Binary column

The design of a distillation column is based on information derived from the VLE diagram describing the mixtures to be separated. The vapor-liquid equilibrium characteristics are indicated by the characteristic shapes of the equilibrium curves. This is what determines the number of stages, and hence the number of trays needed for a separation. Although column designs are often proprietary, the classical method of McCabe-Thiele for binary columns is instructive on the principles of design. 

The diverse combinatorial screening described in the previous sections revealed active Pt-Ru-Co methanol oxidation catalysts, especially near Pt20Co6oRu2o. A second primary screening cycle (Fig. 11.8) focused on a more limited compositional space to isolate the active region in more detail. Figs. 11.15 and 11.16 show the design and the sampled compositional space of a Pt-Ru-Co ternary library. The design contains a pure Pt catalyst, Pt-Co binaries (row A), Pt-Ru binaries (column 1)... 

Extractive distillation is probably the oldest and most widely applied type of hybrid separation, particularly useful in close-boiling-point problems or in systems in which components form azeotropes. In the method, an extra component (solvent) is added to the system, which does not form azeotropes with feed components. The solvent alters the relative volatility of original feed components, allowing one to distill overhead. The solvent leaves the column with the bottom products and is separated in a binary column. Energy savings represent the most important advantage of extractive distillation over the conventional (nonhybrid) separation methods (168,169). 

Converse and Huber (1965), Robinson (1970), Mayur and Jackson (1971), Luyben (1988) and Mujtaba (1997) used this model for simulation and optimisation of conventional batch distillation. Domenech and Enjalbert (1981) used similar model in their simulation study with the exception that they used temperature dependent phase equilibria instead of constant relative volatility. Christiansen et al. (1995) used this model (excluding column holdup) to study parametric sensitivity of ideal binary columns. 

Christiansen, A.C., Jacobsen, E.W., Perkins. J.D. and Skogestad, S., On the dynamics of batch distillation A study of parametric sensitivity in ideal binary columns. Presented at the AIChE Annual Meeting, Miami, USA, November, paper no. 184d, 1995. 

With the reflux ratio fixed, one can step off the number of trays for a binary column using a McCabe-Thiele diagram or, if one wishes to account for heat effects, a Ponchon-Savarit diagram (Treybal. 1968), establishing the number of trays needed and where to feed the column. 

Parameters in a Fixed-Pressure Binary Column Section... 

FIGURE 5.2 Equilibrium stages in a binary column section. 

On the other hand, there is little support to propagate schema changes to dependent schema objects, such as views, foreign keys, and indexes. When one alters a table, either the dependent objects must themselves be manually altered in some way, or the alteration must be aborted. The latter approach takes the majority of the time. For instance, SQL Server aborts any attempt to alter a column if it is part of any index, unless the alteration is within strict limits - namely, the alteration is a widening of a text or binary column. Dropped columns simply cannot participate in any index. DB2 has similar restrictions Oracle invalidates dependent objects like views so that they must be revalidated on next use and fails to execute them if they do not compile against the new schema version. 

Specification of the Control Objectives. We can have up to four control objectives since there are four remaining degrees of freedom. Acceptable operation of the binary column requires that the following variables be maintained at desired values ... 

Curve fitting (peak Parameter Single and binary Column and plant... 

In this chapter, we apply the techniques learned in Chapter 7 for the simple binary column to more complex phase equilibria and more complex distillation flowsheets. 

Chapter 4. Binary Column Distillation Internal Stage-by-Stage Balances... 

In theory we should control the temperature at the point at which the product is withdrawn from the column. However there are several reasons why this may not be practical. Firstly, the liquid may not be homogeneously at its bubble point. This is likely to be the situation close to the top tray since reflux is often subcooled. It can also occur at the base of the column if the vapour from the reboiler is superheated. Secondly, in pseudo-binary columns, the relationship between composition and bubble point also depends on the proportion of non-key components in the product The greatest proportion of LLK will occur at the top of the column, and of HHK at the bottom. Thus, if non-key composition varies, these are the regions most prone to inaccuracy. Finally, particularly on high purity columns, the temperature may not be sensitive to changes in composition. 

Equations 5.11 and 5.12 are plotted on a Y-X diagram in Figure 5.2. Curve A is the equilibrium curve representing Equation 5.12 or any other set of vapor-liquid equilibrium data. Curve B is the operating line, or material balance relationship, expressed by Equation 5.11. The binary column section may be solved on this diagram by graphically duplicating the steps in the analytical procedure. 

Two other models for binary columns are those proposed by Wahl and Harriott and by Waller. These are similar in that they are both based on circulation rates and liquid holdup in the column. Low-order transfer functions are calculated from steady-state data. The two models give essentially the same results except that the Waller method leads to higher order—and intuitively more accurate—transfer functions. For columns with moderate relative volatilities—say 2 to 5—and for terminal purities not greater than 98 to 99 percent, predicted behavior checks with that of more rigorous models. But for high-purity, nonideal separations, accuracy falls off. More work needs to be done to check the range of validity of these models. 

Lost composition control schemes for a binary column involve manipulating either reflux or distillate to control top composition, and either boilup or bottom produrt to control bottom composition. Changes in either of the two top manipulative variables will affect not only top composition, but bottom composition as well. Correspondingly, changes in either bottom-product flow or boilup will affect both bottom and top compositions. As a minimum, therefore, for feedback control purposes we are interested in two composition gains at each end of the column. 

By a procedure similar to that of Binary Column—P we find ... 

---