Hydrogen electron correlation

A very important difference between H2 and molecular orbital calculations is electron correlation. Election correlation is the term used to describe interactions between elections in the same molecule. In the hydrogen molecule ion, there is only one election, so there can be no election correlation. The designators given to the calculations in Table 10-1 indicate first an electron correlation method and second a basis set, for example, MP2/6-31 G(d,p) designates a Moeller-Plesset electron coiTclation extension beyond the Hartiee-Fock limit canied out with a 6-31G(d,p) basis set. 

Most MO methods find a bond alternation pattern in the minimum-energy structure, but calculations that include electron correlation lead to a delocalized minimum-energy structure. Thus, although the n system in 1 is not completely planar, it appears to be sufficiently close to provide a delocalized 10-electron Ji system. A resonance energy of 17.2 kcal has been obtained on the basis of an experimental heat of hydrogenation. ... 

The experimental bond length for the hydrogen fluoride molecule is 0.917A. Determine the basis set required to predict this structure accurately. Perform your optimizations at the MP4 level of theory (electron correlation is known to be important for this system). 

We can compute all of the results except those in the first row by running just three jobs QCISD(T,E4T] calculations on HF and fluorine and a Hartree-Fock calculation on hydrogen (with only one electron, the electron correlation energy is zero). Note that the E4T option to the QCISDfT) keyword requests that the triples computation be included in the component MP4 calculation as well as in the QCISD calculation (they are not needed or computed by default). 

The optimum value of c is determined by the variational principle. If c = 1, the UHF wave function is identical to RHF. This will normally be the case near the equilibrium distance. As the bond is stretched, the UHF wave function allows each of the electrons to localize on a nucleus c goes towards 0. The point where the RHF and UHF descriptions start to differ is often referred to as the RHF/UHF instability point. This is an example of symmetry breaking, as discussed in Section 3.8.3. The UHF wave function correctly dissociates into two hydrogen atoms, however, the symmetry breaking of the MOs has two other, closely connected, consequences introduction of electron correlation and spin contamination. To illustrate these concepts, we need to look at the 4 o UHF determinant, and the six RHF determinants in eqs. (4.15) and (4.16) in more detail. We will again ignore all normalization constants. 

It should be noted that CASSCF methods inherently tend to give an unbalanced description, since all the electron correlation recovered is in die active space, but none in the inactive space, or between the active and inactive electrons. This is not a problem if all the valence electrons are included in the active space, but this is only possible for small systems. If only part of die valence electrons are included in the active space, the CASSCF methods tend to overestimate the importance of biradical structures. Consider for example acetylene where the hydrogens have been bent 60° away from hnearity (this may be considered a model for ort/zo-benzyne). The in-plane jt-orbital now acquires significant biradical character. The true structure may be described as a hnear combination of the three configurations shown in Figure 4.11. 

The basis set is 6-31G(d,p), and electron correlation at the MP2 level is included. A similar structure is obtained with the AMI and PM3 semi-empirical methods. Density functional theory at the B3LYP/6-31G(dp,p) level also produced the same structure for this ion-pair. The only observed differences between the semi-empiri-cal and the ab initio structures were slightly shorter hydrogen bonds (PM3 and AMI) between FI, F2, and F5 and the G2-F1 (H18) on the imidazolium ring. 

Paldus J, Li X (1999) Electron Correlation in Small Molecules Grafting Cl onto CC. 203 1-20 Paleos CM, Tsiourvas D (2003) Molecular Recognition and Hydrogen-Bonded Amphiphilies. 227 1-29... 

Teppen, B. J., M. Cao, R. F. Frey, C. Van Alsenoy, D. M. Miller, and L. Schafer. 1994a. An Investigation into Intramolecular Hydrogen Bonding Impact of Basis Set and Electron Correlation on the Ab Initio Conformational Analysis of 1,2-Ethanediol and 1,2,3-Propanetriol. J. Mol. Struct. (Theochem) 314,169-190. 

Ab initio electron correlated calculations of the equilibrium geometries, dipole moments, and static dipole polarizabilities were reported for oxadiazoles <1996JPC8752>. The various measures of delocalization in the five-membered heteroaromatic compounds were obtained from MO calculations at the HF/6-31G level and the application of natural bond orbital analysis and natural resonance theory. The hydrogen transfer and aromatic energies of these compounds were also calculated. These were compared to the relative ranking of aromaticity reported by J. P. Bean from a principal component analysis of other measures of aromaticity <1998JOC2497>. 

Notwithstanding, after hydrogen, helium is also the simplest naturally available atomic species, which, in contrast to one electron atoms, exhibits the additional electron-electron interaction, as a source of electronic correlations. Hence, helium is one of the simplest systems where electronic correlations can be studied. Direct manifestations of electronic correlations have been found, e.g., in doubly excited states of helium localized along highly asymmetric, though very stable, frozen planet configurations (FPC) (K. Richter et.al., 1990), or scarred by... 

GIAO-HF calculated chemical shifts using a TZP basis for carbon and a DZ basis for hydrogen for the MP2/6-31G(d) optimized geometry of the vinyl cation 28 show large errors of up to 45 ppm because electron correlation is not taken into account (Scheme 2). GIAO-MP2 calculations consider interactions among electrons... 

The Hartree-Fock method was in any case the method of choice for the first quantitative calculations related to homogeneous catalysis. It was the method, for instance, on a study of the bonding between manganese and hydride in Mn-H, published in 1973 [28]. The first studies on single steps of catalytic cycles in the early 1980 s used the HF method [29]. And it was also the method applied in the first calculation of a full catalytic cycle, which was the hydrogenation of olefins with the Wilkinson catalyst in 1987 [30]. The limitations of the method were nevertheless soon noticed, and already in the late 1980 s, the importance of electron correlation was being recognized [31]. These approaches will be discussed in detail in the next section. 

On the other hand, accurate calculations beyond the level of the independent particle approximation are very rare. Recently, a detailed study of (HF) 2 was published 82> in which the influence of electron correlation on the properties of the hydrogen bond was investigated. 

In order to answer these questions, accurate experimental and theoretical results were needed for representative molecular systems. Theoreticians, for obvious reasons, have favored very simple systems, such as the hydrogen molecular ion (Hj) for their calculations. However, with only one electron, this system did not provide a proper test case for the molecular quantum mechanical methods due to the absence of the electron correlation. Therefore, the two-electron hydrogen molecule has served as the system on which the fundamental laws of quantum mechanics have been first tested. 

---