Reaction mechanisms carbocations

We can gam a general understanding of the mechanism of hydrogen halide addi tion to alkenes by extending some of the principles of reaction mechanisms introduced earlier In Section 5 12 we pointed out that carbocations are the conjugate acids of alkenes Therefore strong acids such as HCI HBr and HI can protonate the double bond of an alkene to form a carbocation... 

How do we know that the carbocation mechanism for electrophilic addition reactions of alkenes is correct The answer is that we don t know it s correct at least we don t know with complete certainty. Although an incorrect reaction mechanism can be disproved by demonstrating that it doesn t account for observed data, a correct reaction mechanism can never be entirely proved. The best we can do is to show that a proposed mechanism is consistent with all known facts. If enough facts are accounted for, the mechanism is probably correct. 

To understand why a racemic product results from the reaction of T120 wjtl 1-butene, think about the reaction mechanism. 1-Butene is first protonaled tc yield an intermediate secondary (2°) carbocation. Since the trivalent carbon i sp2-hybridized and planar, the cation has no chirality centers, has a plane o symmetry, and is achiral. As a result, it can react with H20 equally well fron either the top or the bottom. Reaction from the top leads to (S)-2-butano through transition state 1 (TS 1) in Figure 9.15, and reaction from the bottorr leads to R product through TS 2. The two transition states are mirror images. The] therefore have identical energies, form at identical rates, and are equally likeb to occur. 

Saul Winstein (1912-1969) was bom in Montreal, Canada, and received his Ph.D. in 1938 at the California Institute of Technology. From 1942 to 1969, he was professor of chemistry at the University of California, Los Angeles, where he devoted his scientific career to the study of organic reaction mechanisms, particularly those involving carbocations. 

Among the experiments that have been cited for the viewpoint that borderline behavior results from simultaneous SnI and Sn2 mechanisms is the behavior of 4-methoxybenzyl chloride in 70% aqueous acetone. In this solvent, hydrolysis (i.e., conversion to 4-methoxybenzyl alcohol) occurs by an SnI mechanism. When azide ions are added, the alcohol is still a product, but now 4-methoxybenzyl azide is another product. Addition of azide ions increases the rate of ionization (by the salt effect) but decreases the rate of hydrolysis. If more carbocations are produced but fewer go to the alcohol, then some azide must he formed by reaction with carbocations—an SnI process. However, the rate of ionization is always less than the total rate of reaction, so some azide must also form by an Sn2 mechanism. Thus, the conclusion is that SnI and Sn2 mechanisms operate simultaneously. ... 

As another example, the tropylium ion [3 ], which is stabilized by virtue of the 67t electrons spread over a heptagonal sp hybridized carbon framework [Hiickel s (4n 4- 2)v rule with = 1], is also unstable in the gas phase. Its formation from toluene or the benzyl cation has been a long-standing problem in organic mass spectrometry, and the reaction mechanism and energetics have recently been exhaustively discussed (Lif-shitz, 1994). It was, however, isolated as the bromide salt by Doering and Knox (1954, 1957), and was the first non-benzenoid aromatic carbocation. 

The reaction mechanism is based on protonation of the hydroxyl moiety, rearrangement of the phenyl group and simultaneous cleavage of water, creating a carbocation as intermediate [135]. This cation is hydroxylated by water. Thereby, an unstable hemiacetal is formed that splits into two molecules, phenol and water. 

Addition of a proton occurs to give the more-substituted carbocation, so addition is regioselective and in accord with Markovnikov s rule. A more detailed discussion of the reaction mechanism is given in Section 6.2 of Part A. Owing to the strongly acidic and rather vigorous conditions required to effect hydration of most alkenes, these conditions are applicable only to molecules that have no acid-sensitive functional groups. The reaction is occasionally applied to the synthesis of tertiary alcohols. 

