0-Carbonium stabilization

The styrene oxide isomerization is known to be an easy reaction due to the carbonium stabilization by the aromatic nucleus. In the case of H-ZSM-5, taking into account the respective size of this medium-pore zeolite (5.5A) and the kinetic diameter of the styrene oxide molecule (5.9A), it was assumed that the weak external acidic sites are active enough to catalyze the reaction (ref. 16). If this were the case for all zeolites, no shape-selectivity could be obtained for any epoxide rearrangement. Nevertheless, for large-pore zeolites, the contribution of all the acidic sites cannot be excluded. 

Hydroxypyrroles. Pyrroles with nitrogen-substituted side chains containing hydroxyl groups are best prepared by the Paal-Knorr cyclization. Pyrroles with hydroxyl groups on carbon side chains can be made by reduction of the appropriate carbonyl compound with hydrides, by Grignard synthesis, or by iasertion of ethylene oxide or formaldehyde. For example, pyrrole plus formaldehyde gives 2-hydroxymethylpyrrole [27472-36-2] (24). The hydroxymethylpyrroles do not act as normal primary alcohols because of resonance stabilization of carbonium ions formed by loss of water. 

The initiating step in these reactions is the attachment of a group to the sulfoxide oxygen to produce an activated intermediate (5). Suitable groups are proton, acyl, alkyl, or almost any of the groups that also initiate the oxidations of alcohols with DMSO (40,48). In a reaction, eg, the one between DMSO and acetic anhydride, the second step is removal of a proton from an a-carbon to give an yUde (6). Release of an acetate ion generates the sulfur-stabilized carbonium ion (7), and the addition of acetate ion to the carbonium ion (7) results in the product (eq. 15) ... 

This method is suitable only for the preparation of 4-substituted and/or 3,4-disubstituted derivatives, the substituents being only alkyl, aryl or heteroaryl groups. The presence of electron-withdrawing groups in the unsaturated side chain prevents the cyclization step. This is understandable if the influence of such groups on the stability of the intermediate carbonium ion is considered. Of more limited application is the analogous cyclization of diazotized o-aminophenylpropiolic acids, the reaction being referred to as the Richter synthesis (Scheme 70). A related synthesis (also referred to as the Neber-Bossel synthesis)... 

The protonated azirine system has also been utilized for the synthesis of heterocyclic compounds (67JA44S6). Thus, treatment of (199) with anhydrous perchloric acid and acetone or acetonitrile gave the oxazolinium perchlorate (207) and the imidazolinium perchlorate (209), respectively. The mechanism of these reactions involves 1,3-bond cleavage of the protonated azirine and reaction with the carbonyl group (or nitrile) to produce a resonance-stabilized carbonium-oxonium ion (or carbonium-nitrilium ion), followed by attack of the nitrogen unshared pair jf electrons to complete the cyclization. 

On the basis of the above, the rate acceleration afforded by lysozyme appears to be due to (a) general acid catalysis by Glu (b) distortion of the sugar ring at the D site, which may stabilize the carbonium ion and the transition state) and (c) electrostatic stabilization of the carbonium ion by nearby Asp. The overall for lysozyme is about 0.5/sec, which is quite slow (Table... 

Theoretical Studies of Enzymic Reactions Dielectric, Electrostatic and Steric Stabilizations of the Carbonium Ion in the Reaction of Lysozyme A. Warshel and M. Levitt Journal of Molecular Biology 103 (1976) 227-249... 

In this paper, we study the stabihty of the carbonium ion intermediate formed in the cleavage of a glycosidic bond by lysozyme. It is found that the electrostatic stabilization is an important factor in increasing the rate of the reaction step that leads to the formation of the carbonium ion intermediate. Steric factors, such as the strain of the substrate on binding to lysozyme, do not seem to contribute significantly. 

The acyl residue controls the formation and stability of the carbonium ion. If the carbonium ion is destabilized (by electron withdrawing groups), then cyclization to the phenanthridine nucleus will be sluggish. The slower the rate of cyclization, the greater the chance of side reactions with the cyclization reagent. Therefore, the yield of the phenanthridine will depend on the relative rates of cyclization and side reactions, which is controlled by the stability of the carbonium ion. 

It will be observed that most syntheses yield pyrylium salts in which positions 2,4, and 6 are substituted. Since according to formulas Ib-lc these positions have a partial positive charge, it can readily be understood why electron-donating substituents (hydroxy, alkoxy, alkyl, or aryl) in these positions stabilize the pyrylium salts. Only three pyrylium salts which do not have substituents in either a-position have been reported and few unsubstituted in y or in one a-position they are less stable toward hydrolysis, and in the case of perchlorates they explode more easily, than 2,4,6-trisubstituted compounds. In fact, the former are secondary, the latter tertiary carbonium ions. This fact also explains why the parent compound (1) was prepared only in 1953. 

Thane et al. [46] reported that in pentane suspension, alkylaluminum compounds efficiently alkylate labile chlorines in PVC, and alternatively, PVC carbonium ions could alkylate aromatic compounds to give rise to polymers of increased stability. The values of 2-3% for labile chlorines estimated by them were considerably higher than now generally believed. 

