Comparison of Experiment and Theory

In Fig. 12.3, the relaxation modulus of a nearly monodisperse polystyrene of Mui = 4.22 X 10 (F40) at the step shear strain A = 5 is compared with that in the linear region (A = 0.2), both being measured at the same temperature. In the nonlinear relaxation modulus, as expected from Eq. (12.28), two distinctive relaxation processes are visible in addition to the terminal relaxation, a faster process occurs in the time region corresponding to the plateau in the linear G t). The linear and nonlinear relaxation curves are superposable in the terminal region as one of the two curves is allowed to shift along the modulus axis (as explained below, a small shift toward the 

In making the superposition of two relaxation-modulus curves in the terminal region, the shift factor along the modulus axis defined by 

The nonlinear relaxation modulus as shown in Fig. 12.3 contains two distinctive relaxation processes. It is both interesting and important to see how well the relative positions of the two relaxation processes are described by Eq. (12.28) together with Eqs. (9.11), (9.12), (12.22) and (12.25). In Figs. 12.4-12.7, we compare the measured relaxation moduli at A = 3 and 5 with those calculated from Eq. (12.28) for two nearly monodisperse polystyrene samples F40 and F80 = 7.75 x 10 ). The molecular-weight distribu- 

Finally, we shall mention the slip-stick melt fracture phenomenon — a phenomenon often observed in polymer extrusion — which is much related to the relative positions of the /Ltg(t, E) and pcit) processes. The phenomenon is a well-known problem in the polymer processing industry because it limits the output of polymer through an extruder. In a capillary flow, the decline of the viscosity observed as the shear rate (or flow rate) increases from the Newtonian region is much related to the damping factor 

Number of Entanglement Strands per Cubed Entanglement Distance, rit 

---

P. Attard, J. L. Parker. Oscillatory solvation forces A comparison of theory and experiment. J Phys Chem 9(5 5086-5093, 1992. 

Roth, CM Lenhoff, AM, Electrostatic and van der Waals Contributions to Protein Adsorption Comparison of Theory and Experiment, Langmuir 11, 3500, 1995. 

For some of the comparison of theory and experiment it is necessary to be specihc about the molecular length scale a (a very detailed discussion of this quantity can be found in Ref. [47]). The molecular scale denotes the lattice... 

Figure 15 Comparison of theory and experiment for the fractionation of oligoade-nylates on ion exchange materials, (a) Simulated chromatogram, (b) Observed chromatogram. An example of how theory is being used to attempt to optimize performance of ion exchange materials. The curve in (a) shows the nonlinear gradient development with a convex curvature. (Reproduced with permission of Elsevier Science from Baba, Y., Fukuda, M., and Yoza, N., J. Chromatogr., 458, 385, 1988.)...

Fig. 21. Comparison of theory and experiment for the thermal rate constant of the H+H2O — H2+OH reaction and the calculated contributions from individual vibrational states of H2O.

Figure 3.8 Comparison of theory and experiments (water-air horizontal flow at 25°C and 1 atm pressure with diameter of 2.5 cm). Solid lines theory. (From Dukler, 1978. Copyright 1978 by National Council of Canada. Reprinted with permission.) Fuzzy lines experimental data. (From Mand-hane et al., 1974. Copyright 1974 by Elsevier Science Ltd., Kidlington, UK. Reprinted with permission.)...

We should remember (1) that the activation energy of eh reactions is nearly constant at 3.5 0.5 Kcal/mole, although the rate of reaction varies by more than ten orders of magnitude and (2) that all eh reactions are exothermic. To some extent, other solvated electron reactions behave similarly. The theory of solvated electron reaction usually follows that of ETR in solution with some modifications. We will first describe these theories briefly. This will be followed by a critique by Hart and Anbar (1970), who favor a tunneling mechanism. Here we are only concerned with fe, the effect of diffusion having been eliminated by applying Eq. (6.18). Second, we only consider simple ETRs where no bonds are created or destroyed. However, the comparison of theory and experiment in this respect is appropriate, as one usually measures the rate of disappearance of es rather than the rate of formation of a product. 

Comparison of Theory and Experiment. The expression for the free energy of interpenetration of sterically stabilized particles may be obtained by combining Equations 2, 3 and 6. Using these expressions can be calculated as a function of both... 

Though the more recent results present a consistent pattern, systematic comparisons of theory and experiment over a larger range of interatomic distances would be most useful. 

Blast Effects in Air, Water, and Solids (311-29) Deformation of Solids (320-23) Metal-Charge Interaction (323-5) Explosion of Shells and Bombs (325-26) Action of Fragments on Target (327-28) Shaped Charges (329-42) Comparison of Theory and Experiment (373-90)... 

