Arrhenius Plot Theory

Another technique known and available for evaluating and predicting performance in special applications concerns the Arrhenius plot. 

Why materials age Aging involves both chemical and physical changes, although many of the latter are just the visible manifestation of the former. While most of these should be obvious to the chemist and engineer, it is important that they be reviewed as background to the basic approach to be taken. 

Rate of aging process It has been known for a long time as an empirical fact that many reactions approximately double or treble their rates with a 10°C rise in temperature. A more quantitative relation is given by the classical Arrhenius modified equation  

A straight line is produced when the logarithm of a specific reaction rate is plotted against the reciprocal of the absolute temperature. Temperature has a marked influence on the reaction rates, but the range between reactions that are too slow or too fast to measure is really quite narrow. 

Similarly, the rate of evaporation of materials depends on the vapor pressure, p, of the volatile constituent, which in turn varies directly as its molar concentration and the temperature  

---

In fig. 26 the Arrhenius plot ln[k(r)/coo] versus TojT = Pl2n is shown for V /(Oo = 3, co = 0.1, C = 0.0357. The disconnected points are the data from Hontscha et al. [1990]. The solid line was obtained with the two-dimensional instanton method. One sees that the agreement between the instanton result and the exact quantal calculations is perfect. The low-temperature limit found with the use of the periodic-orbit theory expression for kio (dashed line) also excellently agrees with the exact result. Figure 27 presents the dependence ln(/Cc/( o) on the coupling strength defined as C fQ. The dashed line corresponds to the exact result from Hontscha et al. [1990], and the disconnected points are obtained with the instanton method. For most practical purposes the instanton results may be considered exact. 

Figure 10. Arrhenius plot of the thermal rate constants for the 2D model system. Circles-full quantum results. Thick solid (dashed) curve present nonadiabatic transition state theory by using the seam surface [the minimum energy crossing point (MECP)] approximation. Thin solid and dashed curves are the same as the thick ones except that the classical partition functions are used. Taken from Ref. [27].

The present formula Eq. (126) is tested in comparison with the Bixon-Jortner perturbation theory in the weak electronic coupling regime [109]. The Arrhenius plot is shown in Fig. 23, where the electronic coupling Had is taken... 

Figure 23. Arrhenius plot of the electron transfer rate. The electronic coupling strength is TIad = 0.0001 a.u. Solid line-Bixon-Jortner perturbation theory Ref. [109]. FuU-circle present results of Eq. (26 ). Dashed line-results of Marcus s high temperature theory [Eq.(129)]. Taken from Ref. [28].

In experimental practice, we usually ignore the temperature dependence of the prefactor and extract the activation energy by making an Arrhenius plot, as discussed in Chapter 2. The consequence of collision theory, however, is that a curved plot, rather than a straight line, will result if the activation energy is of the same order of k T. 

Three possibilities were considered to account for the curved Arrhenius plots and unusual KIEs (a) the 1,2-H shift might feature a variational transition state due to the low activation energy (4.9 kcal/mol60) and quite negative activation entropy (b) MeCCl could react by two or more competing pathways, each with a different activation energy (e.g., 1,2-H shift and azine formation by reaction with the diazirine precursor) (c) QMT could occur.60 The first possibility was discounted because calculations by Storer and Houk indicated that the 1,2-H shift was adequately described by conventional transition state theory.63 Option (b) was excluded because the Arrhenius curvature persisted after correction of the 1,2-H shift rate constants for the formation of minor side products (azine).60... 

Using the same experimental approach, a family of enantiomerically pure oxonium ions, i.e., O-protonated 1-aryl-l-methoxyethanes (aryl = 4-methylphenyl ((5 )-49) 4-chlorophenyl ((5)-50) 3-(a,a,a-trifluoromethyl)phenyl ((5)-51) 4-(a,a,a-trifluoromethyl)phenyl ((S)-52) 1,2,3,4,5- pentafluorophenyl ((/f)-53)) and 1-phenyl-l-methoxy-2,2,2-trifluoroethane ((l )-54), has been generated in the gas phase by (CH3)2Cl -methylation of the corresponding l-arylethanols. ° Some information on their reaction dynamics was obtained from a detailed kinetic study of their inversion of configuration and dissociation. Figs. 23 and 24 report respectively the Arrhenius plots of and fc iss for all the selected alcohols, together with (/f)-40) of Scheme 23. The relevant linear curves obey the equations reported in Tables 23 and 24, respectively. The corresponding activation parameters were calculated from the transition-state theory. 

