Radical reactions spin trapping

Many of the early reports of spin-trapping experiments were focused on mechanistic investigations, and some of these feature in the early reviews (see p. 4). Unfortunately, it is in this application that inferences drawn may be most suspect. For example, the inability of the method to differentiate between radical trapping on the one hand, and a combination of nucleophile trapping with one-electron oxidation on the other, is a serious shortcoming. An early example of this was the tentative conclusion that acetoxyl radicals were spin-trapped by PBN competitively with their decarboxylation in reactions of lead tetraacetate. In view of the rapidity of the decarboxylation reaction, trapping of acetate ion and subsequent oxidation seems a likely alternative. 

Nitroso compounds, nitrones, and other diamagnetic molecules are used as spin traps. Capturing radicals prodnced in the reaction, spin traps form the so-called spin adducts—stable nitroxyl radicals easily detectable by ESR spectroscopy. In other words, the progress of the reaction can easily be followed by an increasing intensity of the spin-adduct signal. By and large, the method of traps reveals radicals by the disappearance (or appearance) of the ESR signal. 

The aim of this section is to give a concise description of the use of traps, to note the most popular traps, and mainly to underline the possible artifacts connected with the application of traps to ion radical reactions. The problem of radical trapping is also relevant because radicals are often the primary products of ion radical transformations. The radicals are, as a rule, not stable, and special traps—radical and spin traps—arc used to reveal them. 

Great care has to be taken in interpreting the results from spin-trapping experiments and they have to be augmented with thorough blank experiments because it is possible to generate free radicals from spin traps in reactions in which free radicals are not involved. 

ESR studies on the initial free radicals were carried out by using MNP(2-methyl-2-nitrosopropane) or DMPO (5,5-dimethylpyrroline N-oxide) as the spin-trapping agent. The reactions are shown as ... 

In spin trapping, radicals are trapped by reaction with a diamagnetic molecule to give a radical product.476 This feature (i.e. that the free spin is retained in the trapped product) distinguishes it from the other trapping methods. The technique involves EPR detection of the relatively stable radicals which result front the trapping of the more transient radicals. No product isolation or separation is required. The use of the technique in studies of polymerization is covered in reviews by Kamachi477 and Yamada ft a/.478... 

The application of RPR in the detection and quantification of species formed by spin-trapping the products of radical-monomer reactions is described in Section 3.5.2.1, The application of time-resolved F.PR spectroscopy to study intermolecular radical-alkene reactions in solution is mentioned in Section 3.5.1. 

Many nitrones and nitroso-compounds have been exploited as spin traps in elucidating radical reaction mechanisms by EPR spectroscopy (Section 3.5.2.1). The initial adducts are nitroxides which can trap further radicals (Scheme 5.17). 

In related work, the reactions of hydrogen peroxide with iron(II) complexes, including Feu(edta), were examined.3 Some experiments were carried out with added 5.5"-dimethyl-1-pyrroline-N-oxide (DMPO) as a trapping reagent fa so-called spin trap) for HO. These experiments were done to learn whether HO was truly as free as it is when generated photochemically. The hydroxyl radical adduct was indeed detected. but for some (not all) iron complexes evidence was obtained for an additional oxidizing intermediate, presumably an oxo-iron complex. 

The reaction of OH radicals with dimethyl sulfoxide in aqueous solution was studied already in 1964 by Norman and coworkers37 38. They used the system T1m-H202 to produce OH radicals and using ESR/rapid mixing techniques they were able to demonstrate elimination of a methyl radical during the OH induced oxidation. Further studies showed the formation of sulfmic radicals in this reaction either directly or by spin trapping experiments39-44. 

It is unfortunate that typical concentrations of free-radical species present in biological systems are only at the limit of e.s.r. detection sensitivity and, of course, there are major technical difficulties in studying whole animals in this manner. Therefore, the most successful e.s.r. experiments have adopted the approach of spin trapping in which very reactive and thus transient radical species are converted to long-lived adducts via reaction with a trap such as a nitrone, e.g. Equation 1.1 ... 

