Chemical kinetics comparison with thermodynamics

CHEMRev The Comparison of Detailed Chemical Kinetic Mechanisms Forward Versus Reverse Rates with CHEMRev, Rolland, S. and Simmie, J. M. Int. J. Chem. Kinet. 37(3), 119-125 (2005). This program makes use of CHEMKIN input files and computes the reverse rate constant, kit), from the forward rate constant and the equilibrium constant at a specific temperature and the corresponding Arrhenius equation is statistically fitted, either over a user-supplied temperature range or, else over temperatures defined by the range of temperatures in the thermodynamic database for the relevant species. Refer to the website http //www.nuigalway.ie/chem/c3/software.htm for more information. 

In the following sections of this article we first define the terms necessary to identify a chemical system. After this, the use of an algebraic technique is developed for the expression of general reaction mechanisms and is compared with the previous treatments just mentioned. Next, a combinatorial method is used to determine all physically acceptable reaction mechanisms. This theoretical treatment is followed by a series of examples of increasing complexity. These examples have been chosen to illustrate the technique and for comparison with previous studies. They do not constitute a survey of all the most significant studies concerned with the mechanisms illustrated. Finally, a discussion is presented of the relationship of the present treatment to studies concerned with thermodynamics, and of the relationship between kinetics and mechanisms. 

Nonequilibrium thermodynamics was chosen as a main object for comparison, though an essential part of conclusions drawn below is useful in MEIS comparison with the models of chemical kinetics, synergetics, theory of dynamic systems and other models, model engineering and theories of motions. Comparison is made from two standpoints (1) a scope of areas of effective applications and (2) simplicity and fruitfulness of computing experiments. 

The accurate prediction of enzyme kinetics from first principles is one of the central goals of theoretical biochemistry. Currently, there is considerable debate about the applicability of TST to compute rate constants of enzyme-catalyzed reactions. Classical TST is known to be insufficient in some cases, but corrections for dynamical recrossing and quantum mechanical tunneling can be included. Many effects go beyond the framework of TST, as those previously discussed, and the overall importance of these effects for the effective reaction rate is difficult (if not impossible) to determine experimentally. Efforts are presently oriented to compute the quasi-thermodynamic free energy of activation with chemical accuracy (i.e., 1 kcal mol-1), as a way to discern the importance of other effects from the comparison with the effective measured free energy of activation. 

Even though such power laws of chemical kinetics in activities were proposed [154, 156] the results are often controversial, cf. [165-168] and caused polemics between Haase and Hall [169-175], see detailed discussion in review [108]. These difficulties in application of activities and other thermodynamic concepts in chemical kinetics [131, 132, 157, 176], the dependence of chemical reaction rates on pressure (relatively small effect in comparison with temperature dependence [132, 157, 177]), problems related to not using T, P, wp instead of T, py as thermodynamic variables, etc., may be connected, as it seems, with the result of our theory that the thermodynamic pressures Pa and P are not the same as measured pressures (like pa... 

Vibrational spectroscopy is of utmost importance in many areas of chemical research and the application of electronic structure methods for the calculation of harmonic frequencies has been of great value for the interpretation of complex experimental spectra. Numerous unusual molecules have been identified by comparison of computed and observed frequencies. Another standard use of harmonic frequencies in first principles computations is the derivation of thermochemical and kinetic data by statistical thermodynamics for which the frequencies are an important ingredient (see, e. g., Hehre et al. 1986). The theoretical evaluation of harmonic vibrational frequencies is efficiently done in modem programs by evaluation of analytic second derivatives of the total energy with respect to cartesian coordinates (see, e. g., Johnson and Frisch, 1994, for the corresponding DFT implementation and Stratman etal., 1997, for further developments). Alternatively, if the second derivatives are not available analytically, they are obtained by numerical differentiation of analytic first derivatives (i. e., by evaluating gradient differences obtained after finite displacements of atomic coordinates). In the past two decades, most of these calculations have been carried... 

The topic of interactions between Lewis acids and bases could benefit from systematic ab initio quantum chemical calculations of gas phase (two molecule) studies, for which there is a substantial body of experimental data available for comparison. Similar computations could be carried out in the presence of a dielectric medium. In addition, assemblages of molecules, for example a test acid in the presence of many solvent molecules, could be carried out with semiempirical quantum mechanics using, for example, a commercial package. This type of neutral molecule interaction study could then be enlarged in scope to determine the effects of ion-molecule interactions by way of quantum mechanical computations in a dielectric medium in solutions of low ionic strength. This approach could bring considerable order and a more convincing picture of Lewis acid base theory than the mixed spectroscopic (molecular) parameters in interactive media and the purely macroscopic (thermodynamic and kinetic) parameters in different and varied media or perturbation theory applied to the semiempirical molecular orbital or valence bond approach [11 and references therein]. 

Generally speaking, PEVD is a modified form of chemical vapor deposition (CVD). A comparison between PEVD and conventional CVD is schematically shown in Figure 1 for a product (D) formed from reactants (A) and (B). In a CVD process, both reactants (A) and (B) are supplied through a vapor phase at the same side of a solid substrate (E). They react chemically at the surface of the solid substrate (E), aided by some type of catalytic effect, to form a desired product (D). In a PEVD process, one reactant (A) is transported from one side (source) of a solid substrate (E) to the other side (sink) under well-controlled thermodynamic and kinetic conditions. At the sink side, reaction with (B) occurs to form (D). Further growth of (D) into a continuous thin film with the desired thickness in a PEVD process also relies on (A) transported in the solid state now through (E) and (D) to react with (B). 

Additional insights into the resonance effect on the stabilization of 72 comes from a consideration of the rate constants ki and k-i, or, more precisely, the intrinsic rate constants. The general definition of the intrinsic rate constant, ko, of a reaction with forward and reverse rate constants k and k-i, respectively, is ko = k = k-i when = 1 if dealing with free energies, one can define an intrinsic barrier, AGq, as AGq = AGj = AgIj when AG° = q H9,i20 significance of ko or AGq is that they are purely kinetic measures of chemical reactivity because they separate out thermodynamic effects from kinetic effects and hence they allow meaningful comparisons of reactivity between different reactions. 

---