Cyclopropanes from metal-catalyzed decomposition

Whereas metal-catalyzed decomposition of simple diazoketones in the presence of ketene acetals yields dihydrofurans 121,124,134), cyclopropanes usually result from reaction with enol ethers, enol acetates and silyl enol ethers, just as with unactivated alkenes 13). l-Acyl-2-alkoxycyclopropanes were thus obtained by copper-catalyzed reactions between diazoacetone and enol ethers 79 105,135), enol acetates 79,135 and... 

As it is known from experience that the metal carbenes operating in most catalyzed reactions of diazo compounds are electrophilic species, it comes as no surprise that only a few examples of efficient catalyzed cyclopropanation of electron-poor alkeiies exist. One of those examples is the copper-catalyzed cyclopropanation of methyl vinyl ketone with ethyl diazoacetate 140), contrasting with the 2-pyrazoline formation in the purely thermal reaction (for failures to obtain cyclopropanes by copper-catalyzed decomposition of diazoesters, see Table VIII in Ref. 6). 

Oxa-l -silabicyclo[ . 1,0 alkanes (n = 3 111 n = 4 113) were the only products isolated from the photochemical, thermal or transition-metal catalyzed decomposition of (alkenyloxysilyl)diazoacetates 110 and 112, respectively (equation 28)62. The results indicate that intramolecular cyclopropanation is possible via both a carbene and a carbenoid pathway. The efficiency of this transformation depends on the particular system and on the mode of decomposition, but the copper triflate catalyzed reaction is always more efficient than the photochemical route. For the thermally induced cyclopropanation 112 —> 113, a two-step noncarbene pathway at the high reaction temperature appears as an alternative, namely intramolecular cycloaddition of the diazo dipole to the olefinic bond followed by extrusion of N2 from the pyrazoline intermediate. A direct hint to this reaction mode is the formation of 3-methoxycarbonyl-4-methyl-l-oxa-2-sila-3-cyclopentenes instead of cyclopropanes 111 in the thermolysis of 110. 

Depending on the mode of generation, a carbene may be initially formed in either the singlet or triplet state, irrespective of its stability. Common methods used for the generation of carbenes include photolytic, thermal, or metal catalyzed decomposition of diazocompounds, elimination of halogenfrom gem-dihalides, elimination of Hx from CHX3, decomposition of ketenes, thermolysis of a-halo-mercury compounds and cycloelimination of shelf stable substrates such as cyclopropanes, epoxides, aziridines and diazirines. 

All of these carbenes are reactive intermediates that must be generated from the appropriate precursors in the presence of the alkene (or arene) which is to be cyclopropanated. The following methods of carbene-transfer reactions to C-C double bonds will be discussed path a. from a-halo-a-metal (or alkylmetal) compounds by a-elimination path b. from iodine or sulfur ylides by thermal, photochemical or transition metal catalyzed decomposition ... 

Although the addition of carbene to a double bond to make a cyclopropane is well known, it is not particularly useful synthetically because of the tendency for extensive side reactions and lack of selectivity for thermally or photochemically generated carbenes. Similar processes involving carbenoids (species that are not free carbenes) are much more useful from the preparative standpoint [91,92]. For example, metal catalyzed decomposition of diazoalkanes usually results in addition to double bonds without the interference of side reactions such as C-H insertions. Consider the possible retrosynthetic approaches to a 1,2-disubstituted cyclopropane shown in Figure 6.8. Disconnection a entails the addition of a methylene across a double bond, a conversion that is often stereospecific e.g., the Simmons-Smith reaction [93]). Disconnections b and c are more problematic, since the issue of cis/trans product isomers (simple diastereoselection) arises. 

The transition metal-catalyzed decomposition of a-cabonyl diazo compounds is a very important synthetic method, as has been reviewed [98]. Cu and Rh catalytic systems have been proved very effective for this process. From the perspective of synthetic and process chemists, such metal carbenes can undergo three major types of reactions cyclopropanation with alkenes, addition to an unsaturated C—C bond, and the formation of ylide, which have been the source of fruitful cascades. 

