Experimental physical chemistry emphasizing

A recent book on physical chemistry,5 written by a scientist6 and aimed primarily at other scientists, contains substantial historical information on the beginnings of physical chemistry and on various topics, such as chemical spectroscopy, electrochemistry, chemical kinetics, colloid and surface chemistry, and quantum chemistry. The book also discusses more general topics, such as the development of the physical sciences and the role of scientific journals in scientific communication. The same author has written a brief account of the development of physical chemistry after 1937,7 emphasizing the application of quantum theory and the invention of new experimental methods stopped-flow techniques (1940), nuclear magnetic resonance... 

It has already been emphasized that safe laboratory procedures require thoughtful awareness on the part of both students and instractors. This is especially important in the planning and execution of special projects, where new procedures need to be developed and often modified as the work progresses. Appendix C on safety hazards and safety equipment should be read before beginning a course of experimental work in physical chemistry and reviewed carefully before beginning any special project. 

We wish also to emphasize the benefit we have derived from the close relationship which has been established between our group of workers and that of the Physical Chemistry Laboratory of the University of Brussels directed by Professor Timmermans, and which has enabled us to maintain close contact with experimental work in the field of the thermod3uiamics of solutions. 

The analysis of such inhibition curves has been based on the implied assumption that these metal chelate complexes (E. L. Smith and Hanson, 1949) are analogous to those observed in simple systems (Martell and Calvin, 1952), an assumption for which little experimental justification exists. It should be emphasized that a metalloenzyme inhibited by binding of a chelating agent to a metal in situ represents a mixed complex, consisting of two different ligands combined with one metal. Studies of the physical chemistry of simple complexes of this type are as yet few (Klotz and Loh-Ming, 1954 de Witt and Watters, 1954). The data on mixed complexes available to date are apparently not adequate to justify extrapolations to the interpretation of inhibition of metalloenzymes (Coryell, 1955, personal communication). 

As a concluding remark, it has to be emphasized that every acceptable retention theory must be consistent with fundamental physics, as well as describe experimental findings. The complex multiplicity of phenomena involved in an IIC system requires a complex description of the thermodynamics solutes have undergone this description is epistemologically acceptable if the model is well founded in physical chemistry and if it is able to describe experimental data better than previous models. 

The elucidation of reaction mechanisms is a central topic in organic chemistry that led to many elegant studies emphasizing the interplay of theory and experiment as demonstrated, for example, by the seminal contributions of the Houk group to the understanding of the Diels-Alder and other pericyclic reactions.38 This reaction class is rather typical for the elucidation of reaction mechanisms. On the experimental side, the toolbox of solvent, substituent and isotope effect studies as well as stereochemical probes have been used extensively, while the reactants, products, intermediates and transition structures involved have been calculated at all feasible levels of theory. As a result, these reactions often serve as a success story in physical organic chemistry. 

The laboratory has been identified as a distinct domain here to emphasize a point. In some cases, behavior of the system in the test tube or the Petri dish (in vitro) closely simulates the behavior of a pond or a forest ecosystem (in vivo). For many systems, however, care must be taken in extrapolating from the laboratory environment to the natural environment. The difference in scale of the mixing processes for the two systems and the presence of interspecies effects in the natural environment are but two factors that may be significant. This is not to say that the whole is not the sum of its parts, but simply to provide a cautionary note for the reader that it is important to recognize all of the parts and then to form the proper sum. The laboratory must be included in a description of how we go about studying natural systems for the simple reason that much experimental work of the natural sciences (biology, chemistry, and physics) occurs in the laboratory. 

Chemistry is an experimental science, and primarily lives in the laboratory. No book on spreadsheets will change that. However, many aspects of chemical analysis have significant quantitative, mathematical components, and many of these can be illustrated effectively using spreadsheets. At the same time, the spreadsheet is a very accessible tool for data analysis, an activity common to all of the physical sciences. This book emphasizes the use of spreadsheets in data analysis, while at the same time illustrating some of the underlying principles. The basic strength of spreadsheets was summarized by the name of the very first spreadsheet, VisiCalc, in that it facilitates the visualization of calculations, and thereby can help to make theory and data analysis come to life. 

Inevitably, such discussions lead to the non-classical ion problem. Few subjects have generated as much experimental and computational effort—as well as debate, controversy, and animosity—as the non-classical ion problem. At one time it appeared that almost all of physical organic chemistry was focused on this single issue, and many have argued that this intensity, bordering on obsession, was ultimately detrimental to physical organic chemistry. With the benefit of hindsight, we can put this era into perspective and emphasize the positive outcomes of the diverse efforts to address the problem. 

---