Sonochemical and photochemical

A rough, but useful, comparison between typical sonochemical and photochemical efficiencies is shown in Table I. As shown, homogeneous sonochemistry is typically more efficient than photochemistry, and heterogeneous sonochemistry is several orders of magnitude better. Unlike photochemistry, whose energy inefficiency is inherent in the production of photons, ultrasound can be produced with nearly perfect efficiency from electric power. Still, a primary limitation of sonochemistry remains its... 

Table I. Comparisons Between Sonochemical and Photochemical Apparatuses...

Table 2. Comparisons between sonochemical and photochemical apparatus...

Suslick has pubUshed a rough comparison between typical sonochemical and photochemical efficiencies which demonstrates that homogeneous sonochemistry is typically more efficient than photochemistry and that heterogeneous sonochemistry is several orders of magnitude better [3] (Table 2). 

In 1981, the first report on the sonochemistry of discrete organometallic complexes demonstrated the effect of ultrasound on iron carbonyls in alkane solutions (174). The transition metal carbonyls were chosen for these initial studies because their thermal and photochemical reactivities have been well characterized. The comparison among the thermal, photochemical, and sonochemical reactions of Fe(CO)5 provides an excellent example of the unique chemistry which homogeneous cavitation can... 

Reaction pathway control is a general term implying that reactions can occur by more than one path. Use of specific paths might be governed by a variety of phenomena which may be different for each different reaction. For example, thermal reactions may have entirely different pathways than photochemical, electrochemical, sonochemical and other systems. Electron... 

The first and rate-determining step involves carbon monoxide dissociation from the initial pentacarbonyl carbene complex A to yield the coordinatively unsaturated tetracarbonyl carbene complex B (Scheme 3). The decarbonyla-tion and consequently the benzannulation reaction may be induced thermally, photochemically [2], sonochemically [3], or even under microwave-assisted conditions [4]. A detailed kinetic study by Dotz et al. proved that the initial reaction step proceeds via a reversible dissociative mechanism [5]. More recently, density functional studies on the preactivation scenario by Sola et al. tried to propose alkyne addition as the first step [6],but it was shown that this... 

Zhu et al. [94] reported the synthesis of Sn02 semiconductor nanoparticles by ultrasonic irradiation of an aqueous solution of SnCLj and azodicarbonamide under ambient air. They found that the sonochemically synthesized Sn02 nanoparticles improved remarkably the performance of Li ion batteries such that there was about threefold increase (from 300 to 800 mAh/g) in the reversible capacity in the first lithiation to delithiation cycles. Similarly the irreversible capacity also increased by about 70% (from 800 to 1400 mA h/g). Wang et al. [95] reported the synthesis of positively charged tin porphyrin adsorbed onto the surface of silica and used as photochemically active templates to synthesise platinum and palladium shell and... 

Mark G, Schuchmann MN, Schuchmann H-P, von Sonntag C (1990) The photolysis of potassium peroxodisulphate in aqueous solution in the presence of tert-butanol a simple actinometer for 254 nm radiation. J Photochem Photobiol A Chem 55 157-168 Mark G, Korth H-G, Schuchmann H-P, von Sonntag C (1996) The photochemistry of aqueous nitrate revisited. J Photochem Photobiol A Chem 101 89-103 Mark G, Tauber A, Laupert R, Schuchmann H-P, Schulz D, Mues A, von Sonntag C (1998) OH-radical formation by ultrasound in aqueous solution, part II. Terephthalate and Fricke dosimetry and the influence of various conditions on the sonolytic yield. Ultrason Sonochem 5 41-52 MarkG, Schuchmann H-P, von Sonntag C (2000) Formation of peroxynitrite by sonication of aerated water. J Am Chem Soc 122 3781-3782... 

Extrusion of nitrogen from arylchlorodiazirines formally gives a carbene. In the presence of an olefin, a sonochemical cyclopropanation occurs smoothly under neutral conditions (Eq. 6). The authors state that the procedure is "extraordinarily simple" a diazirine and an olefin are sonicated in a bath in hexane at 40 C, a temperature at which the compounds are thermally stable.66 The reaction occurs in yields equivalent to the photochemical process, but with much greater ease. Good yields are obtained from allyl bromide, 2,3-dimethyl-2-butene, or diethyl... 

The behavior in the same reaction of several phosphorus compounds with a labile P-H bond was investigated under a variety of conditions (homogeneous, heterogeneous, heating, photochemical, sonochemical, "dry medium").Qf these, sonication appears to be especially efficient and selective, but the system is made complex by the important reactivity differences between the various substrates used (phosphonate, phosphine, phosphine oxide, or sulfide) and no general rule can be formulated. 

Of greater interest is the sonolysis of lead tetraacetate (LTA) in the presence of styrene. i In this reaction, several products are formed, 1-phenylpropanol acetate via a radical pathway, and gem- and vie- diacetates via polar mechanisms (Fig. 27). 2 Conventionally, the free radical process is initiated photochemically. The cleavage of LTA to an acetoxyl radical is followed by decarboxylation and the resulting methyl radical adds to the C=C double bond. As expected, the radical process is favored by sonication. These reactions can be considered as an example of sonochemical switching. The mechanism is still unclear, and LTA was found to be stable when sonicated in the absence of styrene.53... 

This domain is necessarily limited, because of the relatively small number of published examples. For instance, in the field of [2+2] additions, only the cases of ketenes or keteniminiums and olefins were investigated sonochemically. No olefin dimerization was reported, making a theoretically interesting comparison between photochemical and sonochemical activations impossible. A few [3+2] dipolar additions were described in papers aimed at synthesis, but the mechanistic aspects were not envisaged. The [4+2] cycloadditions constitute the more important center of interest, and the interpretations below should be considered only as a first attempt on the way towards a rational understanding of a complex domain. 

For Type lb sonochemical effects one may draw a parallel between the ability of sonication to create coordinatively unsatured transition metal complexes and the photochemical activation of resistant C-H bonds in the presence of selected transition metal complexes.22 The only problem in these cases is that one is dealing here with stoichiometric activation in most cases. In photochemistry, most of the corresponding reactions would be characterized by quantum yields smaller than 1. Examples of such reactions can be found in Ch. 2. Therefore, this type of sonochemical activation which creates active species (radicals, nitrenes, transition metal compounds with vacancies) unable to trigger a chain or a catalytic reaction should consume far more energy than Type la. 

We have seen in the first paragraph that some aspects of sonochemical activation are reminiscent of photochemical activation. One important difference remained until recently the use of photochemical sensitizers had little counterpart if any in sonochemical activation. The promoting effect of added p-nitrocumene in the sonochemical version of electron transfer catalysis (Fig. 1), and the role of di-f-butyl-biphenyl in the formation of the dianion of xanthen-9-one (Ch. 5, p. 182) changes this perspective. If it can be proved that this methodology can be generalized by a clever choice of sonochemical activators, the possibilities could be considerably widened, as in the case of electron transfer activation, which opened the way to several new and mild reactions of synthetic interest. A very innovative domain deserves mention even if only a few exploratory works have been conducted thus far the effects of sonication on photochemical reactions. Pioneering works were disclosed by Toma et al A combination of the photochemical and the sonochemical effects should offer a new domain for the search for new selective processes. 

---