Evolution of the code

We can easily imagine a period when no code was existing, and any tRNA could bind to any amino acid irrespective of its anticodon. In these conditions, peptide bonds were made at random, and only statistical proteins were synthesised. Let us suppose now that one of the tRNAs underwent a change that allowed it to bind only one particular amino acid. This is equivalent to the appearance of a single 

We find a similar process in the evolution of linguistic codes. The sounds uttered by the first speakers were probably little more than random combinations of vowels and consonants, at the beginning then they were divided into a few major categories (sounds of friendship, enmity, fear, satisfaction, etc.), and finally they managed to express an increasing number of meanings. The evolution of the rules went on hand in hand with the evolution of the words, and the two processes, although intrinsically different, evolved in parallel. 

We conclude that, during postchemical evolution, what was taking place was not only a development of metabolic structures, but also an evolution of coding rules, of natural conventions. The true mechanism of postchemical evolution, in other words, was not genetic drift alone, but a combination of drift and natural conventions. To the classical concepts of evolution by genetic drift and by natural selection, we must add therefore the concept of evolution by natural conventions. 

It is important to notice that this is very different from the mechanism of chemical evolution. Kauffman and Dyson, it will be remembered, have shown that the probability of a spontaneous transition from chaos to order increases with the complexity of the system, but in this case the order (or antichaos) is not a result of natural conventions and has nothing to do with organic codes. 

This tells us that chemical evolution was really different from postchemical evolution. In the course of chemical evolution, the jump of primitive metabolic systems from chaos to order was only a question of statistical probability and energy conditions. During postchemical evolution, instead, a new type of antichaos appeared, an order that was based on conventional rules of correspondence between two independent molecular worlds, and it was from these first natural conventions that the genetic code finally emerged. 

---

But the enigma of the origin of the genetic Code stays with us. Half a dozen theories all attempt to explain the evolution of the Code. 

Recently, an asymmetric codon assignment rule was proposed. Evidence was found for a rapid early evolution of the Code via successive binary choices of 16 X X2N codons. It was claimed that the other scenarios (listed above in points 1-5) could have played a role in different periods of the evolving Genetic Code. 

In 1994, a conference with the title Aminoacyl-tRNA Synthetases and the Evolution of the Genetic Code was held in Berkeley, California its patron was the Institute of Advanced Studies in Biology. The conference dealt with the development of the synthetases and that of the genetic code (see Sect. 8.2), i.e., the assignment of the various amino acids to the corresponding base triplets of the nucleic acids. 

The close connection of this enzyme family with the transfer of genetic information has made it a popular object of study when dealing with questions regarding the formation and evolution of the genetic code (see Sect. 8.1). It is now agreed that the aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases are a very ancient enzyme species which do not, however, arise from one single primeval enzyme, but from at least two, corresponding to the synthetase classes. 

Table 8.2 According to the co-evolution theory proposed by Wong, the biosynthetic routes to amino acids from their precursors could perhaps provide information on the evolution of the genetic code (Wong, 1975)...

An important factor in the evolution of the genetic code is certainly provided by the aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (see Sect. 5.3.2). It is clear that the two synthetase classes are not randomly distributed across the matrix of the amino acid assignment of the genetic code. For example, with one exception, all XUX codons code for class 1 synthetases, while all XCX codons code for class 2 aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. A possible explanation could be that the synthetases and the genetic code evolved simultaneously. However, it is more likely that these enzymes evolved when the genetic code had already been established (Wetzel, 1995). 

One important question is that of the order in which the basic mechanisms of evolution processes, leading eventually to the emergence of life, occurred. As far as the development of the genetic code is concerned, it is not clear whether the code evolved prior to the aminoacylation process, i.e., whether aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases evolved before or after the code. A tRNA species which is aminoacy-lated by two different synthetases was studied if this tRNA had important identity elements such as the discriminator base and the three anticodon bases for the two synthetases, this would be evidence that the aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases had developed after the genetic code. Dieter Soil s group, which is experienced in working with this family of enzymes, came to the conclusion that the universal genetic code must have developed before the evolution of the aminoacylation system (Hohn et al, 2006). 

