Toughened anaerobic adhesives

Figure 2.2 Fatigue performance of a typical toughened anaerobic adhesive. This S/N curve (load v cumulative number of loading cycles to induce joint failure) for a toughened anaerobic adhesive shows that it will not fail through fatigue if the load applied is less than 50 per cent of the ultimate strength in shear of the adhesive - in this specific joint configuration.

The rate of chemical degradation above 200°C as well as general performance depend largely upon the components used, the working environment and the adhesive type employed. Some of the newer, toughened, anaerobic adhesives will seal cylinder liners adjacent to exhaust ports, because, although decomposition takes place, degeneration is not so rapid that the adhesive is completely destroyed before natural deposits have built up to maintain the seal. 

Anaerobic adhesives contain reactive monomer(s), accelerators, stabilisers or inhibitors, fillers, colorants, modifiers, tougheners (rubbers, butadiene graft, etc.). The chemistry of anaerobic adhesive is complex but the schematic brief of the reaction may be shown as follows ... 

The use of elastomeric or flexibilizing modifiers occurred and grew with epoxy resins first. Various aspects of toughened epoxy adhesives have been covered in reviews by the present authors (2,3), where the elastomeric modifiers have essentially been carboxylic, liquid and solid butadiene/acrylonitrile polymers. There has not been a systematic review, however, of these and other reactive liquid polybutadiene/acrylonitriles in the burgeoning areas of acrylic, anaerobic and radiation-curable systems. Thus, this paper s intent. 

Table 7 illustrates the mechanical property behavior of VTBN in a simple hydroperoxide model. Recipe with an appreciable tear strength broke in a tensile-yielding mode similar to toughened thermoplastics. VTBN (as well as CTBN and HTBN) have found utility in the newer anaerobic adhesive systems. 

Aspects of this subject are also dealt with in other articles, notably Acrylic adhesives. Durability - fundamentals. Joint design general. Joint design cylindrical joints. Joint design strength and fracture perspectives. In the article on Toughened acrylic adhesives, some properties are compared with those of Epoxide adhesives and anaerobic adhesives. 

An anaerobic adhesive is the best choice for these applications and only under extreme environmental conditions is it necessary to resort to the toughened variants or - in the final resort - the toughened, single-part epoxies (see p.33 Splines, keys and set screws and p.71 Co-axial - splined). 

Suitable plastics pulleys may be bonded satisfactorily with cyanoacrylate adhesives or, where large components are involved, with toughened acrylics -many of which are unsuitable for use on small parts. The stronger anaerobic adhesives and single-part epoxies should be used for all-metal assemblies. 

If it is necessary to maximise performance, the engaged area should be as large as allowed by the design and the plastic s surface should be chemically treated or roughened if at all possible. Finally, a high-performance adhesive of low modulus - preferably toughened - should be used. The selection procedure of Section 5.2 helps locate a suitable material. Note in the presence of a steel part, most high quality anaerobic adhesives will set satisfactorily - even if one surface is non-metallic - but two non-metallic surfaces will invariably require a primer if an anaerobic adhesive is to cure. 

Toughened anaerobic. The toughened acrylic-based anaerobic adhesives take two disparate forms, the first group being similar in nature to the stronger versions of the anaerobic adhesives described above — though their overall performance is considerably enhanced. 

It has proved possible to toughen anaerobic compositions and, like the other toughened adhesives discussed in the earlier sections, these variants have proved to be particularly robust and suitable for very rigorous applications. Their use should always be given consideration when conventional solutions to assembly problems have failed. 

Urethanes have also been used to toughen vinyl-terminated acrylic adhesives for improved impact resistance. Thus rubber-toughened urethane acrylates [79,80], water-dispersible urethane acrylates [81], and high-temperature-performance urethane-acrylate structural adhesives have been reported [82]. Polyurethanes terminated with acrylic functionality are also used for anaerobic or radiation-cured adhesives with improved toughness [83]. 

In the mid-seventies, spurred by developments from the DuPont Corporation, a new kind of two-component acrylic adhesive system was introduced to the joining industry. The DuPont technology has been widely licensed and is now referred to by numerous terms such as "second-generation acrylics", "reactive adhesives", "modified acrylics", "toughened acrylics", etc. These adhesives seemed to answer the need for improvements over some of the major disadvantages found in anaerobic structural adhesives, namely those of cost, the need for scrupulous surface preparation, and the ability to bond plastic surfaces. 

The use of adhesives/sealants in both the industrial and consumer spheres has increased dramatically in the past 20 years. In the industrial segment, both reactive and nonreactive systems are used in a wide variety of applications. The increasing use of reactive systems has, however, tended to overshadow that of the nonreactive systems. Most prominent amongst the reactive systems favored in industrial applications are anaerobic sealants (methacrylate ester based), instant adhesives (alkyl cyanoacrylate ester based), acrylic (toughened) adhesives, epoxy resin adhesives, polyurethane/isocyanate-based adhesives, silicone adhesives/sealants, and phenolic resin adhesives. 

