Facts, as evidence

In another work, Z. Chen et al. have added dropwise diluted bromine to Triton X-100 suspended SWNTs and SWNT bundles and observed sedimentation of tube material enriched in metallic SWNTs [128]. No enrichment was observed for experiments using sodium dodecyl sulfonate as surfactant. The authors take this experimental fact as evidence that the enrichment mechanism involves bromine-induced destabilization of the Triton X-100 surfactant shell, with greater specificity for metallic SWNTs. 

Students also find it difficult to accept anything other than empirical facts as evidence for the existence of a problem which requires a solution. Second year students at the University of Western Australia were asked to critically analyse alternative sources of energy with a social justice lens in their preliminary analysis of the effect of wind turbines, it was clear that they were dismissive of subjective statements made by farming communities about the effect of the noise on their health. Downplaying the health costs of development is a common problem, particularly in the mining sector (e.g. Brueckner and Ross 2010) and students are asked, not just whether it is possible to be objective, value-free and scientific but to what extent self-interest drives these positivist attributes. They are introduced to different knowledge systems, and also asked to question notions of scientific expertise which often assume there to be one basic truth known by the experts. 

Attempts have been made to deduce the structure of the predominant form of a potentially tautomeric compound from the shifts which occur in the ultraviolet spectrum of the compound in question on passing from neutral to basic or acidic solutions. The fact that no bathochromic shifts were observed for 2- and 4-hydroxy quinoline and 1-hydroxyisoquinoline under these conditions was taken as evidence that they existed in the oxo form [similar work on substituted quinol-4-ones led to no definite conclusions ]. A knowledge of the dissociation constants is essential to studies of this type, and the conclusions can, in any case, be only very tentative. A further dif-... 

As demonstrated in Fig. 5.7, the result indicates that two-phase flow patterns observed in a 100 pm quartz tube are almost similar to those observed in a 25 pm silica capillary tube with several exceptions. One such exceptions is that in slug flow encountered at low velocities, small liquid droplets in a gas slug stick to the tube wall (Fig. 5.8). This fact is evidence that no liquid film exisfs befween fhe gas slug and the tube wall. 

The fact that ) -D-galactosidase from Escherichia coli is inactivated more rapidly in the absence of Mg than in its presence can be taken as evidence that the activation of the triazene 38, that is, formation of )5-D-galactosyl-methyldiazonium ion, proceeds without acid catalysis, because Mg is required for the proton-assisted catalysis of yS-D-galactoside hydrolysis by this enzyme.Additional evidence for the absence of acid catalysis in the de-... 

The difference in stabilities of cation radicals located on G, GG, and GGG sequences was initially investigated by Sugiyama and Saito [14], who employed ab initio methods to calculate the gas phase ionization potentials of nucleobases stacked in B-DNA geometries. Their results indicated large differences in potential for holes on G vs GG (0.47 eV) and GGG (0.68 eV) sequences. A similar G vs GG difference was calculated by Prat et al. [62]. These values suggest that GG and GGG are, in fact, deep hole traps and they have been widely cited as evidence to that effect [54, 63]. 

In Section 3.1 it was shown that the photoreduction of benzophenone can be quenched by addition of small amounts of triplet quenchers such as oxygen or ferric dipivaloylmethide.<60) In fact this was presented as evidence that the benzophenone triplet was involved in the photoreduction. This reaction can also be quenched by naphthalene. In the presence of naphthalene, light is still absorbed by benzophenone and thus benzophenone triplets are produced. However, photoreduction products are decreased. On examining this reaction with flash photolysis, triplet-triplet absorptions were observed but these absorptions corresponded to those of the naphthalene triplet. Thus the triplet excitation energy originally present in the benzophenone triplet must have been transferred to naphthalene and since little of the photoreduction product was observed, this transfer must have been fast in relation... 

---