Nevertheless, the importance of the parent molecule remains undeniable, and the reason for it forms the second motivation for the minimalist approach It is the traditional way to bring theory and experiment together for mutual comparison. For decades, chemists have been aware of the limitations on theoretical techniques imposed by computational capacity. Everyone dreamed of the day when the properties of any reasonably sized molecule could be calculated to any desired degree of accuracy. In fact, some computational enthusiasts announced about 25 years ago— prematurely, in my opinion—that the day aheady had arrived. Most chemists were skeptical then they continued under the assumption that the most practical comparisons of theory and experiment would involve experiments on the simplest possible test molecules. Thus, those comparisons accepted the limitations that theory still operated under. 

These relations between spectral densities and experiments furnish only the formal framework for a comparison of theory and experiment. The most difficult step still remains How can one evaluate the relevant correlation functions and spectral densities from a theoretical microscopic... 

Figure 6. Comparison of theory and experiment of the unperturbed wavepacket dynamics of the transitions shown in Fig. 4 [7].

Quantitative calculations of cross-section curves have been performed for the systems He(2 S)-Ar and He(23S)-Ar. A comparison of theory and experiment in the case of He(2 S) is not so significant since the measured curve varies only little in the subtended energy range. Therefore, we compare in results for He(23S)-Ar Fig. 10 ... 

Fig. II. Comparisons of theory and experiment for I-V profiles from Pt(IlI) at room temperature for (a) the (00) beam and (b) the (TO) beam at three angles of incidence. The vertical scales are of relative intensity in arbitrary units and are not necessarily compatible from one curve to the next. The theoretical results were calculated on the assumption of the bulk inter-planar spacing for all atomic layers parallel to the surface. 

Figure 1.17 shows the comparison of theory and experiment for preferential adsorption coefficient X of poly(alkyl methacrylate)s in 1,4-dioxane-methanol. 

Fig. 1.17 Comparison of theory and experiment for preferential adsorption coefficient, X, of poly(alkyl methacrylate)s in 1,4-dioxane-methanol. (pso = methanol volume fraction). Points Experimental results from ref. [6], (o) PMMA (alkyl = Me) (A) PEMA (Et) ( ) PiBM (iBu). Association equilibria theory. (2-A) Calculated with the parameter values shown in Table I and numbered as 4-6, Curves (a) PMMA (b) PEMA, (c) PiBMA. (2-B) Calculated with the parameter values shown in Table I and numbered as 10-12. Curves (a) PMMA (b) PEMMA (c) PiBMa. (From ref. [120])...

Miaoulis, I.N., et al., Electric charging in flow of low-conductivity liquids through screens A comparison of theory and experiments,/. Electrostatics, 25, 295-307, 1990. 

Evidently, more work has to be done for a comprehensive comparison of theory and experiment. Theory and simulations reveal clearly that the PB-cell model should be a poor approximation for divalent counterions and breaks down totally for trivalent counterions [29]. A comprehensive experimental test of these very important conclusions is still missing. 

Figure 4. Comparison of theory and experiment with bed diameter, 0.45 m u, 0.6 m/s um/, 0.0164 m/s and 4 mole% hydrocarbon feed.

Figure 5. Comparison of theory and experiment at 410°C with bed diameter 0.04 m space velocity, 1000/h and umf, 0.0041 m/s.

The 1998 recommended value of a-1 based on all the available data, but which is primarily influenced by the comparison of theory and experiment for the anomalous magnetic moment of the electron, is... 

The Rydberg constant is evaluated by the comparison of theory and experiment for energy levels in hydrogen and deuterium. The measured transition frequencies used in the 1998 adjustment are given in Table 3. 

Table 2. Comparison of theory and experiment. Here, go(e) stands for the magnetic moment of a free electron and it contains the anomalous magnetic moment a a/2n...

Improvement by a factor of about 10 in the sensitivity of the comparison of theory and experiment for Av appears possible at this time.9 With the use of a chopped muon beam now available at Los Alamos, line narrowing techniques can be employed.10 Use of a higher magnetic field value will improve the accuracy in determining p /pp. Finally, the intensity and quality of the muon beam has been improved since the last measurement. Considering all these factors, a measurement of Av to about 5 ppb and of p /up to 30 ppb appears possible. 

Comment Experiments point to a gap in the existing theory, namely, the need for a microcanonical theory which takes some account of the solvent frictional effects. What is desirable next is a detailed comparison of theory and experiment. 

Fig. 14.2. Comparison of theory and experiment for the dead-end filtration of the protein bovine serum albumin (BSA). (a) Time (t) over permeate volume (V) vs. permeate volume for varying pH at an ionic strength of 0.03 M. (b) Time over permeate volume vs. permeate volume for varying ionic strength at a pH of 8.0. The model predictions contain no adjustable parameters. ( signifies zeta-potential.

Anson, L.W., Chivers, R.C. 1993. Ultrasonic velocity in suspensions of solids in solids—a comparison of theory and experiment. J. Phys. D Appl. Phys. 26, 1566-1575. 

---