Comparison of the methods

It is interesting to compare the Debye-Hiickel and virial methods, since each has its own advantages and limitations. The Debye-Hiickel equations are simple to apply and readily extensible to include new species in solution, since they require few coefficients specific to either species or solution. The method can be applied as well over the range of temperatures most important to an aqueous geochemist. There is an extensive literature on ion association reactions, so there are few limits to the complexity of the solutions that can be modeled. 

The Debye-Hiickel methods work poorly, however, when carried to moderate or high ionic strength, especially when salts other than NaCl dominate the solute. In the theory, the ionic strength represents all the properties of a solution. For this reason, a Debye-Hiickel method applied to any solution of a certain ionic strength (whether dominated by NaCl, KC1, HC1, H2SO4, or any salt or salt mixture) gives the same set of activity coefficients, irregardless of the solution s composition. This result, except for dilute solutions, is, of course, incorrect. Clearly, we cannot rely 

STEP 10. Calculate the activity aw of water from the relation 

The virial methods, on the other hand, provide remarkably accurate results over a broad range of solution concentrations and with a variety of dominant solutes. The methods, however, are limited in breadth. Notably lacking at present are data for redox reactions and for components such as aluminum and silica with low solubilities. Data for extending the methods to apply beyond room temperature (e.g., Mpller, 1988 Greenberg and Mpller, 1989), furthermore, are limited currently to relatively simple chemical systems. 

Unlike the Debye-Hiickel equations, the virial methods provide little or no information about the distribution of species in solution. Geochemists like to identify the dominant species in solution in order to write the reactions that control a system s behavior. In the virial methods, this information is hidden within the complexities of the virial equations and coefficients. Many geochemists, therefore, find the virial methods to be less satisfying than methods that predict the species distribution. The information given by Debye-Hiickel methods about species distributions in concentrated solutions, however, is not necessarily reliable and should be used with caution. 

TABLE 7.4 HMW model parameters for cation-anion pairs 

TABLE 7.6 HMW model parameters for anion-anion pairs and triplets 

---

A comparison of the methods of proton-proton NOE detection has shown that two-dimensional NOE detection such as NOESY and ROESY are better suited to the investigation of the stereochemistry of biopolymers whereas for small- to medium-sized molecules (up to 30 C atoms) NOE difference spectroscopy is less time consuming, more selective and thus more conclusive. 

Several methods have been discussed for the determination of method limitations when evaluating procedures for the determination of pesticides in food. A brief comparison of the methods discussed for the determination of the detection and quantification limits of methods used for the analysis of food products can be found in Table 2. 

Antonenko, Y. N. Bulychev, A. A., Measurements of local pH changes near bilayer lipid membrane by means of a pH microelectrode and a protonophore-dependent membrane potential. Comparison of the methods, Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1070, 279-282 (1991). 

Table 6.6 Comparison of the methods to calculate In Kar at various temperatures.

We have made some preliminary comparisons of the methods used in this research.7 In general the dialysis experiments give the most reliable results. These experiments can not, however, be run with all compounds. 

The history of analytical methods used to control the product is prepared The analytical development department prepares a chronological history of the various analytical methods used during the product development. This includes justifications for any changes made in the methods during the development process and a comparison of the methods used to release clinical batch vis-a-vis the commercial batches. 

Various methods have been developed for the synthesis of the different classes of compounds. Their applicability depends on the substrates available and the desired products. Insofar, a comparison of the methods is not possible. 

An excellent comparison of the methods employed in conformational searching of organic molecules has been published11061. In the vast majority of published inorganic molecular modeling studies no stochastic or molecular dynamics conformational searches have been conducted. There are three reasons for this. 

Figura, E and McDuffie, B. (1979) Use of Chelex resin for determination of labile trace metal fractions in aqueous ligand media and comparison of the method with anodic stripping voltammetry. Anal. Client., 51, 120-128.

A comparison of the method proposed in this paper with other methods is difficult because there are few published solutions for nonideal distillation problems. We were unable to find a completely solved problem with all material and energy balances satisfied. We have demonstrated that the Jacobian matrix gives rapid convergence in the vicinity of the solution, and this method might serve as a basis to evaluate other methods. 

S, et al. Comparison of the methods for profiling glycoprotein glycans-HUPO Hnman Disease Glycomics/Proteome Initiative multi-instimtional stndy. Glycobiology 2007 17 411-422. 

Estimated MP2 and CCSD(T) interaction energies of w-alkane dimers at the basis set limit Comparison of the methods of Elelgaker et al. and Feller ... 

This did away with centrifuging. However, possible effects could be that the volume of serum (or plasma) produced from the whole blood sample may be too low, or the erythrocytes may burst or may rub on and haemolyse the sample. Comparison of the methods of the Reflotron system vs. conventional analysis showed that this kind of serum (plasma) separation does not influence the routine methods in clinical chemistry. 

Jorgensen, B.B., 1978. A comparison of the methods for the quantification of bacteriological sulfate reduction in coastal marine sediments. III. Estimation from chemical and bacteriological field data. Geomicrobiol. J., 1 49—64. 

Most of the tests discussed above will detect all species of mycoplasma and closely related organisms, such as A. laidlawii. The table below shows a comparison of the methods described above. Isolation by culture will detect all species except for M. hyorhinis, which is noncultivable (14). The range of species which may be detected with the commercially available ELISA method described is much restricted since the ELISA assay, while allowing a positive identification of the contaminating mycoplasma species, detects only four species (M. orale, M. hyorhinis, M. arginini, and A. laidlawii). 

---