Structure of the Starting State

The vibrational spectrum of H+ is even harder to interpret. Absorption increases at all frequencies in the infrared and the already broad water bands get broader, but not symmetrically. The additions to the water bands have been interpreted as the new bands of the HsO+ unit in H+ (Falk and Gigufere, 1957). The suggested frequencies are shown in Table 9. On the other hand it has been suggested that the rapid proton shifts from one oxygen to another precludes a band spectrum for that unit in water (Ackermann, 1961) and its absorption has been 

Evidence from NMR spectra (Kresge and Allred, 1963 Gold, 1963) supports the intuitively attractive idea that only the M30+ unit of M+, in an isotopically mixed solvent, has an isotopic composition significantly different from the water. The isotopic equilibrium constant, l (0-69, Section IIA4), then pertains to the distribution of isotopes between MsO+ and M20. It could be calculated if the frequency distributions (including librations and restricted translations) were known for liquid H20, D20, and H+ and D+ in those solvents. Since only uncertain approximations of typical frequencies are available, an unsophisticated estimate, made by means of equation (62) (Bunton and Shiner, 1961a) 

Falk and Giguere frequencies the librational frequencies of H30+ were assumed to be the same as those in water. When using the Rudolph and Zimmermann frequencies the cited values were used for the libra-tions. In both cases the restricted translations were assumed to be isotopically insensitive. The even more simplified approximations of Bunton and Shiner (1961a) give a value of 0-73 for l. 

In water an acid, AH, can transfer a proton, cooperatively, through one or several water molecules, as shown in Fig. 6. For proton transfer from trimethylammonium ion to trimethylamine, n is known to be 

---

A relative selectivity toward one of the anions, which depends on the grid-complex used as the starting material, was observed in these experiments. It is interesting to compare the results of tests 2 and 3, on the one hand, and those of tests 4 and 5 on the other. These correspond to experiments in which the same cationic grid is used as the starting material but with a different counter-anion. The data are clearly different, indicating that the solid state structure of the starting material is very important in the selectivity towards a specific anion. 

The object of this section is to consider work associated with the detailed description of the proton transfer process in A-SB2 processes. Included are the nuclear arrangement and electronic structure in the starting state, the transition state, and important intermediate states, as well as the dynamics of the process. This work seems hardly more than begun, and many problems remain. Nevertheless some results have been achieved and the relative promise of various possible approaches can be assessed. Needless to say, much of the contents of this section is speculative. 

How can we draw the structure of the unstable transition state The stmcture of the transition state is somewhere in between the structures of the starting material and product. Any bond that is partially broken or formed is drawn with a dashed line. Any atom that gains or loses a charge contains a partial charge in the transition state. Transition states are drawn in brackets, with a superscript double dagger ( ). 

Problem 6.15 Draw an energy diagram for the Bronsted-Lowry acid-base reaction of CH3CO2H with "OCICHglg to form CH3CO2" and (CHglgCOH. Label the axes, starting materials, products, AH°, and Eg. Draw the structure of the transition state. 

In the absence of Lewis acid the stereochemical outcome was controlled by the conformation of the starting radicals XIII (Sch. 11). Divalent Lewis acids such as MgBr2 or Mgl2 could alter the structure of the transition state XIV to the bidentate chelate, thus changing the diastereofacial selectivity of the addition reaction. 

Hammond-Leffler postulate. States that the structure of the transition state more closely resembles the product or the starting material, depending on which is higher in enthalpy. 

It should be emphasized that polymerization in a glow discharge consists of both plasma-induced polymerization and plasma state polymerization. Which of these two mechanisms plays the predominant role depends not only on the chemical structure of the starting material but on the condition of the discharge. 

The stereochemistry of products relative to starting materials can give important clues to the structure of the transition state. The stereochemistry of molecules gives rise to two types of isomerism optical isomerism (cnantiomcrismjand geometrical isomerism. 

Figure 8.27 (a) Topotactic, single crystal solid-state photodimerisation of 5-benzyl-2-benzylidene-cyclopentanone. (b) Superposition of the structures of the starting material and dimersied product (reprinted with permission from [33] 1981 American Chemical Society). 

---