Alcohol carbocation

As described in Section III.B.l, decomposition of primary alkoxides in inert organic solvents requires temperatures much higher than 300°C, but in alcohols they may decompose at relatively low temperatures. The carbocation formed by the heterolytic cleavage of the C-0 bond is only poorly solvated in the inert organic solvent therefore the reaction barely proceeds. On the other hand, in alcohols, carbocation is solvated, which lowers the activation energy for the decomposition of alkoxide. For example, aluminum ethoxide does not decompose in toluene at 300°C, while it does decompose in ethanol, yielding the alkyl derivative of boehmite. 

Used to denote primary, mainly for alcohols, carbocations and carbanions... 

The reaction of trivalent carbocations with carbon monoxide giving acyl cations is the key step in the well-known and industrially used Koch-Haaf reaction of preparing branched carboxylic acids from al-kenes or alcohols. For example, in this way, isobutylene or tert-hutyi alcohol is converted into pivalic acid. In contrast, based on the superacidic activation of electrophiles leading the superelectrophiles (see Chapter 12), we found it possible to formylate isoalkanes to aldehydes, which subsequently rearrange to their corresponding branched ketones. 

To be able to prepare and study these elusive species in stable form, acids billions of times stronger than concentrated sulfuric acid were needed (so called superacids). Some substituted carbocations, however, are remarkably stable and are even present in nature. You may be surprised to learn that the fine red wine we drank tonight contained carbocations which are responsible for the red color of this natural 12% or so alcoholic solution. I hope you enjoyed it as much as I did. 

Carbocations derived from the alcohol are probably the reactive species, but data concerning by-products expected with carbocationic intermediates are lacking. Rearrangement of 2-alkylaminothiazoles to 2-amino-5-alkylthiazoles may also explain the observed products 2-aminothiazole with benzyl chloride yields first 2-benz Iaminothiazole (206). which then rearranges to 2-amino-5-benzvlthiazole (207) (Scheme 130) (163. 165. 198). 

As carbocations go CH3" is particularly unstable and its existence as an inter mediate m chemical reactions has never been demonstrated Primary carbocations although more stable than CH3" are still too unstable to be involved as intermediates m chemical reactions The threshold of stability is reached with secondary carbocations Many reactions including the reaction of secondary alcohols with hydrogen halides are believed to involve secondary carbocations The evidence m support of tertiary carbo cation intermediates is stronger yet... 

One important experimental fact is that the rate of reaction of alcohols with hydro gen halides increases m the order methyl < primary < secondary < tertiary This reac tivity order parallels the carbocation stability order and is readily accommodated by the mechanism we have outlined... 

The SnI mechanism is generally accepted to be correct for the reaction of tertiary and secondary alcohols with hydrogen halides It is almost certainly not correct for methyl alcohol and primary alcohols because methyl and primary carbocations are believed to be much too unstable and the activation energies for their formation much too high for them to be reasonably involved The next section describes how methyl and primary alcohols are converted to their corresponding halides by a mechanism related to but different from S l... 

The major difference between the two mechanisms is the second step The second step m the reaction of tert butyl alcohol with hydrogen chloride is the ummolecular dis sociation of tert butyloxonium ion to tert butyl cation and water Heptyloxonium ion however instead of dissociating to an unstable primary carbocation reacts differently It IS attacked by bromide ion which acts as a nucleophile We can represent the transition state for this step as... 

Secondary and tertiary alcohols react with hydrogen halides by a mech anism that involves formation of a carbocation intermediate m the rate determining step... 

The rate at which alcohols are converted to alkyl halides depends on the rate of carbocation formation tertiary alcohols are most reactive primary alcohols and methanol are least reactive... 

These common features suggest that carbocations are key intermediates m alcohol dehydra tions just as they are m the reaction of alcohols with hydrogen halides Figure 5 6 portrays a three step mechanism for the acid catalyzed dehydration of tert butyl alcohol Steps 1 and 2 describe the generation of tert butyl cation by a process similar to that which led to its for matron as an intermediate m the reaction of tert butyl alcohol with hydrogen chloride... 

Write a structural formula for the carbocation intermediate formed in the dehydration of each of the alcohols in Problem 5 14 (Section 5 10) Using curved arrows show how each carbocation is deprotonated by water to give a mixture of alkenes... 

