Substitution, electrophilic substrate reactivity

Nitration in sulphuric acid is a reaction for which the nature and concentrations of the electrophile, the nitronium ion, are well established. In these solutions compounds reacting one or two orders of magnitude faster than benzene do so at the rate of encounter of the aromatic molecules and the nitronium ion ( 2.5). If there were a connection between selectivity and reactivity in electrophilic aromatic substitutions, then electrophiles such as those operating in mercuration and Friedel-Crafts alkylation should be subject to control by encounter at a lower threshold of substrate reactivity than in nitration this does not appear to occur. 

In retrospect, it is ironic to it that when I met Ernst Schumacher in 1969 (he was then Professor at the University of Bern in Switzerland) we did not talk about the experiments he did at Zurich in the same building where I was at that time. Instead, his interest focussed on our work on borazine transition metal compounds and we discussed in some detail whether it would be possible to incorporate metal atoms like chromium or molybdenum between the layers of hexagonal boron nitride (BN) in a similar way as it can be done with graphite. In the course of these discussions I did not mention that, after I had moved to Zurich, we had begun to investigate the reactivity of nickelocene towards both nucleophilic and electrophilic substrates. The reason was that we were still at the beginning, and while we had been able to prepare a series of monocyclopentadienyl nickel complexes from Ni(C5H5)2 and Lewis bases, our attempts to obtain alkyl- or acyl-substituted nickelocenes by the Friedel-Crafts reaction failed. 

Alternative reaction pathways exploring different synthetic possibilities have been studied. For instance, electron-rich dihydroazines also react with isocyanides in the presence of an electrophile, generating reactive iminium species that can then be trapped by the isocyanide. In this case, coordination of the electrophile with the isocyanide must be kinetically bypassed or reversible, to enable productive processes. Examples of this chemistry include the hydro-, halo- and seleno-carba-moylation of the DHPs 270, as well as analogous reactions of cyclic enol ethers (Scheme 42a) [223, 224]. p-Toluenesulfonic acid (as proton source), bromine and phenylselenyl chloride have reacted as electrophilic inputs, with DHPs and isocyanides to prepare the corresponding a-carbamoyl-(3-substituted tetrahydro-pyridines 272-274 (Scheme 42b). Wanner has recently, implemented a related and useful process that exploits M-silyl DHPs (275) to promote interesting MCRs. These substrates are reacted with a carboxylic acid and an isocyanide in an Ugi-Reissert-type reaction, that forms the polysubstituted tetrahydropyridines 276 with good diasteroselectivity (Scheme 42c) [225]. The mechanism involves initial protiodesilylation to form the dihydropyridinum salt S, which is then attacked by the isocyanide, en route to the final adducts. 

Among organic sulfides, those derived from 1,3-dithiane occupy an important place. The interest in these reagents lies not only in their reactivity with electrophilic substrates but also in the synthetic principles which have been developed from work on these compounds. By masking the aldehyde group by the formation of a dithiane, the carbon atom may participate in nucleophilic additions or substitution reactions and after hydrolysis of the thioacetal, the carbonyl group can then be regenerated (Scheme 1). 

In summary, then, analysis of the structures of product alkyl-aromatics, patterns of substrate reactivity, and side reaction pathways in modified faujasite-catalyzed alkylations reveals great similarity to the corresponding features commonly reported for electrophilic aromatic substitutions in the presence of strong protonic acids or promoted Lewis acids. 

