Carbenium ions alkyl cations

Staley RH, Wieting RD, Beauchamp JL. Carbenium ion stabilities in the gas phase and solution. An ion cyclotron resonance study of bromide transfer reactions involving alkali ions, alkyl carbenium ions, acyl cations, and cyclic halonium ions. J Am Chem Soc. 1977 99 5964-72. 

BF3-Et20, NaCNBHs, THF, reflux 4-24 h, 65-98% yield. Functional groups such aryl ketones and nitro compounds are reduced and electron-rich phenols tend to be alkylated with the released benzyl carbenium ion. The use of BF3 Et20 and triethylsilane as a cation scavenger is also effective." ... 

The initial step is the coordination of the alkyl halide 2 to the Lewis acid to give a complex 4. The polar complex 4 can react as electrophilic agent. In cases where the group R can form a stable carbenium ion, e.g. a tert-buiyX cation, this may then act as the electrophile instead. The extent of polarization or even cleavage of the R-X bond depends on the structure of R as well as the Lewis acid used. The addition of carbenium ion species to the aromatic reactant, e.g. benzene 1, leads to formation of a cr-complex, e.g. the cyclohexadienyl cation 6, from which the aromatic system is reconstituted by loss of a proton ... 

All alkyl ions tested demonstrate a comparable behaviour independent of the sign of their charges. The decrease of the reaction enthalpies AH (11) with the change from the methyl to the ethyl cation (AAH (ll) = 165 kJ mol-1) and from the ethyl to the but-2-enyl cation (AAH°(11) = 117 kJ mol-1) corresponds to the increase of stability of these carbenium ions, which are expressed by the difference of their heats of formation (AAH f = —118 and AAHj = —42 kJ mol-1 90)) and of their hydride ion affinity (AHIA = 176 and 126 kJ mol-1 91)), respectively. 

The various carbenium ions /erf-alkyl, bridgehead-, norbornyl-, allyl-, benzyl- or cyclopropylcarbinyl-cations, which are assumed to be intermediates in these decarboxylations are compiled in ref. [293]. 

Theoretically, even the direct alkylation of carbenium ions with isobutane is feasible. The reaction of isobutane with a r-butyl cation would lead to 2,2,3,3-tetramethylbutane as the primary product. With liquid superacids under controlled conditions, this has been observed (52), but under typical alkylation conditions 2,2,3,3-TMB is not produced. Kazansky et al. (26,27) proposed the direct alkylation of isopentane with propene in a two-step alkylation process. In this process, the alkene first forms the ester, which in the second step reacts with the isoalkane. Isopentane was found to add directly to the isopropyl ester via intermediate formation of (non-classical) carbonium ions. In this way, the carbenium ions are freed as the corresponding alkanes without hydride transfer (see Section II.D). This conclusion was inferred from the virtual absence of propane in the product mixture. Whether this reaction path is of significance in conventional alkylation processes is unclear at present. HF produces substantial amounts of propane in isobutane/propene alkylation. The lack of 2,2,4-TMP in the product, which is formed in almost all alkylates regardless of the feed (55), implies that the mechanism in the two-step alkylation process is different from that of conventional alkylation. 

Intermolecular hydride transfer (Reaction (6)), typically from isobutane to an alkyl-carbenium ion, transforms the ions into the corresponding alkanes and regenerates the t-butyl cation to continue the chain sequence in both liquid acids and zeolites. 

With both liquid acid catalysts, but presumably to a higher degree with sulfuric acid, hydrides are not transferred exclusively to the carbenium ions from isobutane, but also from the conjunct polymers 44,46,71). Sulfuric acid containing 4-6 wt% of conjunct polymers produces a much higher quality alkylate than acids without ASOs (45). Cyclic and unsaturated compounds, which are both present in conjunct polymers, are known to be hydride donors (72). As was mentioned in Section II.B, these species can abstract a hydride from isobutane to form the -butyl cation, and they can give a hydride to a carbenium ion, producing the corresponding alkane, for example the TMPs, as shown in reactions (7) and (8). 

