Bow tie analysis

Bow tie analysis is a tool that has become very popular in the last few years, especially because of the ease in which it can display cause-consequence of a particular hazardous condition. It is a qualitative tool that combines the fault tree to determine the causes and how the fault could occur, with the event tree, which documents the consequence of the hazardous condition. It became much better known in the mid-1990s when Royal Dutch/Shell used it to better understand the Piper Alpha disaster. The process industry uses it not only to assess the hazards and risks but also as a very effective communication tool to illustrate the cause-consequence-control and how it can impact a hazardous condition. In reality, it really isn t a new analytical tool, but rather, a very good visualization tool. 

---

Deviations are in fact analysed for all the activities identified as critical (as being part of a safety barrier) according to the bow-tie analysis of the accidental scenarios. Every step considered to be critical and therefore represented more in depth in the detail task analysis is associated with the Ust of relevant PSF affecting it for the scope of experiment design. 

The scenarios identified in the fieldwork have been analyzed by means of a bow-tie analysis by a team... 

The first step is to proceed to the bow tie analysis of the two identified risks (i.e. R and R2) as shown in figures 3 and 4. Note that in 55i we have five preventive barriers (i.e. Periodic preventive maintenance tankvalve (PMV), Periodic preventive maintenance to... 

Once the bow tie analysis achieved, we will apply our transformation procedure (i.e. Algorithm 2) with the following input data ... 

FIGURE B.2 Graphical depiction of Bow-Tie Analysis. (Image Courtesy of ABS Consulting.)... 

The standard reference for the offshore oil and gas industry is API RP 14J. However, as already noted, this standard does not provide guidance on some of the latest techniques being used, such as Bow-Tie Analysis. 

A hazards analysis technique that is widely used on offshore facilities is known as Bow-Tie Analysis. The name is based on the shape of the final analysis product as shown in Figure 5.1. The method is used not only to identify risks, but also to assess the effectiveness of the system s safeguards. 

R. Ouache, A.A.J. Adham, N.A.B. Azizan, Hybrid layer of protection analysis and bow tie analysis with fuzzy approach for quantitative risk assessment. International Journal of Advanced Research in Engineering and Technology (IJARET) 5 (10) (October 2014). 

Literature on the many techniques for making risk assessments is abundant. For example, in ANSI/ASSE Z690.3. Risk Assessment Techniques—reviews are included of 31 techniques. Examples are such as Primary Hazard Analysis, Fault Tree Analysis, Hazard and Operably Studies, Bow Tie Analysis, Markov Analysis, and Bayesian Statistics. Uncomplicated systems that could be introduced to supervisors and front-line employees are not as prevalent. Such a system is contained in an extension of the previously cited European Community bulletin. It follows. 

Bow-Tie Analysis (BTA) a type of qualitative process hazard analysis.The methodology is an adaptation of three conventional system safety techniques Fault Tree Analysis, Causal Factors Charting, and Event Tree Analysis. Existing safeguards (barriers) are identified and evaluated for adequacy... 

Bow tie analysis is a qualitative, iterative technique often conducted by a team. It unifies fault tree analysis and event tree analysis. This technique visualizes all effects leading to a top event and all consequences which result from the top event (Badreddine and Ben Amor, 2010). 

Bow tie analysis is a semi-specific method. As it combines two methods which fit to the purpose of urban security enhancement, we believe it to be suitable for rather extensive analysis of specific security issues, e.g., terroristic events. 

Shahriar, A. Sadiq, R. Tesfamariam, S. 2012. Risk analysis for oil gas pipelines A sustainability assessment approach using fuzzy based bow-tie analysis. J. Loss Prevention Process bid. 25, 505-523. 

Bow-tie analysis is an analysis technique that combines FTA and ETA together to evaluate multiple possible outcomes from an undesired IE. The various outcomes result from the operation or failure of barriers intended to prevent a mishap. The analysis begins with identification of the IE of concern in the... 

---