Reaction paths experimental determination

One of the possibilities is to study experimentally the coupled system as a whole, at a time when all the reactions concerned are taking place. On the basis of the data obtained it is possible to solve the system of differential equations (1) simultaneously and to determine numerical values of all the parameters unknown (constants). This approach can be refined in that the equations for the stoichiometrically simple reactions can be specified in view of the presumed mechanism and the elementary steps so that one obtains a very complex set of different reaction paths with many unidentifiable intermediates. A number of procedures have been suggested to solve such complicated systems. Some of them start from the assumption of steady-state rates of the individual steps and they were worked out also for stoichiometrically not simple reactions [see, e.g. (8, 9, 5a)]. A concise treatment of the properties of the systems of consecutive processes has been written by Noyes (10). The simplification of the treatment of some complex systems can be achieved by using isotopically labeled compounds (8, 11, 12, 12a, 12b). Even very complicated systems which involve non-... 

The simultaneous determination of a great number of constants is a serious disadvantage of this procedure, since it considerably reduces the reliability of the solution. Experimental results can in some, not too complex cases be described well by means of several different sets of equations or of constants. An example would be the study of Wajc et al. (14) who worked up the data of Germain and Blanchard (15) on the isomerization of cyclohexene to methylcyclopentenes under the assumption of a very simple mechanism, or the simulation of the course of the simplest consecutive catalytic reaction A — B —> C, performed by Thomas et al. (16) (Fig. 1). If one studies the kinetics of the coupled system as a whole, one cannot, as a rule, follow and express quantitatively mutually influencing single reactions. Furthermore, a reaction path which at first sight is less probable and has not been therefore considered in the original reaction network can be easily overlooked. 

The relative stabilities of the species involved appear to be responsible for the stereochemical outcomes. Relief of ring strain must play a role in determining the course of the reaction. An explanation for the different reaction paths on using different Grignard reagents must wait further experimentation. 

Figure 7.24. Solid-state photochemical decarbonylation model for ketones. The dashed path corresponds to the experimentally determined energies of acetone (in kcal/mol). The effects of substituents with radical stabilizing energies (RSEs) are illustrated by the solid line in the reaction coordinate. See color insert.

The only points on the potential surface for which experimental data are available are the minima, corresponding to stable molecules whose properties can be studied. The geometry of a molecule corresponds to the coordinates of the corresponding point and its heat of formation to the height of the point in the potential surface. The frequenciesof molecular vibrations, determined spectroscopically, allow one to also estimate the curvature of the potential surface at the minimum. It is easily seen that all these quantities must be reproduced by our theoretical treatment if it is to be applied to calculations of reaction paths. 

The techniques of monomolecular rate theory easily transform measured reaction data into a form where we can analyze apparent kinetics and the effects of intracrystalline diffusion by the use of selectivity data. Time dependency has been eliminated. Since selectivity is extremely reproducible and is independent of short-term aging effects, the number of experimental runs is reduced while data reliability is maintained. For catalyst evaluation at any temperature, it is necessary to determine the equilibrium composition and the straight-line reaction path. With this information any catalyst can be evaluated at this temperature with simply the additional information from a curved-line reaction path. The approach used in the application of monomolecular rate theory to the xylene isomerization selectivity kinetics is as follows. Reference is made to the composition diagram, Figure 1. 

Straight-Line Reaction Paths. For a three-component reversible monomolecular system only two straight-line reaction paths exist both can be observed experimentally. Normally, the slow straight-line reaction path is estimated as the tangent to any curved-line reaction path at the equilibrium composition. This path is subsequently determined more precisely in the laboratory. The locus of the second, or fast, straight-line reaction path is then calculated (1). 

The technique for determining straight-line reaction paths in this work differed from the usual experimental approach. Our approach also determined the straight-line reaction path by minimizing the deviation between the experimental data and those predicted. 

Prior to, and perhaps also after, the formation of the a complex, a 77 complex (with the aromatic ring behaving as electron donor) can form, although it has not been proved that its formation is a necessary step in the reaction path.44 It has recently been suggested that the formation of the n complex could in some cases become rate-determining, when the electrophile is a very powerful one.45 This hypothesis, although questioned both from the experimental and theoretical point of view,46-48 is a possibility and could be applicable also when the aromatic substrate is a powerful nucleophile (as is the case with many five-membered heterocyclic rings). 

The focus in the reaction dynamics studies was on the N02 elimination channel, but they also studied the HONO elimination reactions [70]. They based the potential energy surface on experimental data but performed some minimal basis set ab initio calculations to determine geometries, force fields, torsional potentials, and some information about the reaction paths. The representations of the global potential energy surfaces were based on valence force fields for equilibrium structures with arbitrary switching functions operating on the potential parameters to effect smooth and (assumed) proper behavior along the reaction paths. Based on the available experiments [71-73], they assumed that the primary decomposition reaction is simple N-N bond rupture to eliminate N02. 

Although both the laboratory and industrial scale materials science of catalysts requires an integrated approach as already mentioned above, it is customary to classify the characterization methods by their objects and experimental tools used. I will use the object classification and direct the introductory comments to analysis, primarily elemental and molecular surface analysis, determination of geometric structure, approaches toward the determination of electronic structure, characterization by chemisorption and reaction studies, determination of pore structure, morphology, and texture, and, finally, the role of theory in interpreting the often complex characterization data as well as predicting reaction paths. 

---