Substituent shift effects

Using a multiple linear regression computer program, a set of substituent parameters was calculated for a number of the most commonly occurring groups. The calculated substituent effects allow a prediction of the chemical shifts of the exterior and central carbon atoms of the allene with standard deviations of l.Sand 2.3 ppm, respectively Although most compounds were measured as neat liquids, for a number of compounds duplicatel measurements were obtained in various solvents. 

In describing the chemical shifts of the exterior and central allene carbons, the substituent effect symbols depicted in Fig. 1 were used. 

The substituent effects on the chemical shift of the central carbon are given in Fig. 1 and are described by eg. 2 ... 

Substituent effects are often considerable, particularly when strongly electron-donating effects (to the aza-nitrogen) are present, when upheld shifts of up to 60 p.p.m. (2-NH2) may be observed. 

Representative chemical shifts from the large amount of available data on isothiazoles are included in Table 4. The chemical shifts of the ring hydrogens depend on electron density, ring currents and substituent anisotropies, and substituent effects can usually be predicted, at least qualitatively, by comparison with other aromatic systems. The resonance of H(5) is usually at a lower field than that of H(3) but in some cases this order is reversed. As is discussed later (Section 4.17.3.4) the chemical shift of H(5) is more sensitive to substitution in the 4-position than is that of H(3), and it is also worth noting that the resonance of H(5) is shifted downfield (typically 0.5 p.p.m.) when DMSO is used as solvent, a reflection of the ability of this hydrogen atom to interact with proton acceptors. This matter is discussed again in Section 4.17.3.7. 

Substituent effects (substituent increments) tabulated in more detail in the literature demonstrate that C chemical shifts of individual carbon nuclei in alkenes and aromatic as well as heteroaromatic compounds can be predicted approximately by means of mesomeric effects (resonance effects). Thus, an electron donor substituent D [D = OC//j, SC//j, N(C//j)2] attached to a C=C double bond shields the (l-C atom and the -proton (+M effect, smaller shift), whereas the a-position is deshielded (larger shift) as a result of substituent electronegativity (-/ effect). 

Table 14.1. Prediction of C chemical shift of c/s-l,2-dimethylcyclohexane in the frozen state, using the cyclohexane shift of 8c = 27.6 and substituent effects (e.g. Ref. 6, p. 316)...

Adding these substituent effects gives the following calculated shift values (as compared with the observed values in parentheses) for C-1 to C-4 of the pura-disubstituted benzene ring in A and B ... 

Substituent effects calculated for structure B lead to values which are not perfect but which agree more closely than for A with the measured C shifts of the benzene ring carbon atoms. The dia-stereotopism of the NC//2 protons in the H NMR spectrum also points to B as the Newman projection C along the C/fj-ammonium-N bond shows ... 

They have also demonstrated that a linear energy relationship exists between pKa values of sulphoxides and the hydrogen bonding ability which was determined by IR-stretching shift of the OH band in PhOH in CC14. Oae and coworkers173 determined the pKa values of diaryl sulphoxides and found that the substituent effect does not correlate with the Hammett o values but approximately with the a values. The pKa values thus obtained are summarized in Table 19. 

Eq. (1) has potential application to other types of measurements of substituent effects besides those specifically considered in this paper e.g., nmr coupling constants and shifts for other nuclei, ir and uv spectral shifts and intensities. We caution (with emphasis) in these applications the needed use of data sets of high quality, both with respect to the precision of the measurement and substituents considered (i.e., a full complement of substituent o/ and Or properties must be encompassed for a meaningful correlation to be obtained). There is, of course, no requirement that all data sets will be uniquely fitted by eq. (1) using one of the four or scales of Table V. For example, the data for the ionization of the conjugate acids of pyridine-N-oxides (30), HjO, 25° is found to fit equally well the or(ba.) or Or scales (SD=. 14 /=. 072). The data (31) for the rates of alkaline ("OMe) cleavage of ArSnMea are not fitted to acceptable precision (fs >. 23) by any of the Or parameters. This data set is nevertheless indicated... 

The pattern K j < K P < K° and X > X° > X is also clearly shown in the correlation of the proton nmr shifts of substituted phenols in DMSO solution. The o and p- substituent effects are best fitted by the a (A) parameters (cf. para set no. 24 of Table VI), whereas the m- substituent effects are best fitted by parameters. The following fitting parameters are... 

The idea that /3 continuously shifts with the temperature employed and thus remains experimentally inaccessible would be plausible and could remove many theoretical problems. However, there are few reaction series where the reversal of reactivity has been observed directly. Unambiguous examples are known, particularly in heterogeneous catalysis (4, 5, 189), as in Figure 5, and also from solution kinetics, even when in restricted reaction series (187, 190). There is the principal difficulty that reactions in solution cannot be followed in a sufficiently broad range of temperature, of course. It also seems that near the isokinetic temperature, even the Arrhenius law is fulfilled less accurately, making the determination of difficult. Nevertheless, we probably have to accept that reversal of reactivity is a possible, even though rare, phenomenon. The mechanism of such reaction series may be more complex than anticipated and a straightforward discussion in terms of, say, substituent effects may not be admissible. 

Substituent Effect F-nmr Shifts for BCI3 Adduct Formation with p-Fluoro-p -Substituted... 

---