Prediction, probability theory

Figure 1-3 shows a comparison of the calculated and experimental spectra. There are two high-energy transitions predicted by theory, around 190 and 240 nm. The first one is clearly visible in the experimental spectrum at the same wavelength, and roughly the same broadening. The second one was predicted to have intensity of 0.01 relative to the first peak, and is probably masked by the broad 200 nm band. Both are n - n transitions localized in the C=C bond in the ring and are likely to be present in most molecules found in the aromatic acid pathways, which hinders... 

Statistics and probability theory provided the analyst with the theoretical framework that predicts the uncertainties in estimating proj rties of populations when only a part of the population is available for investigation. Unfortunately this theory is not well suited for analytical sampling. Mathematical samples have no mass, do not segregate or detoriate, are cheap and are derived from populations with nicely modelled composition, e.g. a Gaussian distribution of independent items. In practice the analyst does not know the type of distribution of the composition, he has usually to do with correlations within the object and the sample or the number of samples must be small, as a sample or sampling is expensive. 

K.R. Popper, on p. 287 of Conjectures and Refutations (Harper and Row, New York 1968), argues that the least probable theories are the most valuable. He means that the more precise predictions a theory makes, the less one would bet on it a priori, but the greater its value when it turns out to be true, i.e., when its a posteriori probability after checking against reality is close to unity. 

Fig. 9.10. Flux dependence of the chemical erosion yield for Tmax and an ion energy of 30 eV determined from spectroscopic measurements in different fusion devices and plasma simulators. The solid lines are a fit using Bayesian probability theory and its confidence intervals [58,59]. The dashed line is a prediction from an earlier analytic description [44]...

In connection with the stability of aqueous solutions of phenothiazine drugs, it has been suggested that simple probability theory could be used to determine the composition of the ionic environment around a drug molecule, and to predict thereby the stability of various salts of the same drug. ... 

The classical mathematical theories by which certain types of uncertainty can be expressed are classical set theory and probability theory. In terms of set theory, uncertainty is expressed by any given set of possible alternatives in situations where only one of the alternatives may actually happen. For example, when an interval of values of a variable is predicted by a given mathematical model, the set of values in the interval represents a predictive uncertainty, when an unsettled historical question allows a set of possible answers rather than a unique one, the set represents a retrodictive uncertainty when medical diagnosis of a patient results in a set of possible diseases rather than a single disease, the set represents a diagnostic uncertainty when design requirements are specified in terms of sets of alternatives, the sets represent a prescriptive uncertainty. 

An alternative interpretation of the Maxwell-Boltzmann speed distribution is helpful in statistical analysis of the experiment. Experimentally, the probability that a molecule selected from the gas will have speed in the range Au is defined as the fraction AN/N discussed earlier. Because AN/N is equal to f u) Au, we interpret this product as the probability predicted from theory that any molecule selected from the gas will have speed between u and u + Au. In this way we think of the Maxwell-Boltzmann speed distribntion f(u) as a probability distribution. It is necessary to restrict Au to very small ranges compared with u to make sure the probability distribution is a continuous function of u. An elementary introdnction to probability distributions and their applications is given in Appendix C.6. We suggest you review that material now. 

An efficient method has been claimed for the enantiomeric enrichment of racemic tartaric acid by irradiation with highly intense, circularly polarized light from an excimer laser.The enrichment is presumed to occur by enantioselec-tive decarboxylation, and further degradation, of the tartaric acid molecules. All previous attempts to achieve such enantioselection with circularly polarized light have produced very low enantiomeric excesses, as predicted by theory. The highly intense laser beam increases the probability of two-photon absorption, and this could result in higher enantioselectivity than attained with lower power sources. It seems advisable, however, to await further confirmatory results before this approach to the resolution of racemic mixtures should be considered viable. 

We have tabulated for comparison the probability of transition predicted by theory and that which is determined by experiment. Certainly the theoretical value fails to agree in magnitude with the experimental one by an amount much greater than the possible experimental error. 

The laminar flow data of Figure 3.39 have a higher slope (0.52 than predicted by theory (0.33)-probably because of "secondary flow effects". The data were taken in a spiral flow thin channel device. Whenever fluid passes through a curved tube or channel, centrifugal forces tend to throw fluid outward from the center of the channel. It then recirculates inward along the walls of the channel (see Figure 3.40). It is well known that coiled tube heat exchangers possesses superior heat transfer characteristics because of secondary flow effects. 

Probably the most direct and, in principle, the most powerful method for determining the distance dependence of steric interactions is the compression of polymer chains attached to macroscopic objects as they undergo close approach. The most successful method to-date has unquestionably been the crossed mica cylinders technique. This was originated by Tabor and coworkers (Tabor and Winterton, 1969 Israelachvili and Tabor, 1972) and improved by Israelachvili and Adams (1976 1978). In the hands of Pashley and Israelachvili (1981), it has been successfully exploited to test the predictions of the Deqaguin-Landau-Verwey-Overbeek (DLVO) theory of electrostatic stabilization. It is also likely in the future to prove to be the most sensitive method for testing the predictions of theories for the distance dependence of steric interactions. 

The observed large values of the carbon contact shifts (rel to H) indicate that the pseudocontact interactions are probably of secondary importance (data for these complexes is in Table LVI). A comparison of the Ni(2+) (acac)2 complexes with the Co(2-l-) derivatives shows that the mode of delocalization is probably different. The shift at the y carbon (shielded carbon for both Ni and Co, deshielded proton Ni, shielded Co) was interpreted in terms of a dominant n delocalization mechanism due to the close agreement of the aicjffiu fatio with that predicted by theory. Both the pC and are deshielded (/ C > fJH). The observed ratio is too large (relative to theory)... 

There has also been, in recent years, an upsurge of interest in matters relating to structural accidents. Reports of enquiries into recent accidents have become compulsive reading, whilst at the same time the redrafting of codes of practice into the limit state format has stimulated inquiry into the use of probability theory to determine suitable partial factors. Another aspect of this interest is the increasing concern about the way in which the behaviour of actual structures differs from the predictions based on idealised theoretical models or on isolated laboratory tests on physical models or elements of structures. 

Flood Frequency. It would be wonderful if flood prediction were reasonably exact. However, the probability of knowing when floods would occur turns out to be a markedly difficult task as it involves frequency analysis, probability theory, data that need to be homogeneous and independent, and selected assumptions that existing stream-flow data would be similar to future flows. This fallacious assumption implies that there will be no changes in future land use and climate. 

---