Solvolysis salt effect

Figure 5. Solvolysis salt effects and istope effects...

Winstein suggested that two intermediates preceding the dissociated caibocation were required to reconcile data on kinetics, salt effects, and stereochemistry of solvolysis reactions. The process of ionization initially generates a caibocation and counterion in proximity to each other. This species is called an intimate ion pair (or contact ion pair). This species can proceed to a solvent-separated ion pair, in which one or more solvent molecules have inserted between the caibocation and the leaving group but in which the ions have not diffused apart. The free caibocation is formed by diffusion away from the anion, which is called dissociation. 

If (A i[X ]/A 2[Y ]) is not much smaller than unity, then as the substitution reaction proceeds, the increase in [X ] will increase the denominator of Eq. (8-65), slowing the reaction and causing deviation from simple first-order kinetics. This mass-law or common-ion effect is characteristic of an S l process, although, as already seen, it is not a necessary condition. The common-ion effect (also called external return) occurs only with the common ion and must be distinguished from a general kinetic salt effect, which will operate with any ion. An example is provided by the hydrolysis of triphenylmethyl chloride (trityl chloride) the addition of 0.01 M NaCl decreased the rate by fourfold. The solvolysis rate of diphenylmethyl chloride in 80% aqueous acetone was decreased by LiCl but increased by LiBr. ° The 5 2 mechanism will also yield first-order kinetics in a solvolysis reaction, but it should not be susceptible to a common-ion rate inhibition. 

Kinetic studies also provide other evidence for the SnI mechanism. One technique used F NMR to follow the solvolysis of trifluoroacetyl esters. If this mechanism operates essentially as shown on page 393, the rate should be the same for a given substrate under a given set of conditions, regardless of the identity of the nucleophile or its concentration. In one experiment that demonstrates this, benzhy-dryl chloride (Ph2CHCl) was treated in SO2 with the nucleophiles fluoride ion, pyridine, and triethylamine at several concentrations of each nucleophile. In each case, the initial rate of the reaction was approximately the same when corrections were made for the salt effect. The same type of behavior has been shown in a number of other cases, even when the reagents are as different in their nucleophilicities (see p. 438) as H2O and OH . 

A unimolecular ionization was shown to be the mechanism of solvolysis by means of rate studies, solvent effects, salt effects, and structural effects (179,180). The products of reaction consist of benzo [bjthiophen derivatives 209 or nucleophilic substitution products 210, depending upon the solvent system employed. By means of a series of elegant studies, Modena and co-workers have shown that the intermediate ion 208 can have either the open vinyl cation structure 208a or the cyclic thiirenium ion 208b, depending... 

Winstein Robinson (1958) used this concept to account for the kinetics of the salt effects on solvolysis reactions. They considered that carbonium ions (cations) and carbanions could exist as contact ion-pairs, solvated ion-pairs and as free ions and that all these forms participated in the reactions and were in equilibrium with each other. These equilibria can be represented, thus ... 

Winstein, S., Clippinger, E., Fainberg, A. H. Robinson, G. C. (1954). Salt effects and ion-pairs in solvolysis. Journal of the American Chemical Society, 76, 2597-8. 

Only low yields of the azide ion adduct are obtained from the reaction of simple tertiary derivatives in the presence of azide ion 2145 46 and it is not possible to rigorously determine the kinetic order of the reaction of azide ion, owing to uncertainties in the magnitude of specific salt effects on the rate constants for the solvolysis and elimination reactions. Therefore, these experiments do not distinguish between stepwise and concerted mechanisms for substitution reactions at tertiary carbon. 

The difference between A obsd and caic might be due to a specific salt effect on the rate constant for solvolysis. However, this is unlikely because perchlorate ion acts to stabilize carbocations relative to neutral substrates.At high concentrations of sodium bromide, the rate-limiting step for solvolysis of 1-Br is the capture of 1 by solvent (ks Scheme 5A). Substitution of Br for CIO4 should destabilize the carbocation-like transition state for this step relative to the starting neutral substrate, and this would lead to a negative, rather than positive deviation of obsd for equations (3A) and (3B). 

