Transition state attractive

In summary, it seems that for most Diels-Alder reactions secondary orbital interactions afford a satisfactory rationalisation of the endo-exo selectivity. However, since the endo-exo ratio is determined by small differences in transition state energies, the influence of other interactions, most often steric in origin and different for each particular reaction, is likely to be felt. The compact character of the Diels-Alder activated complex (the activation volume of the retro Diels-Alder reaction is negative) will attenuate these eflfects. The ideas of Sustmann" and Mattay ° provide an attractive alternative explanation, but, at the moment, lack the proper experimental foundation. 

The soft-nucleophile-soft-electrophile combination is also associated with a late transition state, in which the strength of the newly forming bond contributes significantly to the stability of the transition state. The hard-nucleophile-hffld-elechophile combination inqilies an early transition state with electrostatic attraction being more important than bond formation. The reaction pathway is chosen early on the reaction coordinate and primarily on the basis of charge distributiotL... 

A more interesting possibility, one that has attracted much attention, is that the activation parameters may be temperature dependent. In Chapter 5 we saw that theoiy predicts that the preexponential factor contains the quantity T", where n = 5 according to collision theory, and n = 1 according to the transition state theory. In view of the uncertainty associated with estimation of the preexponential factor, it is not possible to distinguish between these theories on the basis of the observed temperature dependence, yet we have the possibility of a source of curvature. Nevertheless, the exponential term in the Arrhenius equation dominates the temperature behavior. From Eq. (6-4), we may examine this in terms either of or A//. By analogy with equilibrium thermodynamics, we write... 

The negatively charged ring in the transition state and intermediate complex presumably exerts little or no inductive electron attraction on a substituent. So, as one might expect, the transition-state effect of an azine methoxy group can differ from its (conjugated)... 

The general principle that activation of para substitution is greater than of ortho substitution holds true also for an azinium moiety in the one instance studied. Thus, the activation energy for the 4-chloropyridine quaternary salt 280 (Table II, line 9) is 1 kcal lower than that for the 2-isomer (line 5). The rate relation (2- > 4-isomer) is controlled by the entropies of activation in this reaction due to electrostatic attraction in the transition state (281). The reverse rate relation (4- > 2-position) is predicted for aminations of such quaternary compounds due to electrostatic repulsion (282) plus the difference in E. A kinetic study of the 2- and 4-pyridine quaternary salts... 

In bicyclic azines, as in the monocyclic azines already discussed, the faster of two nucleophilic substitutions proceeds via the transition state which has the lower free energy (with respect to the reactants) due to the stabilizing effects of resonance, hydrogen bonding, or electrostatic attractions. Different nucleophiles and different leaving... 

The reactivities of 4- and 2-halo-l-nitronaphthalenes can usefully be compared with the behavior of azine analogs to aid in delineating any specific effects of the naphthalene 7r-electron system on nucleophilic substitution. With hydroxide ion (75°) as nucleophile (Table XII, lines 1 and 8), the 4-chloro compound reacts four times as fast as the 2-isomer, which has the higher and, with ethoxide ion (65°) (Table XII, lines 2 and 11), it reacts about 10 times as fast. With piperidine (Table XII, lines 5 and 17) the reactivity relation at 80° is reversed, the 2-bromo derivative reacts about 10 times as rapidly as the 4-isomer, presumably due to hydrogen bonding or to electrostatic attraction in the transition state, as postulated for benzene derivatives. 4-Chloro-l-nitronaphthalene reacts 6 times as fast with methanolic methoxide (60°) as does 4-chloroquinoline due to a considerably higher entropy of activation and in spite of a higher Ea (by 2 kcal). ... 

Specific alterations of the relative reactivity due to hydrogen bonding in the transition state or to a cyclic transition state or to electrostatic attraction in quaternary compounds or protonated azines are included below (cf. also Sections II, B, 3 II, B, 5 II, C and II, F). A-Protonation is often reflected in an increase in JS and therefore the relative reactivity can vary with the significance of JS in controlling the reaction rate. Variation can also result from rate determination by the second stage of the SjjAr2 mechanism or from the intervention of thermodynamic control of product formation. Variation in the rate and in the reactivity pattern of polyazanaph-thalenes will result when nucleophilic substitution [Eq. (10)] occurs only on a covalent adduct (408) of the substrate rather than on its aromatic form (400). This covalent addition is prevented by any 4-... 

An expedient and stereoselective synthesis of bicyclic ketone 30 exemplifies the utility and elegance of Corey s new catalytic system (see Scheme 8). Reaction of the (R)-tryptophan-derived oxazaboro-lidine 42 (5 mol %), 5-(benzyloxymethyl)-l,3-cyclopentadiene 26, and 2-bromoacrolein (43) at -78 °C in methylene chloride gives, after eight hours, diastereomeric adducts 44 in a yield of 83 % (95 5 exo.endo diastereoselectivity 96 4 enantioselectivity for the exo isomer). After reaction, the /V-tosyltryptophan can be recovered for reuse. The basic premise is that oxazaborolidine 42 induces the Diels-Alder reaction between intermediates 26 and 43 to proceed through a transition state geometry that maximizes attractive donor-acceptor interactions. Coordination of the dienophile at the face of boron that is cis to the 3-indolylmethyl substituent is thus favored.19d f Treatment of the 95 5 mixture of exo/endo diastereo-mers with 5 mol % aqueous AgNC>3 selectively converts the minor, but more reactive, endo aldehyde diastereomer into water-soluble... 

The mode of the diastcrcofacial selectivity is completely reversed in the case of reactions with A -methyl A-acyliminium precursors 4176. Now the nitrogen atom of the A-acyliminium ion is not able to chelate with the tin atom and the lower diastereoselectivity is explained by the less rigid nonchelation-controlled transition state 5. An electronic effect, such as n-iz attraction between the electron-deficient carbonyl group of the acyliminium ion and the electron-rich phenyl group of the phcnylthio substituent R, may account for the somewhat higher diastereoselectivity in the case of arylthio substituents R. 

---