Nucleophilic substitution tertiary carbon

Up to this point in our discussion, we have considered only carbocations in which the cationic carbon can be 5p -hybridized and planar. When this hybridization cannot be achieved, die carbocations are of higher energy. In a classic experiment, Bartlett and Knox demonstrated that the tertiary chloride 1-chloroapocamphane was inert to nucleophilic substitution. Starting material was recovered unchanged even after refluxing for 48 h in ethanolic silver nitrate. The umeactivity of this compound is attributed to the structure of... 

Identify the substitution pattern of the two epoxide carbon atoms—in this case, one carbon is secondary and one is primary. Then recall the guidelines for epoxide cleavages. An epoxide with only primary and secondary carbons usually undergoes cleavage by SN2-like attack of a nucleophile on the less hindered carbon, but an epoxide with a tertiary carbon atom usually undergoes cleavage by backside attack on the more hindered carbon. In this case, an S]sj2 cleavage of the primary C—O epoxide bond will occur. 

To sum up, primary and secondary substrates generally react by the Sn2 mechanism and tertiary by the SnI mechanism. However, tertiary substrates seldom undergo nucleophilic substitution at all. Elimination is always a possible side reaction of nucleophilic substitutions (wherever a P hydrogen is present), and with tertiary substrates it usually predominates. With a few exceptions, nucleophilic substitutions at a tertiary carbon have little or no preparative value. However, tertiary substrates that can react by the SET mechanism (e.g., /i-N02C6H4CMe2Cl) give very good yields of substitution products when treated with a variety of nucleophiles. ... 

Alkyl halides can be hydrolyzed to alcohols. Hydroxide ion is usually required, except that especially active substrates such as allylic or benzylic types can be hydrolyzed by water. Ordinary halides can also be hydrolyzed by water, if the solvent is HMPA or A-methyl-2-pyrrolidinone." In contrast to most nucleophilic substitutions at saturated carbons, this reaction can be performed on tertiary substrates without significant interference from elimination side reactions. Tertiary alkyl a-halocarbonyl compounds can be converted to the corresponding alcohol with silver oxide in aqueous acetonitrile." The reaction is not frequently used for synthetic purposes, because alkyl halides are usually obtained from alcohols. 

The nucleophilic substitution on poly(vinyl chloroformate) with phenol under phase transfer catalysis conditions has been studied. The 13c-NMR spectra of partly modified polymers have been examined in detail in the region of the tertiary carbon atoms of the main chain. The results have shown that the substitution reaction proceeds without degradation of the polymer and selectively with the chloroformate functions belonging to the different triads, isotactic sequences being the most reactive ones. 

So the tertiary halide reacts by a different mechanism, which we call SnI- It s still a nucleophilic substitution reaction (hence the S and the N ) but this time it is a unimolecular reaction, hence the 1 . The rate-determining step during reaction is the slow unimolecular dissociation of the alkyl halide to form a bromide ion and a carbocation that is planar around the reacting carbon. 

The first evidence that an elimination-addition mechanism could be important in nucleophilic substitution reactions of alkanesulfonyl derivatives was provided by the observation (Truce et al., 1964 Truce and Campbell, 1966 King and Durst, 1964, 1965) that when alkanesulfonyl chlorides RCH2S02C1 were treated in the presence of an alcohol R OD with a tertiary amine (usually Et3N) the product was a sulfonate ester RCHDS020R with exactly one atom of deuterium on the carbon alpha to the sulfonyl group. Had the ester been formed by a base-catalysed direct substitution reaction of R OD with the sulfonyl chloride there would have been no deuterium at the er-position. Had the deuterium been incorporated by a separate exchange reaction, either of the sulfonyl chloride before its reaction to form the ester, or of the ester subsequent to its formation, then the amount of deuterium incorporated would not have been uniformly one atom of D per molecule. The observed results are only consistent with the elimination-addition mechanism involving a sulfene intermediate shown in (201). Subsequent kinetic studies... 

You have read (Unit 10, Class Xll) that the carbon - halogen bond In alkyl or benzyl haUdes can be easily cleaved by a nucleophile. Hence, an allqrl or ben l haUde on reaction with an ethanollc solution of ammonia undergoes nucleophilic substitution reaction m which the halogen atom Is replaced by an amino (-NHJ group. This process of cleavage of the C-X bond by ammonia molecule Is known as ammonolysis. The reaction Is carried out In a sealed tube at 373 K. The primary amine thus obtained behaves as a nucleophile and can further react with allqrl halide to form secondary and tertiary amines, and finally quaternary ammonium salt. 