Extensive studies have been carried out on the concentrated salt effects on the solvolysis reaction rates of aliphatic halides and related compounds in acetone-water mixed solvents. The main outcome of the complicated results presented appears to be that Tt is proposed that one could simply distinguish 5n1 from 5n2 reactions merely by observing a substantial increase in the solvolysis rate constant at 1.0 mol dm LiC104 in aqueous mixed solvents. ... 

Salt effects on monomolecular heterolysis reactions (Avrl, El, FI, solvolysis) have been reviewed and me effects of salts on me rate of dehydrobromination of 3-bromocyclohexene have been interpreted. The regiochemistry and stereochemistry... 

The rate constant for solvolysis of the model tertiary substrate 5-Cl is independent of the concentration of added azide ion, and the reaction gives only a low yield of the azide ion adduct (e.g., 16% in the presence of 0.50 M NaNa in 50 50 (v/v) water/trifluoroethanol]." Therefore, this is a borderline reaction for which it is not possible to determine the kinetic order with respect to azide ion, because of uncertainties about specific salt effects on the reaction." ... 

Scheme 5 depicts Winstein s complete solvolysis mechanism.29 Ion-pair return can be from the intimate ion pair (ion-pair return or internal return), from the external ion pair (external ion-pair return), or from the free ions (external ion return). The term external return refers to the sum of external ion-pair return and external ion return. The special salt effect operates by diversion of the external.ion pair, probably through the mechanism shown in Equation 519, so that it can no longer... 

A new Y solvolysis scale has been developed for benzylic species with extensive charge delocalization, based upon the solvolyses of some benzhydryl bromides and /-butyl(2-naphthyl)methyl bromides.39 Chlorides have negative salt effects on the ionization of benzhydryl bromide in 7-butyrolactone.40 The X-ray structure of the dimerization product of l,8-bis(dhnethylammonio)-4-naphthyl(phenyl)methyl carbocation has been determined it appears to be formed via a 4n + 2n-cycloaddition mechanism 41... 

Aroyl esters of anthracene-9-methanol are photolysed in methanol to give products consistent with the anthracene-9-methyl cation as an intermediate.41 Rate constants for the solvolyses of secondary alkyl tosylates in fluorinated solvents were analysed in terms of the possible involvement of very short-lived carbocation-tosylate ion pair intermediates.42 The effect of added electrolytes on the rate of solvolysis of cumyl chloride and its -methyl derivative was studied in 90% aqueous acetone and 80% aqueous DMSO, with the results revealing a combination of a special salt effect and a mass law effect.43 Kinetic parameters obtained for the solvolysis of (8) (R1 = R2 = Me and R1 = Ar, R2 = H) show that there is substantial n, n participation in the transition state [e.g. (9). 44... 

The observation that the rate of loss of optical activity during the solvolysis of certain chiral substrates R — X exceeded the rate of acid production and the occurrence of a special salt effect led to the postulation of two distinct ion-pair intermediates [161, 162]. The basic Winstein solvolysis scheme is given by Eq. (2-20). 

The proposal that cyclopropyl participation in solvolysis of the cis-3-bicyclo[3.1.0]hexyl tosylate (108) proceeds via a trishomocyclopropenyl cation intermediate (109) has been firmly established by product, deuterium scrambling and salt effect studies However, because the cyclopropyl participation in this system requires an unfavorable conformation, it is not apparent from simple kinetic studies. Thus, the cis-3-bicyclo[3.1.0]hexyl tosylate (108) has an acetolysis rate which is only nine times faster than that of the non-participating trans isomer, 110. However, when the 3-bicyclo[3.1.0]hexyl moiety is incorporated into a tricyclic or tetracyclic structure which locks it into a chair form, dramatically large rate enhancements are found. Some examples from the literature which are provided in the review by Haywood-Farmer are given below. These... 

---