A further (mathematical) model for the evolution of the genetic code was devised by Carl Woese and co-workers. This dynamic theory provides information on the evolvability and universality of the genetic code. One conceptual difficulty was due to the fact that it had been overlooked that the genetic code was highly communal... 

A detailed treatment of the evolution of the genetic code requires modelling physical components of the translational process this includes the dynamic processes of the tRNAs and the aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (Vetsigian et al., 2006). Thus, in spite of considerable advances in the search for the roots of the genetic code, there is still much to do ... 

In evolution parts of the code, even parts essential for independent functioning, have been lost so that higher organisms are dependent on vitamins, for example for coenzymes, and on amino acids, lipids and saccharides, or even on selenium incorporation, from other forms of life. This is selective loss in an environment of supportive organisms. Can this be random ... 

Our discussion indicates that, in the light of this clearly directional evolution, a re-evaluation of the role and functioning of the genetic machinery (not just of the coded molecules, DNA, RNA, proteins) is necessary. How does chance mutation lead to directional change when DNA is both conservative and changes of its sequence are undeniably linked only to chance mutation There is growing evidence of occurrence... 

Fig. 3. Simulations calculated with the PHREEQC geochemical code (Parkhust Appelo 1999) (a) time-dependent diagram for the pH evolution of the Aspo ground water/bentonite interaction (b) time-dependent diagram for the pe evolution of the Aspo groundwater/bentonite interaction. Curves correspond to different initial partial oxygen pressures. Initial calcite and pyrite contents are 0.3 wt% and 0.01 wt% respectively, except for the curve of log/02 = —0.22 where calcite and pyrite contents are 1.4 wt% and 0.3 wt%, respectively, pe calculated stands for the cases where the oxygen fugacity is obtained from the groundwater redox potential (Bruno et at. 1999).

Initially, Oz diffuses through the bentonite and granitic domains, controlling the redox state of the system. Once 02 is exhausted, granitic groundwater controls the redox state of the system. The results of these calculations performed with the PHREEQC geochemical code (Parkhust Appelo 1999) clearly indicate that there is a substantial variability in pH/pe space along the temporal and spatial evolution of the near field of a repositoiy. This has clear consequences for the subsequent interactions with the Fe canister material and finally with the spent fuel matrix. 

Application of the collected thermodynamic data to model the oxidative alteration pathway of U02 under repositoiy conditions by using the PHREEQC code (Parkhurst Appelo 1999) is given in Fig. 1 la and b. Once the thermodynamic framework is set for the geochemical evolution of the repositoiy system, we have to take into consideration that for many of the processes involved, there will be some kinetic constraints. This is illustrated by Table 2, where a comparison of the expected lifetime for some of the phases expected in the repositoiy system is made. 

Ohama, T., Osawa, S., Watanabe, K. and Jukes, T.H. (1990) Evolution of the mitochondrial genetic code. IV. AAA as an asparagine codon in some animal mitochondria. Journal of Molecular Evolution 30, 329-332. 

Woese CR, Dugre DH, Dugre SA et al. On the fundamental nature and evolution of the genetic code. Cold Spring Harbor Symposia on Quantitative Biology 1966 31 723. 

The AGDISP model is run until the released material becomes a spray cloud. Then the FSCBG model uses the AGDISP predictions to create a Gaussian plume model. This gives a complete predictive code, accurate from the time of release until long after the released material can be treated as a cloud. All important forces influencing the evolution of the released material are accounted for and the increase in computer time is nominal. 

The experimental results were analyzed using an integrated approach. To obtain the temporal evolution of the temperature and the density profiles of the bulk plasma, the experimental hot-electron temperature was used as an initial condition for the 1D-FP code [26]. The number of hot electrons in the distribution function were adjusted according to the assumed laser absorption. The FP code is coupled to the 1-D radiation hydrodynamic simulation ILESTA [27]. The electron (or ion) heating rate from hot electrons is first calculated by the Fokker-Planck transport model and is then added to the energy equation for the electrons (or ions) in ILESTA-1D. Results were then used to drive an atomic kinetics package [28] to obtain the temporal evolution of the Ka lines from partially ionized Cl ions. 

---