There are, however, serious problems that must be overcome in the application of this reaction to synthesis. The product is a new carbocation that can react further. Repetitive addition to alkene molecules leads to polymerization. Indeed, this is the mechanism of acid-catalyzed polymerization of alkenes. There is also the possibility of rearrangement. A key requirement for adapting the reaction of carbocations with alkenes to the synthesis of small molecules is control of the reactivity of the newly formed carbocation intermediate. Synthetically useful carbocation-alkene reactions require a suitable termination step. We have already encountered one successful strategy in the reaction of alkenyl and allylic silanes and stannanes with electrophilic carbon (see Chapter 9). In those reactions, the silyl or stannyl substituent is eliminated and a stable alkene is formed. The increased reactivity of the silyl- and stannyl-substituted alkenes is also favorable to the synthetic utility of carbocation-alkene reactions because the reactants are more nucleophilic than the product alkenes. 

The first step of the reaction is likely to be the protonation of ethylene to produce a carbocation that undergoes the direct addition of acetic acid to produce ethyl acetate. The successive addition of ethylene to the carbocation leading to the production of alkene oligomers is a likely side reaction Formation and accumulation of these oligomers could eventually deactivate the catalyst. Detailed studies for a better understanding of the complex reaction mechanism are in progress. 

Reference has already been made in the last chapter to the generation of carbocations, in ion pairs, as intermediates in some displacement reactions at a saturated carbon atom, e.g. the solvolysis of an alkyl halide via the SN1 mechanism. Carbocations are, however, fairly widespread in occurrence and, although their existence is often only transient, they are of considerable importance in a wide variety of chemical reactions. 

The cyclic phosphonium salts 140,141,143,145, and 146 so obtained are evidence for the mechanism of the oxaphospholic cyclization and especially for the main role of the tertiary carbocation formation during the process. The additional data which support this assumption, come from the investigation of the same reaction, but with different substrate, i.e., dimethyl(l,2-hexadienyl)phosphine oxide 147. In this case, the reaction mechanism involved formation of secondary carbocation that gives oxaphosphole product 148 only in 10% yield (Scheme 60) [124],... 

The focus of the next four chapters (Chapters 14-17) is mainly on the theoretical/computational aspects. Chapter 14 by T. S. Sorensen and E. C. F. Yang examines the involvement of p-hydrido cation intermediates in the context of the industrially important heptane to toluene dehydrocyclization process. Chapter 15 by P. M. Esteves et al. is devoted to theoretical studies of carbonium ions. Chapter 16 by G. L. Borosky and K. K. Laali presents a computational study on aza-PAH carbocations as models for the oxidized metabolites of Aza-PAHs. Chapter 17 by S. C. Ammal and H. Yamataka examines the borderline Beckmann rearrangement-fragmentation mechanism and explores the influence of carbocation stability on the reaction mechanism. 

In the early days of alkene chemistry, some researchers found that the hydrohalogenation of alkenes followed Markovnikov s rule, while others found that the same reaction did not. For example, when freshly distilled but-l-ene was exposed to hydrogen bromide, the major product was 2-bromopropane, as expected by Markovnikov s rule. However, when the same reaction was carried out with a sample of but-l-ene that had been exposed to air, the major product was 1-bromopropane formed by antl-Markovnikov addition. This caused considerable confusion, but the mystery was solved by the American chemist, Morris Kharasch, in the 1930s. He realised that the samples of alkenes that had been stored in the presence of air had formed peroxide radicals. The hydrohalogenation thus proceeded by a radical chain reaction mechanism and not via the mechanism involving carbocation intermediates as when pure alkenes were used. 

Primary carbocations Should you wish to use carbocations in a reaction mechanism, you must consider the relative stability of these entities. Tertiary carbocations are OK, and in many cases so are secondary carbocations. Primary carbocations are just not stable enough, unless there is the added effect of resonance, as in benzylic or ally lie systems. 

This notion that reaction mechanisms are strictly enforced by the intermediate lifetime implies the existence of a narrow borderline region and a sharp change in reaction mechanism with changing lifetime of the carbocation intermediate. However, a narrow borderline region is not observed in all cases. The problem is... 

The benzylic substrates X-l-Y and X-2-Y have provided a useful platform for examining the changes in reaction mechanism for nucleophilic substitution that occur as the lifetime of the carbocation intermediate is decreased systematically by varying the meta- and para- aromatic ring substituents. When X is strongly resonance electron-donating, X-l-Y and X-2-Y react by a stepwise mechan-... 

---