Recently, transition state theory calculations were applied to a class of reactions involving OH radicals and haloalkanes, again to account systematically for the expected curvature in Arrhenius plots for these reactions (Cohen and Benson, 1987a). Subsequently, empirical relationships were also derived for the a priori determination of pre-exponential factors (A) and activation energies ( ) based on an assumed T dependency of the pre-exponential factor (Cohen and Benson, 1987b). This and related studies clearly illustrate the broad utility of transition state theory in the systematic development of detailed chemical kinetic mechanisms. 

Mozurkewich M, and Benson, S. W., Negative activation energies and curved Arrhenius plots. 1. Theory of reactions over potential wells, J. Phys. Chem. 88, 6429 (1984). 

Effect of Solvent on Arrhenius Plots. If water is a substrate, then the presence of an organic solvent, which may disrupt the structure and/or orientation of water, may alter the Arrhenius plot. For example, a linear plot is seen with fumarate hydratase in the presence of 10% methanol. However, the plot is biphasic in the presence of 10% ethanol . See Boltzmann Distribution Collision Theory Temperature Dependency, Transition-State Theory Energy of Activation On... 

Finally, yet another issue enters into the interpretation of nonlinear Arrhenius plots of enzyme-catalyzed reactions. As is seen in the examples above, one typically plots In y ax (or. In kcat) versus the reciprocal absolute temperature. This protocol is certainly valid for rapid equilibrium enzymes whose rate-determining step does not change throughout the temperature range studied (and, in addition, remains rapid equilibrium throughout this range). However, for steady-state enzymes, other factors can influence the interpretation of the nonlinear data. For example, for an ordered two-substrate, two-product reaction, kcat is equal to kskjl ks + k ) in which ks and k are the off-rate constants for the two products. If these two rate constants have a different temperature dependency (e.g., ks > ky at one temperature but not at another temperature), then a nonlinear Arrhenius plot may result. See Arrhenius Equation Owl Transition-State Theory van t Hoff Relationship... 

As discussed in Chapter 5, kinetic theories predict that the preexponential factor should have a temperature dependence that manifests itself in curved Arrhenius plots if the reactions are studied over a sufficiently broad temperature range. This is the case for OH-al-kane reactions, where there has been great interest in the high-temperature kinetics for combustion systems. Table 6.2 also shows the temperature dependence for the OH reactions in the form k = BT"e c/l, where C = E.JR and in the form recommended by Donahue et al. (1998a). 

The rate constant, k, for most elementary chemical reactions follows the Arrhenius equation, k = A exp(— EJRT), where A is a reaction-specific quantity and Ea the activation energy. Because EA is always positive, the rate constant increases with temperature and gives linear plots of In k versus 1 IT. Kinks or curvature are often found in Arrhenius plots for enzymatic reactions and are usually interpreted as resulting from complex kinetics in which there is a change in rate-determining step with temperature or a change in the structure of the protein. The Arrhenius equation is recast by transition state theory (Chapter 3, section A) to... 

Such a comparison between experiment and theory would be interesting insofar as Vr is computed at distances of ca. 10 A, where the validity of the macroscopic theories used may be questionable. However, using the Arrhenius equation (see Equation 16) is not necessarily valid as it is written. It is assumed implicitly in writing Equation 16 that E is temperature independent. If rewriting the functional form of fci as given in Equation 14 into the form given in Equation 16 embeds a temperature dependence into E, then the Arrhenius plots will yield anomalous results. 

Transition state theory can also give us some insight into the non-Arrhenius behaviour of rate coefficients as epitomized by Fig. 2.6 for the OH + ethane reaction. Curvature of the Arrhenius plot can arise from a number of factors. 

---