These substitutions are facilitated by electron release from the heteroatom pyrroles are more reactive than furans, which are in turn more reactive than thiophenes. Quantitative comparisons of the relative reactivities of the three heterocycles vary from electrophile to electrophile, but for trifluoroacetylation, for example, the pyrrole furan thiophene ratio is 5 x 10 1.5 x 10 I " in formylation, furan is 12 times more reactive than thiophene, and for acetylation, the value is 9.3. In hydrogen exchange (deuteriodeproton-ation), the partial rate factors for the a and p positions of A-methylpyrrole are 3.9 x 10 ° and 2.0 x 10 ° respectively for this same process, the values for furan are 1.6 x 10 and 3.2 x l(f and for thiophene, 3.9 X 10 and 1.0 x 10 respectively, and in a study of thiophene, a P ratios ranging from 100 1 to 1000 1 were found for different electrophiles. Relative substrate reactivity parallels positional selectivity i.e. the a P ratio decreases in the order furan > thiophene > pyrrole. ° Nice illustrations of these relative reactivities are found in acylations of compounds containing two different systems linked together. ... 

In view of the overall increased reactivity of furan compared with thiophene it would be anticipated that furan would be less regioselective in its reactions with electrophiles than thiophene. Possible reasons for the high regioselectivity of furan in electrophilic substitution reactions include complex formation between substrates and reagents and the ability of heteroatoms to assist in the stabilization of cationic intermediates (80CHE1195). 

The most complete discussion of the electrophilic substitution in pyrazole, which experimentally always takes place at the 4-position in both the neutral pyrazole and the cation (Section 4.04.2.1.1), is to be found in (70JCS(B)1692). The results reported in Table 2 show that for (29), (30) and (31) both tt- and total (tt cr)-electron densities predict electrophilic substitution at the 4-position, with the exception of an older publication that should be considered no further (60AJC49). More elaborate models, within the CNDO approximation, have been used by Burton and Finar (70JCS(B)1692) to study the electrophilic substitution in (29) and (31). Considering the substrate plus the properties of the attacking species (H", Cl" ), they predict the correct orientation only for perpendicular attack on a planar site. For the neutral molecule (the cation is symmetrical) the second most reactive position towards H" and Cl" is the 5-position. The activation energies (kJmoF ) relative to the 4-position are H ", C-3, 28.3 C-5, 7.13 Cr, C-3, 34.4 C-5, 16.9. 

The table below gives first-order rate constants for reaction of substituted benzenes with w-nitrobenzenesulfonyl peroxide. From these data, calculate the overall relative reactivity and partial rate factors. Does this reaction fit the pattern of an electrophilic aromatic substitution If so, does the active electrophile exhibit low, moderate, or high substrate and position selectivity ... 

A more practical solution to this problem was reported by Larson, in which the amide substrate 20 was treated with oxalyl chloride to afford a 2-chlorooxazolidine-4,5-dione 23. Reaction of this substrate with FeCL affords a reactive A-acyl iminium ion intermediate 24, which undergoes an intramolecular electrophilic aromatic substitution reaction to provide 25. Deprotection of 25 with acidic methanol affords the desired dihydroisoquinoline products 22. This strategy avoids the problematic nitrilium ion intermediate, and provides generally good yields of 3-aryl dihydroisoquinolines. 

The optimal pH-value for the coupling reaction depends on the reactant. Phenols are predominantly coupled in slightly alkaline solution, in order to first convert an otherwise unreactive phenol into the reactive phenoxide anion. The reaction mechanism can be formulated as electrophilic aromatic substitution taking place at the electron-rich aromatic substrate, with the arenediazonium ion being the electrophile ... 

In an initial step the reactive formylating agent is formed from N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) 2 and phosphorus oxychloride. Other N,N-disubstituted formamides have also found application for example A -methyl-A -phenylformamide is often used. The formylating agent is likely to be a chloromethyl iminium salt 4—also called the Vilsmeier complex (however its actual structure is not rigorously known)—that acts as the electrophile in an electrophilic substitution reaction with the aromatic substrate 1 (see also Friedel-Crafts acylation reaction) ... 

The hydroxyl group is a strongly activating, ortho- and para-directing substituent in electrophilic aromatic substitution reactions (Section 16.4). As a result, phenols are highly reactive substrates for electrophilic halogenation, nitration, sulfonation, and lTiedel-Crafts reactions. 

---