As we have just seen, SnI reactions are highly favoured at tertiary carbon, and very much disfavoured at primary carbon. This is in marked contrast to Sn2 reactions, which are highly favoured at primary carbon and not at tertiary carbon. With Sn2 reactions, consideration of steric hindrance rationalized the results observed. This leads to the generalizations for nucleophilic substitutions shown in Table 6.8, with secondary substrates being able to participate in either type of process. 

The prominent role of alkyl halides in formation of carbon-carbon bonds by nucleophilic substitution was evident in Chapter 1. The most common precursors for alkyl halides are the corresponding alcohols, and a variety of procedures have been developed for this transformation. The choice of an appropriate reagent is usually dictated by the sensitivity of the alcohol and any other functional groups present in the molecule. Unsubstituted primary alcohols can be converted to bromides with hot concentrated hydrobromic acid.4 Alkyl chlorides can be prepared by reaction of primary alcohols with hydrochloric acid-zinc chloride.5 These reactions proceed by an SN2 mechanism, and elimination and rearrangements are not a problem for primary alcohols. Reactions with tertiary alcohols proceed by an SN1 mechanism so these reactions are preparatively useful only when the carbocation intermediate is unlikely to give rise to rearranged product.6 Because of the harsh conditions, these procedures are only applicable to very acid-stable molecules. 

For all the above examples, the nucleophilic attack takes place at the tertiary carbon atom of the (oxa/thia)azoline ring. However in two particular cases, namely for the fluoromethyl substituted dioxazoline (158) <84JOC9i9> and the unusual oxathiazoline (159) <74ZOR39>, the nucleophiles attack at the sp ring carbon according to Scheme 25, and Equation (4)). 

Students of reaction mechanism will recognize intuitively that the difference between the narrow and broad borderline regions observed for nucleophilic substitution of azide ion at secondary and tertiary carbon (Fig. 2.2) is due to the greater steric hindrance to bimolecular nucleophilic substitution at the tertiary carbon. This leads to a large difference in the effects of an a-Me group on (s ) for the stepwise solvolysis and s ) for concerted bimolecular nucleophilic... 

The essential features of the mechanism for aliphatic nucleophilic substitution at tertiary carbon were established in studies by Hughes and Ingold." ° However, as chemists probed more deeply, the problems associated with the characterization of borderline reaction mechanisms were encountered, and controversy remains to this day about whether these problems have been entirely solved." What is generally accepted is that ferf-butyl derivatives undergo borderline solvolysis reactions through a ferf-butyl carbocation intermediate that is too unstable to diffuse freely through nucleophilic solvents such as methanol and water. The borderline nature of substitution reactions at tertiary carbon is exemplihed by the following observations. 

An important question is whether nucleophilic substitution at tertiary carbon proceeds though a carbocation intermediate that shows a significant chemical barrier to the addition of solvent and other nucleophiles. The yield of the azide ion substitution product from the reaction of 5-Cl is similar to that observed for the reactions of X-2-Y when this product forms exclusively by conversion of the preassociation complex to product. Therefore the carbocation 5 is too unstable to escape from an aqueous solvation shell and undergo diffusion-controlled trapping by azide ion. This result sets a lower limit of w fcj > -d 1.6 x 10 ° s (Scheme 2.4) " for addition of solvent to the ion pair intermediate 5" C1 . 

There is an ongoing controversy about whether there is any stabilization of the transition state for nucleophilic substitution at tertiary aliphatic carbon from interaction with nucleophilic solvent." ° This controversy has developed with the increasing sophistication of experiments to characterize solvent effects on the rate constants for solvolysis reactions. Grunwald and Winstein determined rate constants for solvolysis of tert-butyl chloride in a wide variety of solvents and used these data to define the solvent ionizing parameter T (Eq. 3). They next found that rate constants for solvolysis of primary and secondary aliphatic carbon show a smaller sensitivity (m) to changes in Y than those for the parent solvolysis reaction of tert-butyl chloride (for which m = 1 by definition). A second term was added ( N) to account for the effect of changes in solvent nucleophilicity on obsd that result from transition state stabilization by a nucleophilic interaction between solvent and substrate. It was first assumed that there is no significant stabilization of the transition state for solvolysis of tert-butyl chloride from such a nucleophilic interaction. However, a close examination of extensive rate data revealed, in some cases, a correlation between rate constants for solvolysis of fert-butyl derivatives and solvent nucleophicity. " ... 

---