Of course, this is not a standard practice in distillation design, and the reason for looking at this may not be all that apparent at this stage, but will become clear in subsequent chapters. The next section introduces the necessary theory the application of it will be seen from Chapter 3 onwards. 

---

The synthesis of an epothilone model system via an alternative C9-C10 disconnection was first examined by Danishefsky in 1997. However, extension of this C9-C10 strategy to a fully functionalized epothilone intermediate was not successful, demonstrating the limitations of RCM with the early catalysts A and B [116]. In 2002, Sinha and Sun disclosed the stereoselective total syntheses of epoA (238a) and epoB (238b) by the RCM of epoxy compounds 242 in the presence of catalyst C (Scheme 50) [117]. The reaction furnished an inconsequential mixture of isomers 243 (E/Z 1 1) in high yield. Subsequent selective hydrogenation of the newly formed double bond followed by deprotection led to epothilones A and B. 

Although batch distillation is covered in a subsequent separate section, it is appropriate to consider the application of RCM and DRD to batch distulation at this time. With a conventional batch-rectification column, a charge of starting material is heated and fractionated, with a vapor product removed continuously. The composition of the vapor prodiic t changes continuously and at times drastically as the lighter component(s) are exhausted from the stiU. Between points of drastic change in the vapor composition, a cut is often made. Successive cuts can be removed until the still is nearly diy. The sequence, number, and limiting composition of each cut is dependent on the form of... 

Since the vinylcarbenes la-c and the aryl substituted carbene (pre)catalyst Id, in the first turn of the catalytic cycle, both afford methylidene complex 3 as the propagating species in solution, their application profiles are essentially identical. Differences in the rate of initiation are relevant in polymerization reactions, but are of minor importance for RCM to which this chapter is confined. Moreover, the close relationship between 1 and the ruthenium allenylidene complexes 2 mentioned above suggests that the scope and limitations of these latter catalysts will also be quite similar. Although this aspect merits further investigations, the data compiled in Table 1 clearly support this view. 

Despite comprehensive studies, extension of this C9,C10 strategy to the preparation of a fully functionalized epothilone intermediate proved unattainable, demonstrating limitations of the RCM process [14]. 

Particularly noteworthy examples are Entries 8 and 9 in Table 3.19 these represent a diastereoselective RCM in which the stereoselectivity is controlled by the catalyst [886]. Entries 17, 23 and 24 (Table 3.19) illustrate the use of RCM for the solid-phase synthesis of lactams [894]. RCM induces both ring closure to the lactam and cleavage from the support. Although elegant at first glance, the usefulness of this methodology will be limited if the products must be used without further purification (as is usually the case for compound libraries prepared by parallel synthesis). Because relatively large amounts of catalyst are required, the crude products will only be acceptable for assays in which transition metal complexes do not interfere. 

The upper limit of the impact velocity can be deduced from the fact that rcm < min(<2, a2). For a collision between two spheres of the same diameter dp, Eq. (2.161) yields... 

From the huge number of model studies and synthetic applications realized during the last ten years, it is possible nowadays to delineate the main factors that affect the course of M-RCM. The following section, through convenient examples, illustrates some of the most representative studies that have helped to establish the scope and limitations of the application of RCM to the synthesis of macrocydes. These contributions have made the use of RCM a predictive tool particularly well suited for the closing key step. However, as will be seen later, some complex situations can still occur where the course of the RCM reaction remains unpredictable and continues to require further studies. 

Ring-closing metathesis (RCM) is an important method for construction of medium- and macro-cycle compounds that has been widely used in organic synthesis [43]. For many biologically related substrates, in order to keep their important higher-order structures, application of RCM must be done in aqueous media [53]. In contrast to ROMP, aqueous RCM has many limits in terms... 

A highly convergent, RCM-based approach was explored without success (Scheme 15). Its discussion is included to highlight the limitations of this generally efficient method that has been used recently in numerous... 

In this chapter, the derivation of RCMs from simple batch boiling, as well as the fundamental properties behind RCMs, are discussed. Thereafter, the application of RCMs to continuous processes is explored. However, as will be shown, this application has limitations and these will also be addressed. 

The design equations would include, in addition to the usual heat and mass balances and vapor-liquid equilibria, equations for chemical equilibria and/or reaction kinetics. The occurrence of a chemical reaction can severely restrict the allowable ranges of temperatures and phase compositions by virtue of the additional equations for chemical equilibrium/kinetics. This effect can be quantitatively analyzed by constructing a residue curve map (RCM). It explicitly shows the shifting of distillation boundaries in the presence of reaction and defines the limits of feasible distillation column operation. We illustrate this (Venimadhavan et al., 1994) by considering the reaction... 

In the above conditions, the application of RCM maintenance technique is optimal, since the method is used to determine what it must be done to ensure that a machine or system should continue realizing his duties. Apart from complying with the specifications of SAE JA 1011 norm, in the particular application of limited access facilities it is necessary to carry out the development of maintenance techniques that improve the efficiency of management, finding a strategic work plan, which synthesizes new developments in a coherent model, making possible the evaluation and... 

Nelson DJ, Carboni D, Ashworth IW, Percy JM. Toward a Simulation Approach for Alkene Ring-closing Metathesis Scope and Limitations of a Model for RCM. J Org Chem. 2011 76(20) 8386-8393. 

The principle limitations in RCM arise from three sources steric hindrance, unfavourable molecular conformations and coordination of the ruthenium by a donor atom in the substrate. Steric hindrance around the alkenes can slow down or prevent carbene formation on the substrate. The introduction of newer,... 

RCM has been extensively utilized to access macrocyclic natural products, the stereoselectivity of which, however, represented a significant limitation of this methodology. In most cases the low energy difference between the alkene isomers resulted in a mixture of two products in low ratios. The reported chemical syntheses of the anti-cancer dmg epothilones from a few research groups, for example, all relied on RCM as a key step and the macrocyclic intermediates were only generated in a Z ratio ranging from 1 2 to <2 1 [66,67] (see [30] for the alternative alkyne metathesis/Lindlar reduction sequence by the Fiirstner group). 

In related studies, Lobbel and Koll utilized this approach in the construction of C2 -symmetrical carbon-hnked disaccharides [16]. A critical feature of this approach was the relatively poor efficiency of the RCM, which served to highlight the limitations of the first-generation catalyst [Ruj-I for challenging synthetic applications. Mioskowski et al. later demonstrated that [Ruj-VI provided a more efficient catalyst... 

---