Oxidation of the fatty acids in an LDL particle shares many of the characteristics associated with lipid peroxidation in other biological or chemical systems. Once initiated peroxyl radicals are formed and this results in the oxidation of a-tocopherol to give the a-tocopheroyl radical (Kalyanaraman etal., 1990). This can be demonstrated by e.s.r. techniques that allow the direct observation of stable radicals such as the a-tocopheroyl radical. After the a-tocopheryl radical is consumed, lipid-derived peroxyl radicals can be detected after reaction with spin traps (Kalyanaraman etal., 1990, 1991). 

Despite their short half-lives, it is possible to detect free radicals in biological tissues by the addition of nonradicals such as nitrones or nitroso compounds, which act as spin traps by forming relatively stable free radicals on reaction with the endogenous radical species. Utilizing the technique of electron spin resonance (e.s.r.) spectroscopy, we have demonstrated ROM generation by human rheumatoid synovium when subjected to cycles of hypoxia/normoxia in vitro. Using 3,5-dibromo-4-nitroso-benzenesulphonate (DBNBS) as a spin trap, a... 

Historically, spin traps have been used as an analytical tool to determine the nature of free radicals being generated in reactions (Janzen, 1971). By design, they react with free radicals to form a stable radical product. They... 

The presence of /3-hydrogen in the nitroxide radical may lead to disproportionation reactions. In spin-trapping experiments, N-t-butyl-a-phenyl nitrone yields rather unstable spin adducts. This type of radical can be stabilized by coordination to Nin. The Ni11 complex with N-oxy-A-r-butyl-(2-pyridyl)phenylmethanamine (923) reveals a distorted octahedral geometry with antiferromagnetic interactions between the unpaired electrons of the metal ion and the radical spins.00... 

Spin trapping EPR technique and UV-Vis spectroscopy have been used (Polyakov et al. 2001b) to determine the relative rates of reaction of carotenoids with OOH radicals formed by the Fenton reaction in organic solvents. The Fe3+ species generated via the Fenton reaction... 

Spin trapping methods were also used to show that when carotenoid-P-cyclodextrin 1 1 inclusion complex is formed (Polyakov et al. 2004), cyclodextrin does not prevent the reaction of carotenoids with Fe3+ ions but does reduce their scavenging rate toward OOH radicals. This implies that different sites of the carotenoid interact with free radicals and the Fe3+ ions. Presumably, the OOH radical attacks only the cyclohexene ring of the carotenoid. This indicates that the torus-shaped cyclodextrins, Scheme 9.6, protects the incorporated carotenoids from reactive oxygen species. Since cyclodextrins are widely used as carriers and stabilizers of dietary carotenoids, this demonstrates a mechanism for their safe delivery to the cell membrane before reaction with oxygen species occurs. 

Spin traps which scavenge a reactive radical to give a more persistent radical may be used to detect the intermediacy of such transient radicals in sorting out a reaction mechanism.39... 

Thus, superoxide itself is obviously too inert to be a direct initiator of lipid peroxidation. However, it may be converted into some reactive species in superoxide-dependent oxidative processes. It has been suggested that superoxide can initiate lipid peroxidation by reducing ferric into ferrous iron, which is able to catalyze the formation of free hydroxyl radicals via the Fenton reaction. The possibility of hydroxyl-initiated lipid peroxidation was considered in earlier studies. For example, Lai and Piette [8] identified hydroxyl radicals in NADPH-dependent microsomal lipid peroxidation by EPR spectroscopy using the spin-trapping agents DMPO and phenyl-tcrt-butylnitrone. They proposed that hydroxyl radicals are generated by the Fenton reaction between ferrous ions and hydrogen peroxide formed by the dismutation of superoxide. Later on, the formation of hydroxyl radicals was shown in the oxidation of NADPH catalyzed by microsomal NADPH-cytochrome P-450 reductase [9,10]. 

Recently, Batthyany et al. [133] pointed out that the reduction of cupric ions bound to apolipoprotein B-100 by endogenous LDL components might be an initiation step in copper-mediated LDL oxidation. They suggested that this reaction proceeds to form cuprous ion and the protein-tryptophanyl free radical the latter was identified on the basis of EPR spectrum with spin-trap 2-methyl-2-nitrosopropane. 

---