Hawthorne Effect

Placebo response may be related to the Hawthorne effect. - As the practitioner provides more attention to the patient s health, there is often an increased desire of the patient to please the caregiver and to express appreciation for an effective intervention. 

R. D. Hawthorn, Effect of Radial Temperature Variation of Axial Mixing in Pipes, AJ.Ch,E, Journal, 6,443 (1960). 

Measurement Gathering the information distorts it Hawthorne effect Control group/placebo group... 

The Hawthorne effect usually refers to an effect of the involvement of researchers or other outsiders upon the measured outcome. This term arose from a famous study of factory workers at Western Electric s Hawthorne Works in the 1920s. A subset of workers was moved to a different section of the factory, their working conditions manipulated and the effect of this on their productivity observed. It turned out that workers were more productive under any of the work conditions tried—even an uncomfortable one like low lighting conditions. It is believed that the effect of the new psychosocial working conditions (i.e., increased involvement of workers) in the experimental simation actually overshadowed any effect of the changes in the physical environment. 

Example of a Hawthorne Threat A work-site decides to implement and evaluate a new training program focused on changing safety practices by providing feedback to employees. A consultant examines injuiy records and, with the help of workers and supervisors, develops a checklist of safety practices. The list will be used by the consultant to observe the work force and provide feedback to the employees about their practices. The consultant realizes that his presence (and the taking of observations) could make workers change their normal behavior. To avoid this potential Hawthorne effect, he makes baseline observations on a daily basis until his presence seems to no longer create a reaction and the observations become constant [p. 25]. 

Create endless Hawthorne effects (new goals, new themes and new events as the antidote to the 12-18 month doldrums)... 

Regardless of external validation methodology, sources of bias like the Hawthorne effect (that any change in a standard environment is perceived by individuals in that environment to be positive) are likely to get in the way of objective analysis. When faced with using an ITS, students will by definition work and learn more effectively due to the very novelty of the ITS, rather than particular attributes of the ITS. This problem has bedevilled scientiric attempts to prove that LOGO, for example, is a better way of teaching mathematical reasoning than more traditional approaches. 

The Hawthorne effect usually refers to an effect of the involvement of researchers or other outsiders upon the measured outcome. This term arose from a famous study of factory... 

If we apply the lessons of the Hawthorne Effect to near miss incident reporting, we find the very foundation of safety motivation. Near miss incident reporting is not simply a discipline or a set of precepts that must be imposed from above. It must involve the worker, recognize the worker, and perhaps even reward the worker. 

National Occupational Safety Association (NOSA).1990. We shall call it the Hawthorne Effect. Safety Management Training Course (SAMTRAC). Pretoria, SA NOSA. 

Cocco G. Erectile dysfunction after therapy with metoprolol the Hawthorne effect. Cardiology 2009 112 174-7. 

Perhaps the PMI data and the introduction to the Hawthorne effect and further evidence presented near the end of this written guidance section, even though they may not pertain directly to whatever you and your organization do, will cause you and to give further thought to implementing written guidance for repetitive tasks and processes. It will help you achieve quality, that is, meet all requirements. 

---