The Elimination-Addition Mechanism of Nucleophilic Aromatic Substitution Benzyne

Here it is the combined electron-attracting effects of the six fluorine substituents that stabilize the cyclohexadienyl anion intermediate and permit the reaction to proceed so readily. 

Hahdes derived from certain heterocyclic aromatic compounds are often quite reactive toward nucleophiles. 2-Chloropyridine, for example, reacts with sodium methoxide some 230 million times faster than chlorobenzene at 50°C. 

Another type of nucleophilic aromatic substitution occurs under quite different reaction conditions from those discussed to this point and proceeds by a different and rather surprising mechanism. It is described in the following section. 

8 THE ELIMINATION-ADDITION MECHANISM OF NUCLEOPHILIC AROMATIC SUBSTITUTION BENZYNE 

Very strong bases such as sodium or potassium amide react readily with aryl hahdes, even those without electron-withdrawing substituents, to give products corresponding to nucleophilic substitution of halide by the base. 

PROBLEM 23.5 Write equations describing the addition-elimination mechanism for the reaction of hexafluorobenzene with sodium methoxide, clearly showing the structure of the rate-determining intermediate. 

---

The Elimination-Addition Mechanism of Nucleophilic Aromatic Substitution Benzyne... 

Mechanism of nucleophilic aromatic substitution by elimination addition (the benzyne mechanism). 

Nucleophilic aromatic substitution can also occur by an elimination-addition mechanism This pathway is followed when the nucleophile is an exceptionally strong base such as amide ion m the form of sodium amide (NaNH2) or potassium amide (KNH2) Benzyne and related arynes are intermediates m nucleophilic aromatic substitutions that pro ceed by the elimination-addition mechanism... 

Although nucleophilic aromatic substitution by the elimination-addition mechanism is most commonly seen with very strong amide bases, it also occurs with bases such as hydroxide ion at high temperatures. A " C-labeling study revealed that hydrolysis of chlorobenzene proceeds by way of a benzyne intennediate. 

Notice the symmetry in this mechanism. Benzyne is formed from an ortho carbanion and it gives an ortho carbanion when it reacts with nucleophiles. The whole mechanism from bromobenzene to aniline involves an elimination to give benzyne followed by an addition of the nucleophile to the triple bond of benzyne. In many ways, this mechanism is the reverse of the normal addition-elimination mechanism for nucleophilic aromatic substitution and it is sometimes called the elimination-addition mechanism, the elimination step... 

Halobenzenes undergo nucleophilic aromatic substitution through either of two mechanisms. If the halobenzene has a strongly electron-withdrawing substituent in the ortho or para position, substitution occurs by addition of a nucleophile to the ring, followed by elimination of halide from the intermediate anion. If the halobenzene is not activated by an electron-withdrawing substituent, substitution can occur by elimination of HX to give a benzyne, followed by addition of a nucleophile. 

We take up the aryl halides in a separate chapter because they differ so much from the alkyl halides in their preparation and properties. Aryl halides as a class are comparatively unreactive toward the nucleophilic substitution reactions so characteristic of the alkyl halides. The presence of certain other groups on the aromatic ring, however, greatly increases the reactivity of aryl halides in the absence of such groups, reaction can still be brought about by very basic reagents or high temperatures. We shall find that nucleophilic aromatic substitution can follow two very different paths the bimolecular displacement mechanism for activated aryl halides and the elimination-addition mechanismy which involves the remarkable intermediate called benzyne. 

This phenol synthesis is different from the nucleophilic aromatic substitutions discussed in the previous section because it takes place by an elimination addition mechanism rather than an addition/elimination. Strong base first causes the elimination of HX from halobenzene in an E2 reaction, yielding a highly reactive benzyne intermediate, and a nucleophile then adds to benzyne in a second step to give the product. The two steps are similar to those in other nucleophilic aromatic substitutions, but their order is reversed elimination before addition for the benzyne reaction rather than addition before elimination for the usual reaction. 

As exemplified by equation (2), the Perkin condensation of o-hydroxybenzaldehydes is an important method for the synthesis of substituted coumarins. An interesting variation on this procedure has been reported recently. Heating a mixture of o-fluorobenzaldehyde, 2-thiopheneacetic acid, acetic anhydride and triethylamine affords directly the coumarin (20 equation 13) instead of the expected cinnamic acid (21). The reaction proceeds similarly with several arylacetic acids. The reaction presumably proceeds through the cinnamic acids (21). The observed product can conceivably arise by direct nucleophilic displacement involving the carboxylate or by an elimination/addition (benzyne) mechanism. The authors note that when 2-fluorobenzaldehyde is replaced by its 2-bromo analog in this reaction, the substituted cinnamic acid (22) is the major product and the corresponding coumarin (20) is obtained only in low yield. It is suggested that since it is known that fluoride is displaced more rapidly in nucleophilic aromatic substitution reactions, while bromo aromatic compounds form benzynes more rapidly, this result is consistent with a nucleophilic displacement mechanism. 

---