Barriers valence bonds

One formalism which has been extensively used with classical trajectory methods to study gas-phase reactions has been the London-Eyring-Polanyi-Sato (LEPS) method . This is a semiempirical technique for generating potential energy surfaces which incorporates two-body interactions into a valence bond scheme. The combination of interactions for diatomic molecules in this formalism results in a many-body potential which displays correct asymptotic behavior, and which contains barriers for reaction. For the case of a diatomic molecule reacting with a surface, the surface is treated as one body of a three-body reaction, and so the two-body terms are composed of two atom-surface interactions and a gas-phase atom-atom potential. The LEPS formalism then introduces adjustable potential energy barriers into molecule-surface reactions. 

Molecular dynamics free-energy perturbation simulations utilizing the empirical valence bond model have been used to study the catalytic action of -cyclodextrin in ester hydrolysis. Reaction routes for nucleophilic attack on m-f-butylphenyl acetate (225) by the secondary alkoxide ions 0(2) and 0(3) of cyclodextrin giving the R and S stereoisomers of ester tetrahedral intermediate were examined. Only the reaction path leading to the S isomer at 0(2) shows an activation barrier that is lower (by about 3kcal mol ) than the barrier for the corresponding reference reaction in water. The calculated rate acceleration was in excellent agreement with experimental data. ... 

Another, quite independent theoretical assessment, based on ab initio calculations and the generalized valence bond method, found that the barrier height for cis,trans isomerization of cyclopropane is essentially the same (calculated value, 60.5 kcal mol-1) whether one or both of the thermal CH2 groups are rotated after opening of the CC bond 243. Thus, in 1972, there seemed to be general agreement among theoreticians that the stereomutations of cyclopropane should take place with k, about equal to kl2. 

Isomerization of the retinal Schiff s base can occur when the molecule is excited with light, because the C-l 1-C-12 bond loses much of its double-bond character in the excited state. The valence bond diagrams of figure S2.7 illustrate this point. In the ground state of rhodopsin, the potential energy barrier to rotation about the C-l 1-C-l2 bond is on the order of 30 kcal/mol. This barrier essentially vanishes in the excited state. In fact, the energy of the excited molecule probably is minimal when the C-11 -C-l2 bond is twisted by about 90° (fig. S2.8). The excited molecule oscillates briefly about this intermediate conformation, and when it decays back to a ground state it usually settles into the ail-trans isomer, bathorhodopsin. 

The results of a valence bond treatment of the rotational barrier in ethane lie between the extremes of the NBO and EDA analyses and seem to reconcile this dispute by suggesting that both Pauli repulsion and hyperconjugation are important. This is probably closest to the truth (remember that Pauli repulsion dominates in the higher alkanes) but the VB approach is still imperfect and also is mostly a very powerful expert method [43]. VB methods construct the total wave function from linear combinations of covalent resonance and an array of ionic structures as the covalent structure is typically much lower in energy, the ionic contributions are included by using highly delocalised (and polarisable) so-called Coulson-Fischer orbitals. Needless to say, this is not error free and the brief description of this rather old but valuable approach indicates the expert nature of this type of analysis. 

L. Song, W. Wu, P. C. Hiberty, S. Shaik, Chem. Eur. J. 9, 4540 (2003). An Accurate Barrier for the Hydrogen Exchange Reaction from Valence Bond Theory Is this Theory Coming of Age ... 

BARRIER EXPRESSIONS BASED ON THE VALENCE BOND STATE CORRELATION DIAGRAM MODEL... 

Valence Bond Modeling of Barriers in the Nonidentity Hydrogen Abstraction Reactions, X" + H—X X —H + X (X fX = CH3, SiH3, GeH3, SnH3, PbH3). 

VBSCD Valence bond state correlation diagram. A VB diagram that views the barrier formation as a result of avoided crossing between two state curves that are anchored in the ground and two excited states of reactants and products. The VBSCD is a paradigm for the barrier in chemical reactions (see Chapter 6). 

The trends in the activation barriers were explained440,442 using the valence bond configuration mixing model443 444, as shown schematically in Figure 32a. According to this... 

The results of Benson and McLaughlin104 indicate that no barrier to reaction exists, nor do they show a minimum, which is in contrast to the stable HeH4 complex bound by 0.44 eV reported by Poshusta, Haugen, and Zetik255 using a minimal valence-bond Cl technique. 

---