Confirmatory studies

As a starting point, the objectives of each individual study should be clearly defined. Studies can be broadly divided into two types (i) confirmatory studies which set out to prove or disprove predefined hypotheses on the basis of measuring defined variables... 

A few ex vivo and in vivo studies have been published claiming an antigene (and antisense) effect of mixed purine/pyrimidine sequence PNA [48, 49, 78-80]. However, as pointed out by us in recent reviews [81, 82] these studies lack fundamental controls such as the inclusion of relevant internal standards as a control for sequence-specific non-antigene/antisense effects, thus confirmatory studies are warranted. The in vivo antigene studies from Richelsoris group [79, 83] completely lack a rational basis for the claimed effects. First of all there is no evidence that... 

Additional agents, including selenium, folic acid, and HMG-CoA reductase inhibitors (statins), show promise as chemopreventive agents in colon cancer, and preliminary and confirmatory studies evaluating their effectiveness have been completed or are ongoing, although none of these agents have been approved for the prevention of colon cancer.46... 

Therapeutic exploratory (Phase lb/II) Explore use for the targeted indication Estimate dosage for subsequent studies Provide basis for confirmatory study design, endpoints, methodologies Earliest trials of relatively short duration in well-defined narrow patient populations, using surrogate or pharmacological endpoints or clinical measures Dose-response exploration studies... 

Only seven published studies exist regarding the effects of a small number of antidepressants on computerized sleep EEG patterns [Jarrett et al. 1988 Kupfer et al. 1991, 1994 Minot et al. 1993). In these studies, only 118 total patients were included, and no confirmatory study was done for any of the drugs. Moreover, the length of the drug administration period varied from 1 day (Jarrett et al. 1988] to 3 years (Kupfer et al. 1994], and the method of computerized analysis was not uniform some studies used period analysis (Jarrett et al. 1988 Kupfer et al. 1991], others used fast Fourier transform (Minot et al. 1993 van Bemmel et al. 1992b, 1993b], and some others used both period analysis and fast Fourier transform (Kupfer et al. 1994). 

The classic studies by Challenger (127-129) on microbial methyla-tion of arsenic still provide the basis of our understanding of these processes. Although Challenger s work focused on mycological methyla-tions (he mistakenly believed that bacteria did not methylate arsenic), the scheme he proposed is applicable to other biological systems as well. It is briefly discussed here, together with the confirmatory studies of Cullen and co-workers. 

Simple reporting of numeric results is not appropriate because most physicians are not familiar with pattern recognition. A comprehensive interpretation takes into consideration any available clinical and dietary information and other laboratory results, provides possible differential diagnoses, recommendations for additional biochemical testing and confirmatory studies if indicated, as well as contact information for the laboratory director in case the referring physician has additional questions. 

It should be remembered that photodegradation products formed under stress conditions (i.e., potential photodegradation products) may not always be observed under confirmatory conditions. Such differences may be exacerbated by the use of different photon sources [i.e., ICH Option 1 vs. Option 2 (48)] for stress testing and confirmatory studies, and therefore it may be prudent to use the same source for both studies to avoid confusion. 

Confirmatory studies In addition to consistency of Arrhenius predictions with observed room temperature data, it may be desirable to confirm that the relative stability results for samples compared under the chosen stress conditions are consistent with the relative stability for the same samples at room temperature. This provides another degree of validation that the stress conditions will provide results predictive of real differences observed at lower temperatures over a longer period of time. Since the room temperature data will take longer to obtain, this type of confirmation may be obtained at a later time after initial stress comparison studies are well over. The room temperature data may be generated for regulatory purposes and should be compared to the initial stress study predictions. 

As mentioned in the Introduction, ICH describes two kinds of tests for drug photostability determination (1) forced degradation studies and (2) confirmatory studies . ICH describes two options for light sources for use in confirmatory studies (1). 

For confirmatory studies, samples should be exposed to light providing an overall illumination of not less than 1.2 million lux hours and an integrated near-ultraviolet energy of not less than 200 W hr/square meter. 

End of phase II—held to review planning and ensure well-designed confirmatory studies that will most efficiently confirm a drug s effectiveness and also determine what additional information will be necessary to demonstrate the safety and efficacy of the product for the intended claim. 

Formulation. An application for a proposed drug product that contains a different quality or quantity of an excipient(s) than the listed drug where the studies required for approval are beyond those considered limited confirmatory studies appropriate to a 505(j) application. 

Human pharmacology and therapeutic exploratory studies define the most likely safe and effective dosage regimens for use in subsequent therapeutic confirmatory studies. These therapeutic confirmatory studies are typically run as double-blind, randomized, concurrently controlled clinical trials. 

---