Kinetic studies alternative substrates

It is quite reasonable to expect the bimolecular two-stage mechanism Sj Ar ) to predominate in most aromatic nucleophilic substitutions of activated substrates. However, only in rare instances is there adequate evidence to rule out the simultaneous occurrence or predominance of other mechanisms. The true significance of the alternative mechanisms in azines needs to be determined by trapping the intermediates or by applying modem separation and characterization methods to the identification of at least the major portion of the products, especially in kinetic studies. 

MULTISUBSTRATE SYSTEMS. Wong and Hanes were probably among the first to suggest that alternative substrates may be useful in mechanistic studies. Fromm s laboratory was the first to use and extend the theory of alternative substrate inhibition to address specific questions about multisubstrate enzyme kinetic mechanisms. Huang demonstrated the advantages of a constant ratio approach when dealing with alternative substrate kinetics. 

There are three basic methods for carrying out alternative substrate inhibition studies. In the first, the investigator seeks to observe numerical changes in the coefficients of the double-reciprocal form of the enzyme rate expression in the presence and absence of the alternative substrate. For some mechanisms, only certain coefficients will be altered. This method requires extremely accurate estimates of the magnitudes of the coefficients and should always be supplemented with other kinetic probes . 

Hexokinase provides another example of the stereochemical inferences that can be drawn on the basis of kinetic studies with alternative substrates and competi-... 

NMR and kinetic studies have been conducted with the hope of providing more details about the position and conformation of the polypeptide substrate in cAMP-dependent protein kinase. These have served to narrow down the possible spatial relationships between enzyme bound ATP and the phosphorylated serine. Thus, a picture of the active site that is consistent with the available data can be drawn (12,13,66,67). Although these studies have been largely successful at eliminating some classes of secondary polypeptide structure such as oi-hellces, 6-sheets or an obligatory 6-turn conformation 66), the precise conformation of the substrate is still not known. The data are consistent with a preference for certain 6-turn structures directly Involving the phosphorylated serine residue. However, they are also consistent with a preference or requirement for either a coil structure or some nonspecific type of secondary structure. Models of the ternary active-site complexes based on both the coil and the, turn conformations of one alternate peptide substrate have" been constructed (12). These two models are consistent with the available kinetic and NMR data. 

These were differently affected by different procedures. For example, when the enzyme was activated at 55°, the increment in ki was slight, but k2 increased 3.5-fold. Similarly, in the presence of EDTA, fc, and k2 values decreased independently, suggesting that the sites for both activities were different. Center and Behai (5) found that with the P. mirabilis enzyme, cyclic 2, 3 -UMP competitively inhibited the hydrolysis of bis(p-nitrophenyl) phosphate. The Ki was 40 pAf very close to the Km for the cyclic nucleotide (Km, 75 yM) which indicated that the two compounds could serve as alternate substrates being hydrolyzed at the same active site. In contrast, 3 -AMP was a mixed inhibitor of cyclic 2, 3 -UMP and bis(p-nitrophenyl) phosphate hydrolysis. Adenosine was a mixed inhibitor of bis(p-nitrophenyl) phosphate hydrolysis but a competitive inhibitor of 3 -AMP hydrolysis. From such kinetic studies Center and Behai (5) suggested that two separate and adjacent sites A and B are involved in the hydrolysis of the diester and phos-phomonoester substrates. Site A serves as a binding site for hydrolysis of ribonucleoside 2, 3 -cyclic phosphates and together with site B catalyzes the hydrolysis of the diester bond. During this reaction 3 -... 

Coates and coworkers have carried out kinetic studies of the alternating copolymerization of CHO and C02 catalyzed by several of the P-diiminate zinc derivatives [29]. These authors have proposed a bimetallic mechanism to be operative, which is consistent with their experimental observations, including the large differences in activity noted for a series of structurally closely related catalysts. It was proposed that one zinc center would coordinate and activate the epoxide substrate, while the second zinc center would provide the propagating carbonate species to ring-open the epoxide. This proposal is represented by the transition state depicted in Figure 8.3a. 

The hydrogenation of adiponitrile has additional complications in some kinetic studies 6-aminohexanonitrile was detected in solution and is considered a reaction intermediate (Figure 9). Alternatively, it may be a by-product if the hydrogenation is incomplete. Furthermore, the addition of the amines to the imine intermediates leads to an increased number of possible by-products, including cyclic compounds, due to the bifunctional character of the substrate. 

General base catalysis by formate, acetate, imidazole, phosphate, and methoxyamine is also observed in the hydrolysis of ethyl trifluorothiol-acetate the Bronsted exponent j8 is 0 33. In acetate buffers a careful kinetic study demonstrated inhibition by acetic acid. Therefore, the acetate reaction also involves a tetrahedral intermediate according to scheme C. No complex formation of the substrate with acetic acid, which could alternatively cause inhibition, could be found. Scheme C accounts for the acetate catalysis and inhibition by acetic acid. In scheme C, a general base mechanism is written, the same mechanism which unequivocally applies to the water reaction. 

Kinetic studies with calcineurin yielded a modest solvent isotope effect of 1.35, and a proton inventory and fractionation factor data that were most consistent with a mechanism involving a single proton transfer from a water molecule coordinated to a metal ion.136 No transphosphorylation products were found in the presence of alternate nucleophiles, consistent with direct phosphoryl transfer to a metal-coordinated water.137 No calcineurin-catalyzed oxygen exchange of 180 labeled water with phosphate could be detected.138 In a study using / NPP as the substrate, product inhibition studies found that both phosphate and p-nitrophenol are... 

The alternative approach to examine heterogeneous electron transfer kinetics on the substrate is to hold the tip at a potential where the reaction is mass transfer controlled and study the approach curve as a function of substrate potential. For example, one can generate iron(II) by reduction of iron(III) at the tip and study the oxidation of iron(II) at the substrate. One... 

Any fast reaction that follows a slow reaction will occur at the rate of the slow reaction. Consider the formation of an enzyme intermediate according to Scheme XVIII. This enzyme-bound intermediate (E l) will be invisible kinetically and thermodynamically if A3 ki and k-2 A 3. Thus, one can only define the kinetically significant intermediates or conformational states. Transition states or extremely reactive intermediates cannot be directly observed their presence can only be inferred by knowledge of the chemistry of the reaction. Alternatively, the use of alternate substrates or analogs has provided evidence for an intermediate by slowing the rate of the second step. For example, in studies on chymo-... 

Initial rate measurements, especially with alternative substrates and with a product or substrate analog as inhibitor, and measurements of the rate of isotope exchange at equilibrium, can give a great deal of information about mechanism, and in some cases allow estimates of individual velocity constants and dissociation constants. The results of such studies, which require little enzyme, are an essential basis for the proper interpretation, in relation to the overall catalytic reaction, of pre-steady-state studies and kinetic and thermodynamic studies of enzyme-coenzyme reactions in isolation. 

Comparisons of the kinetic coefficients in Eq. (1) obtained from initial rate measurements with alternative substrates have given a considerable amount of information about reaction pathways as well as indications of the molecular basis of specificity (60). This approach, much used for proteolytic enzymes, has been exploited particularly with the alcohol dehydrogenases, which catalyze the oxidation of a variety of primary and secondary alcohols (61). While several other dehydrogenases have been studied in this way, most of the results have been reported only as apparent maximum rates and apparent Km values for the alternative substrate, which restricts the amount of information that can be derived. 

---