Projected results, confidence

Considerable attention has also been given to the use of computer dose projections as the basis for initiating off-site protective actions. However, for very severe accidents, dose projections would be available too late and would not be adequate to initiate effective off-site protective response. To be useful, dose projections require an accurate estimate of the amount of material to be released and must project, with confidence, where the release will travel. The problem is that it is virtually impossible to predict the time or measure the magnitude of a severe release. Once the release does occur, its movement through the atmosphere will be very complex. In addition, a severe release may also last several days, ultimately impacting areas in every direction around the plant. The complexity of the resulting contamination (and dose) can be seen in Fig. 5.2, which shows the extent of contamination from the Chernobyl accident. Consequently, dose projections based on models will probably be of little value in the early phase of a severe accident. 

Environmental benefits of Emission Controls. Information in Figure 5 illustrate that the emission of sulphur in eastern North America has declined over the past decade. This decline allows for a possible verification of the dose-response relationships on which the environmental concerns for emissions have been based. A decline in sulphate deposition in Nova Scotia has apparently resulted in a decrease in acidity of eleven rivers over the period 1971-73 to 1981-82 (47), In the Sudbury, Ontario area where emissions have dechned by over 50% between 1974-76 and 1981-83, a resurvey of 209 lakes shows that most lakes have now become less acidic. Twenty-one lakes that had a pH < 5.5 in 1974-76 showed an average decline in acidity of 0.3 pH units over the period (48), Surveys of 54 lakes in the Algoma region of Ontario have shown a rapid response to a decline in sulphate deposition. Two lakes without fish in 1979 have recovered populations as pH of the water moved above 5.5 (49). Evidence is accumulating to support the hypothesis of benefits that were projected as a consequence of emission controls. This provides increased confidence in the projections. 

Both lines of research are far from being closed and we are confident that their development will contribute useful results. However, without considering future performances I think that it can already be said that it is a good strategy to project the future Quantum Chemical methodology in such a way that the WF is by-passed and the 2-RDM or (better still but more difficult) the l-RDM are directly determined. 

The major technical problem was the inability to define subsurface geohydrologic conditions with the initial data. Expertise in the area of geohydrology was clearly needed. A lack of specific analytical techniques precluded meaningful environmental and risk assessments. Cleanup efforts were complicated because poltiners are not regulated under RCRA but are regulated under state law. In the middle of the cleanup effort, the site became involved in Superfund activities, and to date this involvement has not been clarified. Project management has become very difficult because of the many players and laws involved. As a result, public confidence has been affected. 

With these considerations in mind, it becomes clear that the information extraction capability of chemomet-rics can be quite useful in several PAT-relevant situations, especially during the research and development phase of a project, or when one is trying to improve customer confidence in the capability of a calibration. As a result, a short discussion of several common exploratory tools will be made here. 

During the research and development phases of a project financial appraisal can and should be carried out frequently, in order to check that the process under review still constitutes an efficient use of resources. For instance, evaluation of the results of basic research or pilot scale versions of the process etc. are valuable exercises, provided sufficiently accurate information can be generated to enable a confident decision to be made concerning a positive commitment to the next stage of the project. Such information is additionally important since it highlights any inter-relationships between the various steps in the process and the final cost of the product, and indicates those operations where further efforts in process development can give the greatest beneficial effects on the cost of the product. 

Physicians should abstain from engaging in research projects involving human subjects unless they are confident that the risks involved have been assessed adequately and can be managed satisfactorily. Physicians should cease any investigation if the risks are found to outweigh the potential benefits or if there is conclusive proof of positive and beneficial results. 

Clearly the procedures of the laboratories involved in this project could be improved. Before suggesting methods of improvement, one obvious point should be stressed. The results of this study do not vitiate the use of data between laboratories they merely indicate that the data should be used with caution. For example, in the Luristan bronzes (14), the arsenic content of arsenical copper artifacts is said to drop from 2-6% to 2% and below after a tin-copper alloy was introduced about 2600 B.C. If another laboratory analyzes a copper alloy object and finds, say 4.9% arsenic (and all other factors agree), the object can be confidently set into the earlier group if the laboratory finds 0.8% arsenic, the object could be set into the later group. If the arsenic content is 1.95%, the grouping into which it would fall is less unequivocal, and other factors... 

QA splits are particularly valuable for field screening with definitive analysis confirmation and for the verification of field laboratory analysis. The frequency of the QA sample collection is best determined based on the project duration and the total numbers of samples to be collected. Typically, they are collected at a 10 percent frequency (one QA sample for every 10 field samples). It is beneficial to establish data comparability in the early phase of field implementation. If data are comparable, the frequency of QA sampling may be reduced as the confidence in field screening or field laboratory results has been established. But if the data are not comparable, the project team needs to identify the cause of the differences and resolve them as soon as possible in order to avoid making decisions on inaccurate or unrepresentative data. 

If the scope of work involves the manufacture of Phase III Good Manufacturing Practice (GMP) materials, advanced monitoring would be pertinent since this activity could result in the success or failure of a critical path project. The sponsor must be confident that the systems are in place to effectively produce the desired deliverable(s) to complete the project. 

It may be useful to calculate a model project using simple average figures and compare the result with more exact cost assessment methods in order to find the best and simplest way to calculate future budgets with a sufficient degree of exactness and confidence. 

---