Molecular orbitals and valence bond theory

Keywords Polarizable force field, Molecular orbital and valence bond theory, Nuclear quantum... 

Equation (4-5) can be directly utilized in statistical mechanical Monte Carlo and molecular dynamics simulations by choosing an appropriate QM model, balancing computational efficiency and accuracy, and MM force fields for biomacromolecules and the solvent water. Our group has extensively explored various QM/MM methods using different quantum models, ranging from semiempirical methods to ab initio molecular orbital and valence bond theories to density functional theory, applied to a wide range of applications in chemistry and biology. Some of these studies have been discussed before and they are not emphasized in this article. We focus on developments that have not been often discussed. 

It will now be clear that the accuracy that may be attained in crystal analysis depends on the number of observed reflections and on the precision with which their intensities can be measured. (We assume that the structure is not complicated by any randomness or disorder, and that the necessary absorption and extinction corrections can be made.) A very useful discussion of the requirements necessary for determining bond lengths to within a limit of error of 0-01 A has been given by Cruickshank (1960). This is, of course, a very ambitious limit, but if it could be achieved it would enable the predictions of the molecular-orbital and valence-bond theories in aromatic hydrocarbons to be distinguished. It is pointed out that at the 0-1% level of significance a bond length difference must be 3-3 times the standard deviation to be accepted as genuine, so the limit of error of 0-01 A would require an e.s.d. (estimated standard deviation) of 0-003 A or better in the bond difference, or a coordinate e.s.d. of 0-0015 A or better. 

BRIDGES BETWEEN MOLECULAR ORBITAL AND VALENCE BOND THEORIES... 

Solvent effects can significantly influence the function and reactivity of organic molecules.1 Because of the complexity and size of the molecular system, it presents a great challenge in theoretical chemistry to accurately calculate the rates for complex reactions in solution. Although continuum solvation models that treat the solvent as a structureless medium with a characteristic dielectric constant have been successfully used for studying solvent effects,2,3 these methods do not provide detailed information on specific intermolecular interactions. An alternative approach is to use statistical mechanical Monte Carlo and molecular dynamics simulation to model solute-solvent interactions explicitly.4 8 In this article, we review a combined quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical (QM/MM) method that couples molecular orbital and valence bond theories, called the MOVB method, to determine the free energy reaction profiles, or potentials of mean force (PMF), for chemical reactions in solution. We apply the combined QM-MOVB/MM method to... 

Examples of some of the types of information that may be obtained from such modem VB wave functions have been illustrated here by means of applications to the ground state of benzene, to the and a A state of FeH, and to the two lowest Ag states of various model polyene systems. It has to be hoped that widespread use of the CASVB procedures via packages such as molpro [8] could diminish the traditional barriers between molecular orbital and valence bond theory. 

C. A. Coulson, Valence, 2d ed., Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1961. Thorough treatments of molecular-orbital and valence-bond theories. 

Coulson continued to be preoccupied with the conceptual foundations of the molecular orbital theory, of the valence bond theory, and about the criteria for their comparison. He strongly believed that despite the extensive use of quantum mechanics, it was still not possible to either choose one of the theories as superior to the other or to consider them as competing approaches. This had been in fact one of the main controversies raging over the first decade of quantum chemistry "we all learned about the molecular-orbital and valence-bond theories, and we became as partisan about them as, in Britain, we are partisan about the Oxford and Cambridge Universities boat race on the Thames " (Coulson 1970, 259). 

In hybridization, molecular orbital, and valence bond theory, not only is energy conserved, but also the number of orbitals is conserved. For example, for an sp hybridized atom, there is still one p orbital left over and for an sp hybridized atom, there are two unhybridized p orbitals left over. Carbon readily uses the leftover p orbitals to form TT bonds (see page 482). In contrast, silicon, the element one below carbon, does not use the p orbitals as readily to form tt bonds. As we will see in Section 11-4, the formation of a 77 bond involves the side-to-side overlap of unhybridized p orbitals. An unhybridized 3p orbital of silicon does not project out far enough to form 77 bonds. 