Hydrocarbons with up to 16 carbon atoms are detected in a typical alkylate (82). With the liquid acids, it was found that the oligomerization rate is higher for isoalkenes than for linear alkenes (49). The same is true for solid acids (14,83). Because of their tertiary carbon atoms, isobutylene and isopentene obviously react more easily with carbenium ions. This point can be inferred from the reverse reaction, (3-scission (see below), which is fastest for reactions of tertiary cations to give tertiary cations. In oligomerization experiments, the following pattern of... 

The isopentene produced will either be protonated or be added to another carbenium ion. With a butyl cation, this would lead to a nonyl cation. The resultant carbenium ion fragment can accept a hydride and form a product heptane, or it can possibly add a butene to form a Cn cation. With hydride transfer, another alkane with an odd number of carbon atoms is produced. Just this example is sufficient to show the huge variety of possible reactions. By means of gas chromatographic analysis, Albright and Wood (82) found about 100-200 peaks in the C9-C16 region, regardless of the alkene and acid employed. A similar number of products can be observed for solid acid-catalyzed alkylation. 

We concluded, therefore, that in sufficiently pure alkyl halide solvents the tert-alkyl tetrahaloaluminates are stable electrolytes and that previous failures to produce them, and the consequent legend of the instability of tcrt-alkyl carbenium ions, arose from the use of inappropriate and insufficiently rigorous experimental techniques. On this basis it seems highly probable that in the polymerised solutions the cations R+ partaking in reaction (viii) were also original ions, i.e., 2 at the end of a live chain and 3 and 4 formed by alumination of a terminal double bond, and not derived ions formed by degradative reactions of monomer or polymer. 

The author s theory which has been used here was developed in detail to explain the polymerisations by ionising radiations of some alkyl vinyl ethers, the polymerisations of which proceed by secondary ions. Although it was shown that the theory is also perfectly serviceable for the tertiary carbenium ions considered here, it must be realised that there is a fundamental difference between these two types of carbenium ions. When one of the bonds of the carbenium ion is a C—H bond, the solvators, especially of course an ion, can get much closer to the positive centre, and they are therefore correspondingly more firmly held to which effect is added that of a smaller steric hindrance. The most researched monomer propagating by secondary cations, apart from the alkyl vinyl ethers, is, of course, styrene. Thus, Mayr s many studies with diaryl methylium cations are directly relevant to the polymerisation of styrene. 

Explanation The increase of both Y and DP with time implies a growing species of long life, which is characteristic of esters but not of carbenium ions, and an absence of transfer reactions. The suppression of all kinds of transfer reactions seems to require some very special features in the anionoid moiety of the ester which are not yet understood fully but which, by hypothesis, cannot affect the reaction pattern of an isolated, unpaired cation. The fact that living polymerisations can occur in toluene is a convincing demonstration that these reactions cannot involve carbenium ions, because growing cations alkylate toluene [33-37], a process which produces low DPs, independent of Y. 

Prins reaction, heteropolyacid catalysis, 41 156 Probe molecules, 42 119 acidic dissociation constant, 38 210 NMR solid acidity studies, 42 139-140 acylium ions, 42 139, 160 aldehydes, 42 162-163 alkyl carbenium ions, 42 154-157 allyl cation, 42 143-144 ammonia, 42 172-174 arenium ions, 42 150-154 carbonium ions, 42 157-160 chalcogenenonium ions, 42 161-162 cyclopentenyl cations, 42 140-143 indanyl cations, 42 144-147 ketones, 42 162,163-165 nitrogen-containing compounds, 42 165-170... 

The Ritter reaction [6] proceeds by the electrooxidation of alkyl iodides (56) in an MeCN-(Pt) system to form Ai-alkyl acetamides (58) (Scheme 21). Attack of carbenium ion intermediate - from dissociation of the initially formed alkyl cation radical - to acetonitrile would give the iminium cation (57). However, a different mechanism is proposed, whereby the alkyl iodide reacts with the electrogenerated iodo cation [I]" " [73]. 

---