The cationic polymerization of cardanol under acidic conditions has been referred to earlier [170,171], NMR studies [16] indicated a carbonium ion initiated mechanism for oligomerization. PCP was found to be highly reactive with aldehydes, amines, and isocyates. Highly insoluble and infusible thermoset products could be obtained. Hexamine-cured PCP showed much superior thermal stability (Fig. 12) at temperatures above 500°C to that of the unmodified cardanol-formaldehyde resins. However, it was definitely inferior to phenolic resins at all temperatures. The difference in thermal stability between phenolic and PCP resins could be understood from the presence of the libile hydrocarbon segment in PCP. 

The reaction is facilitated when R is electron withdrawing, when R has a high migratory aptitude (ability to stabilize a carbonium ion), and by polar reaction media. 

The few exceptions to this general rule arise when the a-carbon carries a substituent that can stabilize carbonium-ion development well, such as oxygen or sulphur. For example, 1-trimethylsilyl trimethylsilyl enol ethers give products (72) derived from electrophilic attack at the /J-carbon, and the vinylsilane (1) reacts with a/3-unsaturated acid chlorides in a Nazarov cyclization (13) to give cyclopentenones such as (2) the isomeric vinylsilane (3), in which the directing effects are additive, gives the cyclopentenone (4) ... 

Although there are a number of reports in the literature of this process, (see ref. 1) only one of these relates to a kinetic study of the reaction168. The ease with which the reaction takes place depends upon the stability of the leaving carbonium ion. Consequently, de-r-butylation is mcst frequently observed and in a kinetic study of the sulphonation of /-butylbenzene in aqueous sulphuric acid (see p. 72) this side reaction was sufficiently prominent for rates to be easily measurable (Table 225)168. Comparison of the rates with those in Table 42 shows that de-... 

FIGURE 6.6. The type of model compounds that were used to estimate the electrostatic stabilization in lysozyme (the only hydrogen atom shown, is the one bonded to the oxygen). Such molecules do not show a large rate acceleration due to electrostatic stabilization of the positively charged carbonium transition state. However, the reaction occurs in solution and not in a protein-active site, and the dielectric effect is expected to be very different in the two cases. 

Tetrhedral intermediate, 172 Thermodynamic cycles, 186 Thermolysin, zinc as cofactor for, 204 Thrombin, 170 Torsional potential, 111 Transition states, 41-42,44, 45,46, 88, 90-92 in amide hydrolysis, 219-221 oxyanion hole and, 181 stabilization of, 181,181 carbonium ion, 154,155,156-161, 167-169 for gas-phase reactions, 43... 

Aquilante and Volpi indicate (2) that propanium ions formed by proton transfer from H3 + are not collisionally stabilized at propane pressures as great as 0.3 mm. and that they decompose by elimination of hydrogen or a smaller saturated hydrocarbon to form an alkyl carbonium ion. Others (16, 19) have proposed one or the other of these fates for unstabilized propanium ions. Our observations can be rationalized within this framework by the following mechanisms ... 

In previous studies (Hogeveen, 1970) the reactivity of long-lived carbonium ions towards molecular hydrogen has been investigated and interesting differences between secondary and tertiary alkyl cations have been observed. Tliis reaction is too slow, however, to be extended to other types of carbonium ions. The reactivity of carbonium ions towards carbon monoxide is much higher (about six powers of ten) than towards molecular hydrogen, which enabled us to determine not only the rate of reaction (3) for some tertiary and secondary alkyl cations, but also the rate of carbonylation of more stabilized carbonium ions. 

For the determination of stabilizations of carbonium ions the equilibrium constants of carbonylation-decarbonylation have been used in previous Sections. For the ions discussed in this Seetion, however, the rate constants of decarbonylation are not known and, therefore, the rate constants of carbonylation will be used as a criterion for such stabilizations. This kinetic criterion is a useful indicator if there are no significant steric factors in the carbonylation step and if this step is indeed rate-determining in the overall process (Hogeveen and Gaasbeek, 1970). The following rate constants in Table 2 are of particular importance. 

In the case of carbanion and radical intermediates the solvent is less important but the products are partially determined by the resistance of the medium to proton or hydrogen atom abstraction respectively. The increased stability of these intermediates compared with carbonium ions allows the reaction mechanism to be more readily modified by the addition of trapping agents. For example, carbanions are trapped in high yields by the presence of carbon dioxide in the electrolysis medium (Wawzonek and Wearring, 1959 Wawzonek et al., 1955). 

Carbonium ions are likewise known to be stabilized by solvation in strongly acidic media (Olah and Pittman, 1966), and consequently the reduction potential of carbonium ions, the ease of formation of a carbonium ion by the oxidation of a substrate and the products from these reactions would be expected to depend on the acidity of the electrolysis... 

Although at first glance addition to the central carbon and formation of what seems like an allylic carbonium ion would clearly be preferred over terminal addition and a vinyl cation, a closer examination shows this not to be the case. Since the two double bonds in allenes are perpendicular to each other, addition of an electrophile to the central carbon results in an empty p orbital, which is perpendicular to the remaining rr system and hence not resonance stabilized (and probably inductively destabilized) until a 90° rotation occurs around the newly formed single bond. Hence, allylic stabilization may not be significant in the transition state. In fact, electrophilic additions to allene itself occur without exception at the terminal carbon (54). 

---