Complex stability donor atoms

In aqueous solutions at pH 7, there is little evidence of complex formation between [MesSnflV)] and Gly. Potentiometric determination of the formation constants for L-Cys, DL-Ala, and L-His with the same cation indicates that L-Cys binds more strongly than other two amino acids (pKi ca. 10,6, or 5, respectively). Equilibrium and spectroscopic studies on L-Cys and its derivatives (S-methyl-cystein (S-Me-Cys), N-Ac-Cys) and the [Et2Sn(IV)] system showed that these ligands coordinate the metal ion via carboxylic O and the thiolic 5 donor atoms in acidic media. In the case of S-Me-Cys, the formation of a protonated complex MLH was also detected, due to the stabilizing effect of additional thioether coordination. ... 

Since most Ni1 species with simple N-donor ligands are prone to disproportionation into Ni° and Ni11, relatively few Ni1 complexes with nonmacrocyclic N-donor ligands have been reported. Formation of Ni1 species is in most cases proposed on the basis of electrochemical data, although ligand-centered redox processes have to be considered. The ligands usually contain imine donor atoms or aromatic N-heterocycles, which because of their 7r-acceptor ability favor stabilization of lower oxidation states. 

A review11 with 123 references is given on amino acid bonding preferences in complexes of platinum and palladium. The preferences for a particular donor atom for Pd11 depends primarily on relative thermodynamic stabilities of the complexes formed. Sizes of potential chelate rings often play a crucial role in determining donor atom preferences. 

The above account of selectivity of inorganic plus organic chemistry in synthesis is given rather extensively to stress three points. All the four (Mg, Fe, Co and Ni) porphyrin products came from one source, the synthesis of uroporphyrin. The basis of selection is very different from that in primitive centres which use thermodynamic stability constant selectivity based on different donor atoms for different metal ions. Here, all ion complexes have the same donor atoms, nitrogen, the most constrained being the coordination of Mg2+ by five nitrogens exactly as is seen for Fe in haemoglobin. Hence, there also has to be a new control feedback to ensure that the appropriate quantities of each metal cofactor is produced in a balanced way, that is synthesis from uroporphyrin has to be divided based upon... 

As we have seen, the Lewis theory of acid-base interactions based on electron pair donation and acceptance applies to many types of species. As a result, the electronic theory of acids and bases pervades the whole of chemistry. Because the formation of metal complexes represents one type of Lewis acid-base interaction, it was in that area that evidence of the principle that species of similar electronic character interact best was first noted. As early as the 1950s, Ahrland, Chatt, and Davies had classified metals as belonging to class A if they formed more stable complexes with the first element in the periodic group or to class B if they formed more stable complexes with the heavier elements in that group. This means that metals are classified as A or B based on the electronic character of the donor atom they prefer to bond to. The donor strength of the ligands is determined by the stability of the complexes they form with metals. This behavior is summarized in the following table. 

Although the subject of stability of complexes will be discussed in greater detail in Chapter 19 it is appropriate to note here some of the general characteristics of the metal-ligand bond. One of the most relevant principles in this consideration is the hard-soft interaction principle. Metal-ligand bonds are acid-base interactions in the Lewis sense, so the principles discussed in Sections 9.6 and 9.8 apply to these interactions. Soft electron donors in which the donor atom is sulfur or phosphorus form more stable complexes with soft metal ions such as Pt2+ or Ag+, or with metal atoms. Hard electron donors such as H20, NH3( or F generally form stable complexes with hard metal ions like Cr3+ or Co3+. 

---