In recent years, the range of adhesive materials used in automotive manufacture has expanded to include polyurethanes, plastisols, phenolics, hot melts, anaerobics, cyanoacrylates, toughened acrylics and epoxies (see Structural and Hot melt adhesives). Selection criteria are based principally upon the nature of the adherends, the mechanical properties required under service conditions and application and curing characteristics. 

Table 2. Comparative benefits of industrial adhesives (toughened acrylics, anaerobics, epoxies)...

Although development of toughened adhesives has been limited to the various acrylic (both anaerobic and non-anaerobic) and epoxy types, overall performance has been improved spectacularly. Both environmental resistance and peel and impact performance have been raised substantially without sacrificing shear strength. 

With this restraint in mind, the most likely order of preference - taking general robustness into account - would be toughened adhesives of the following classes Single-part epoxies, Acrylics, Anaerobics, and Two-part epoxies... 

Note 3 Normally adhesives (non-anaerobic) are not assessed on collar and pin joints -but for comparison with the mechanical and anaerobic techniques the performance of several typical adhesives has been assessed using this method. Acrylic This type of toughened adhesive does not show up well on joints of this size because it is too compliant to be effective on small joint areas. On a large lap joint, a 50 per cent increase could be anticipated. Two-part epoxy The many formulations available could fall anywhere in the band indicated according to their individual characteristics. Single-part epoxy These toughened adhesives offer the maximum perform ance possible and are usually easier to use than two-part types. 

Of the high-performance adhesives there is little doubt that anaerobics are uniquely capable of supplementing the retention and sealing of cylinder liners -both wet and dry. Only the strongest versions should be used and, in the most demanding circumstances, probably only the toughened variants will suffice (see Plate 17). 

As pointed out in Section 1.1, most anaerobic compositions are not true adhesives and, although very stable, they are not currently as robust or durable as the heat-cured, toughened, single-part epoxies. These epoxies are therefore used to replace solder on brass components when only a few threads are available for engagement. The softness of the alloy coupled with the low engagement area militate against anaerobics, especially when it is intended to use these at high temperatures. 

Quite contrary to popular belief - a belief founded on the use of traditional adhesives - reliable joints can be obtained from unprepared surfaces. Of course, there is no denying that the better the preparation the better the overall performance. But, providing contamination is not gross, perfectly adequate levels of performance can normally be obtained from Anaerobic Cyanoacrylate Plastisol Toughened acrylic and Toughened, heat-cured, epoxide-based adhesives. 

No other adhesive type has the versatility of this family for assembly (with dismantling possible) of co-axially fitting parts. But for lap joints, the ultimate performance of even the best of the truly adhesive anaerobics is readily surpassed by other groups - particularly the toughened acrylics and toughened epoxies. However, both of these may be less convenient to use. 

Toughened adhesives contain a dispersed, physically separate, though chemically attached, resilient rubbery phase. The toughened concept (see Section 1.2) - in the modern sense - has so far only been successfully applied to two adhesive families - anaerobics and epoxies described in Section 5.1.2 and 5.1.5 respectively. It has also led to the creation of an entirely new species of adhesive - the toughened acrylic - which is discussed in Section 5.1.12.2 below. 

Toughened adhesives s Acrylic-based Anaerobic, thermoplastic, cold-cured s 2, 27... 

The most important components of acrylic adhesives are monomers, tougheners, and catalyst systems. The acrylic research literature (particularly patents) appears much smaller than the anaerobic literature, in part because acrylic research is often disclosed or covered as part of an anaerobic publication. Therefore, a familiarity with the anaerobic literature is required to fully understand structural acrylic technology. 

In most commercially available acrylic adhesives, the initiator is the oxidant portion of the redox couple. Hydroperoxides are most commonly used (as with anaerobics).Other initiators have been reported, although most acrylic research has focused on monomers and tougheners rather than on the catalyst systems. 

Toughening of anaerobics by using urethane methacrylate monomers or by incorporating rubbers has been moderately successful, to create (although expensive) structural adhesives. However, in contrast to other tough adhesives such as reactive acrylics and polyurethanes, they remain relatively brittle materials. 

The versatility of epoxy-resin systems arises from the many combinations of epoxy resins and hardeners, each of which gives a different cure profile and results in a different molecular structure in the resulting polymer. Compared with other adhesive systems such as cyanoacrylates or anaerobics, epoxies are not very sensitive to impurities. This gives tremendous scope for modification of their properties by additives, modifiers, fillers, rubber tougheners,... 

Acrylic anaerobics, conventional acrylics, cyanoacrylates, the so-called second generation , toughened acrylics and adhesives having UV-activateable or UV-curing capabilities... 

---