Abstract The wave function of Coulson and Fischer is examined within the context of recent developments in quantum chemistry. It is argued that the Coulson-Fischer ansatz establishes a third way in quantum chemistry, which should not be confused with the traditional molecular orbital and valence bond formalisms. The Coulson-Fischer theory is compared with modern valence bond approaches and also modern multireference correlation methods. Because of the non-orthogonality problem which arises when wave functions are constructed from arbitrary orbital products, the application of the Coulson-Fischer method to larger molecules necessitates the introduction of approximation schemes. It is shown that the use of hierarchical orthogonality restrictions has advantages, combining a picture of molecular electronic structure which is an accord with simple, but nevertheless empirical, ideas and concepts, with a level of computational complexity which renders praetieal applications to larger molecules tractable. An open collaborative virtual environment is proposed to foster further development. 

In this section the molecular orbital and valence bond approaches to bonding in the hydrogen molecule will be compared. In their simplest forms we shall find that valence bond theory is better than MO theory, but as the models become more sophisticated the results obtained by the two methods converge to give the exact experimental result. 

However these debates resolve, it is safe to say that chemists justifications for using highly idealized models are not merely pragmatic. Simple molecular orbital and valence bond models are not in widespread use simply because of uncertainties about the fundamental theory, lack of data, or computational difficulties. Rather, the use of such models is tied to the explanatory practices of chemistry and the use of such models is likely to be an enduring part of chemical theorizing. 

Structure. The straiued configuration of ethylene oxide has been a subject for bonding and molecular orbital studies. Valence bond and early molecular orbital studies have been reviewed (28). Intermediate neglect of differential overlap (INDO) and localized molecular orbital (LMO) calculations have also been performed (29—31). The LMO bond density maps show that the bond density is strongly polarized toward the oxygen atom (30). Maximum bond density hes outside of the CCO triangle, as suggested by the bent bonds of valence—bond theory (32). The H-nmr spectmm of ethylene oxide is consistent with these calculations (33). 

The exceptions to the octet rule described in the previous section, the xenon compounds and the tri-iodide ion, are dealt with by the VSEPR and valence bond theories by assuming that the lowest energy available d orbitals participate in the bonding. This occurs for all main group compounds in which the central atom forms more than four formal covalent bonds, and is collectively known as hypervalence, resulting from the expansion of the valence shell This is referred to in later sections of the book, and the molecular orbital approach is compared with the valence bond theory to show that d orbital participation is unnecessary in some cases. It is essential to note that d orbital participation in bonding of the central atom is dependent upon the symmetry properties of individual compounds and the d orbitals. 

Most organic chemists are familiar with two very different and conflicting descriptions of the 7r-electron system in benzene molecular orbital (MO) theory with delocalized orthogonal orbitals and valence bond (VB) theory with resonance between various canonical structures. An attitude fostered by many text books, especially at the undergraduate level, is that the VB description is much easier to understand and simpler to use, but that MO theory is in some sense more fundamental . 

A theoretical study on the reaction mechanism for the Bergman cyclization from the perspective of the Electron Localization Function and Catastrophe Theory has been reported.175 The authors argue that topological analysis of electron localization function can be used to complement the molecular orbital- or valence bond-based methods. 

The topic of interactions between Lewis acids and bases could benefit from systematic ab initio quantum chemical calculations of gas phase (two molecule) studies, for which there is a substantial body of experimental data available for comparison. Similar computations could be carried out in the presence of a dielectric medium. In addition, assemblages of molecules, for example a test acid in the presence of many solvent molecules, could be carried out with semiempirical quantum mechanics using, for example, a commercial package. This type of neutral molecule interaction study could then be enlarged in scope to determine the effects of ion-molecule interactions by way of quantum mechanical computations in a dielectric medium in solutions of low ionic strength. This approach could bring considerable order and a more convincing picture of Lewis acid base theory than the mixed spectroscopic (molecular) parameters in interactive media and the purely macroscopic (thermodynamic and kinetic) parameters in different and varied media or perturbation theory applied to the semiempirical molecular orbital or valence bond approach [11 and references therein]. 

---