Multicomponent Distillation Efficiency Models

Two different approaches have evolved for the simulation and design of multicomponent distillation columns. The conventional approach is through the use of an equilibrium stage model together with methods for estimating the tray efficiency. This approach is discussed in Chapter 13. An alternative approach based on direct use of matrix models of multicomponent mass transfer is developed in Chapter 14. This nonequilibrium stage model is also applicable, with only minor modification, to gas absorption and liquid-liquid extraction and to operations in trayed or packed columns. 

In fact, through use of matrix models of mass transfer in multicomponent systems (as opposed to effective diffusivity methods) it is possible to develop methods for estimating point and tray efficiencies in multicomponent systems that, when combined with an equilibrium stage model, overcome some of the limitations of conventional design methods. The purpose of this chapter is to develop these methods. We look briefly at ways of solving the set of equations that model an entire distillation column and close with a review of experimental and simulation studies that have been carried out with a view to testing multicomponent efficiency models. 

In view of the large influence of interaction effects found by Toor and Burchard (1960) it is a little surprising that there have been so few design calculations reported in the literature. More experience with these models is required before definitive conclusions can be made regarding the use of complicated efficiency models in sophisticated distillation codes. The whole issue of multicomponent mass transfer models in distillation column simulation is taken up again in Chapter 14. 

Chapter 12 presents models of mass transfer on distillation trays. This material is used to develop procedures for the estimation of point and tray efficiencies in multicomponent distillation in Chapter 13. Chapter 14 uses the material of Chapter 12 in quite a different way in an alternative approach to the simulation and design of distillation and absorption columns that has been termed the nonequilibrium stage model. This model is applicable to liquid-liquid extraction with very little modification. Chapter 15 considers the design of mixed vapor condensers. 

Krishna R (1985) Model for prediction of point efficiencies for multicomponent distillation. Chem Eng Res Des 63(5) 312-322... 

Availability of large digital computers has made possible rigorous solutions of equilibrium-stage models for multicomponent, multistage distillation-type columns to an exactness limited only by the accuracy of the phase equilibrium and enthalpy data utilized. Time and cost requirements for obtaining such solutions are very low compared with the cost of manual solutions. Methods are available that can accurately solve almost any type of distillation-type problem quickly and efficiently. The material presented here covers, in some... 

Song HW, Wang SY, Han JC, Wu JW (1996) A new model for predicting distillation point efficiencies of non-ideal multicomponent mixture. CIESC J 47(5) 571... 

---