Aziridines have been synthesized, albeit in low yield, by copper-catalyzed decomposition of ethyl diazoacetate in the presence of an inline 260). It seems that such a carbenoid cyclopropanation reaction has not been realized with other diazo compounds. The recently described preparation of 1,2,3-trisubstituted aziridines by reaction of phenyldiazomethane with N-alkyl aldimines or ketimines in the presence of zinc iodide 261 > most certainly does not proceed through carbenoid intermediates rather, the metal salt serves to activate the imine to nucleophilic attack from the diazo carbon. Replacement of Znl2 by one of the traditional copper catalysts resulted in formation of imidazoline derivatives via an intermediate azomethine ylide261). 

Chiral rhodium(II) oxazolidinones 5-7 were not as effective as Rh2(MEPY)4 for enantioseleetive intramolecular cyclopropanation, even though the sterie bulk of their chiral ligand attachments (COOMe versus /-Pr or C Ph) are similar. Significantly lower yields and lower enantiomeric excesses resulted from the decomposition of 11 catalyzed by either Rh2(4S-IPOX)4, Rh2(4S-BNOX)4, or Rh2(4R-BNOX)4 (Table 3). In addition, butenolide 12, the product from carbenium ion addition of the rhodium-stabilized carbenoid to the double bond followed by 1,2-hydrogen migration and dissociation of RI12L4 (Scheme II), was of considerable importance in reactions performed with 5-7 but was only a minor constituent ( 1%) from reactions catalyzed by Rh2(5S-MEPY)4. This difference can be attributed to the ability of the carboxylate substituents to stabilize the earboeation form of the intermediate metal carbene. 

Certain transition metal complexes catalyze the decomposition of diazo compounds. The metal-bonded carbene intermediates behave differently from the free species generated via photolysis or thermolysis of the corresponding carbene precursor. The first catalytic asymmetric cyclopropanation reaction was reported in 1966 when Nozaki et al.93 showed that the cyclopropane compound trans- 182 was obtained as the major product from the cyclopropanation of styrene with diazoacetate with an ee value of 6% (Scheme 5-56). This reaction was effected by a copper(II) complex 181 that bears a salicyladimine ligand. 

New evidence as to the nature of the intermediates in catalytic diazoalkane decomposition comes from a comparison of olefin cyclopropanation with the electrophilic metal carbene complex (CO)jW—CHPh on one hand and Rh COAc) / NjCHCOOEt or Rh2(OAc)4 /NjCHPh on the other . For the same set of monosubstituted alkenes, a linear log-log relationship between the relative reactivities for the stoichiometric reaction with (CO)5W=CHPh and the catalytic reaction with RhjfOAc) was found (reactivity difference of 2.2 10 in the former case and 14 in the latter). No such correlation holds for di- and trisubstituted olefins, which has been attributed to steric and/or electronic differences in olefin interaction with the reactive electrophile . A linear relationship was also found between the relative reactivities of (CO)jW=CHPh and Rh2(OAc) NjCHPh. These results lead to the conclusion that the intermediates in the Rh(II)-catalyzed reaction are very similar to stable electrophilic carbenes in terms of electron demand. As far as cisjtrans stereoselectivity of cyclopropanation is concerned, no obvious relationship between Rh2(OAc) /N2CHCOOEt and Rh2(OAc),/N2CHPh was found, but the log-log plot displays an excellent linear relationship between (CO)jW=CHPh and Rh2(OAc) / N2CHPh, including mono-, 1,1-di-, 1,2-di- and trisubstituted alkenes In the phenyl-carbene transfer reactions, cis- syn-) cyclopropanes are formed preferentially, whereas trans- anti-) cyclopropanes dominate when the diazoester is involved. 

---