As noted earlier (Section 4 10) primary carbocations are too high m energy to be intermediates m most chemical reactions If primary alcohols don t form primary car bocations then how do they undergo elimination s A modification of our general mech amsm for alcohol dehydration offers a reasonable explanation For primary alcohols it is... 

Like tertiary alcohols secondary alcohols normally undergo dehydration by way of carbocation intermediates... 

There is a strong similarity between the mechanism shown m Eigure 5 12 and the one shown for alcohol dehydration m Eigure 5 6 The mam difference between the dehy dration of 2 methyl 2 butanol and the dehydrohalogenation of 2 bromo 2 methylbutane IS the source of the carbocation When the alcohol is the substrate it is the correspond mg alkyloxonmm ion that dissociates to form the carbocation The alkyl halide ionizes directly to the carbocation... 

Like alcohol dehydrations El reactions of alkyl halides can be accompanied by carbocation rearrangements Eliminations by the E2 mechanism on the other hand nor mally proceed without rearrangement Consequently if one wishes to prepare an alkene from an alkyl halide conditions favorable to E2 elimination should be chosen In prac tice this simply means carrying out the reaction m the presence of a strong base... 

Section 5 12 Secondary and tertiary alcohols undergo dehydration by an El mecha nism involving carbocation intermediates... 

Primary alcohols do not dehydrate as readily as secondary or tertiary alcohols and their dehydration does not involve a primary carbocation A proton is lost from the (3 carbon m the same step m which carbon-oxygen bond cleavage occurs The mechanism is E2... 

Alkene synthesis via alcohol dehydration is complicated by carbocation rearrangements A less stable carbocation can rearrange to a more sta ble one by an alkyl group migration or by a hydride shift opening the possibility for alkene formation from two different carbocations... 

We have seen this situation before m the reaction of alcohols with hydrogen halides (8ection 4 11) m the acid catalyzed dehydration of alcohols (8ection 5 12) and m the conversion of alkyl halides to alkenes by the El mechanism (8ection 5 17) As m these other reactions an electronic effect specifically the stabilization of the carbocation intermediate by alkyl substituents is the decisive factor The more stable the carbo cation the faster it is formed... 

Additional evidence for carbocation intermediates in certain nucleophilic substitutions comes from observing rearrangements of the kind normally associated with such species For example hydrolysis of the secondary alkyl bromide 2 bromo 3 methylbutane yields the rearranged tertiary alcohol 2 methyl 2 butanol as the only substitution product... 

Unbranched primary alcohols and tertiary alcohols tend to react with hydrogen halides without rearrangement The alkyloxonmm ions from primary alcohols react rap idly with bromide ion for example m an Sn2 process Tertiary alcohols give tertiary alkyl halides because tertiary carbocations are stable and show little tendency to rearrange... 

Illustrate the stereochemistry associated with unimolecular nucleophilic substitution by con structmg molecular models of cis 4 tert butylcyclohexyl bromide its derived carbocation and the alcohols formed from it by hydrolysis under S l conditions... 

Because the positive charge m an allylic carbocation is shared by two carbons there are two potential sites for attack by a nucleophile Thus hydrolysis of 3 chloro 3 methyl 1 butene gives a mixture of two allylic alcohols... 

Both alcohols are formed from the same carbocation Water may react with the carbo cation to give either a primary alcohol or a tertiary alcohol... 

Reaction with hydrogen halides (Sec tion 4 7) The order of alcohol reactiv ity parallels the order of carbocation staiiility RjC" > R2CH > RCHj" > CHj" Benzylic alcohols react readily... 

This IS a frequently used proce dure for the preparation of alkenes The order of alcohol reactivity paral lels the order of carbocation stability R3C > R2CH > RCH2 Benzylic al cohols react readily Rearrangements are sometimes observed... 

Steps 4-5 Conversion of hemiacetal to carbocation These steps are analogous to the formation of carbocations m acid catalyzed reactions of alcohols... 

Fnedel-Crafts alkylation Alcohols in combination with acids serve as sources of carbocations Attack of a carbocation on the electron rich ring of a phe nol brings about its alkylation... 

Once the carbocation is formed it is captured by the alcohol acting as a nucleophile Attack can occur at either the a or p face of the carbocation... 

---