Radicals, anti-Markovnikov reaction

The change in regiochemistry is a result of a change in the mechanism of the reaction, from an ionic mechanism in the Markovnikov reaction to a radical chain mechanism in the anti-Markovnikov reaction. The radical chain mechanism for the addition of hydrogen bromide to 1-butene is outlined in the following equations ... 

In 1933, M. S. Kharasch and F. W. Mayo found that some additions of HBr (but not HC1 or HI) to alkenes gave products that were opposite to those expected from Markovnikov s rule. These anti-Markovnikov reactions were most likely when the reagents or solvents came from old supplies that had accumulated peroxides from exposure to the air. Peroxides give rise to free radicals that initiate the addition, causing it to occur by a radical mechanism. The oxygen-oxygen bond in peroxides is rather weak, so it can break to give two alkoxy radicals. 

Free radical anti-Markovnikov addition of coordinated phosphine to non-coor-dinated alkene, a still relatively rarely explored reaction providing the effective formation of a C-P bond, remains a promising strategy for macrocycle formation. 

The mechanism of the addition reaction under these conditions is not an ionic sequence rather, it is a much faster radical chain sequence. The reason is that the activation energies of the component steps of radical reactions are very small, as we observed earlier during the discussion of the radical halogenation of alkanes (Section 3-4). Consequently, in the presence of radicals, anti-Markovnikov hydrobromination simply outpaces the regular addition pathway. The initiation steps are... 

A typical example of a nonpolymeric chain-propagating radical reaction is the anti-Markovnikov addition of hydrogen sulfide to a terminal olefin. The mechanism involves alternating abstraction and addition reactions in the propagating steps ... 

Free radical additions to mono-olefins are quite common and can frequently be employed to advantage on a synthetic scale. Formamide, for example, on exposure to sunlight or UV radiation adds to olefins in an anti-Markovnikov sense giving 1 1 adducts that are readily isolated and crystallized. Moreover, since alkyl formamides may be conveniently converted to carboxylic acids by conventional means, the reaction represents a general method of chain extension. 

Se-phenyl areneselenosulfonates (24) undergo facile free-radical addition to alkenes to produce / -phenylseleno sulfones (25) in excellent yield86,87 (see Scheme 7). The addition occurs regiospecifically and affords anti-Markovnikov products contrary to the analogous boron trifluoride catalyzed reaction which produces exclusively Markovnikov and highly stereospecific products86 (equation 37). Reaction 36 has been shown to have the radical... 

In both mechanisms, the regiochemistry is determined by a preference for forming the most stable intermediate possible. For example, in the ionic mechanism, adds to produce a tertiary carbocation, rather than a secondary carbocation. Similarly, in the radical mechanism, Br adds to produce a tertiary radical, rather than a secondary radical, hi this respect, the two reactions are very similar. But take special notice of the fundamental difference. In the ionic mechanism, the proton comes on first. However, in the radical mechanism, the bromine comes on first. This critical difference explains why an ionic mechanism gives a Markovnikov addition while a radical mechanism gives an anti-Markovnikov addition. 

We have now seen two pathways for adding HBr across a donble bond the ionic pathway (which gives Markovnikov addition) and the radical pathway (which gives anti-Markovnikov addition). Both pathways are actnally in competition with each other. However, the radical reaction is a mnch faster reaction. Therefore, we can control the regiochemistry of addition by carefully choosing the conditions. If we use a radical initiator, like ROOR, then the radical pathway will predominate, and we will see an anti-Markovnikov addition. If we do not use a radical initiator, then the ionic pathway will predominate, and we will see a Markovnikov addition ... 

Anti-Markovnikov addition of HBr to alkynes occur when peroxides are present. 1) These reactions take place through a free radical mechanism. 

Similar to the addition of secondary phosphine-borane complexes to alkynes described in Scheme 6.137, the same hydrophosphination agents can also be added to alkenes under broadly similar reaction conditions, leading to alkylarylphosphines (Scheme 6.138) [274], Again, the expected anti-Markovnikov addition products were obtained exclusively. In some cases, the additions also proceeded at room temperature, but required much longer reaction times (2 days). Treatment of the phosphine-borane complexes with a chiral alkene such as (-)-/ -pinene led to chiral cyclohexene derivatives through a radical-initiated ring-opening mechanism. In related work, Ackerman and coworkers described microwave-assisted Lewis acid-mediated inter-molecular hydroamination reactions of norbornene [275]. 

Electron transfer sensitization allows either the radical cation or the radical anion of an aromatic alkene to form as desired, which finally results in nucleophile addition with Markovnikov and anti-Markovnikov regiochemistry. In an apolar solvent, the tight radical ion pair undergoes a stereoselective reaction when the electron-accepting sensitizer is chiral (Figure 3.10). ... 

The stereoselectivity of anti-Markovnikov adducts (161) and (162) produced through photo-induced electron-transfer reaction of (160) with MeOH in MeCN depends on the optimum structures and stabilities of the corresponding radical and carbanion intermediates (163) and (164). In PhH, steric hindrance in an exciplex, comprising an excited singlet sensitizer and (160), forced cis addition of MeOH to (160) to give trans-isomer (161) as the major addition product. 

Now, just the same sort of rationalization can be applied to the radical addition, in that the more favourable secondary radical is predominantly produced. This, in turn, leads to addition of HBr in what is the anti-Markovnikov orientation. The apparent difference is because the electrophile in the ionic mechanism is a proton, and bromide then quenches the resultant cation. In the radical reaction, the attacking species is a bromine atom, and a hydrogen atom is then used to quench the radical. This is effectively a reverse sequence for the addition process but, nevertheless, the stability of the intermediate carbocation or radical is the defining feature. The terminologies Markovnikov or anti-Markovnikov orientation may be confusing and difficult to remember consider the mechanism and it all makes sense. 

Substituted cyclopropane systems also undergo nucleophilic addition of suitable solvents (MeOH). For example, the photoinduced ET reaction of 1,2-dimethyl-3-phenylcyclopropane (112, R = Me) with p-dicyanobenzene formed a ring-opened ether by anti-Markovnikov addition. The reaction occurs with essentially complete inversion of configuration at carbon, suggesting a nucleophilic cleavage of a one-electron cyclopropane bond, generating 113. The retention of chirality confirms that the stereochemistry of the parent molecule is unperturbed in the radical cation 112 " ". 

Kharasch and Mayo in 1933," in the first of many papers on the subject, showed that the addition of HBr to allyl bromide in the presence of light and air occurs rapidly to yield 1,3-dibromopropane, whereas in the absence of air and with purified reagents, the reaction is slow and 1,2-dibromopropane is formed. The latter reaction is the normal addition occurring by an ionic pathway giving the Markovnikov orientation. In 1933 the mechanism of the abnormal process ( anti-Markovnikov addition) was not discussed, and it was only in 1937 that the free radical chain mechanism for this process was proposed by Kharasch and his co-workers. "" The mechanism was extended to propene, for which the role of peroxides in promoting the reaction was demonstrated (equations 30, 31). This mechanism was also proposed... 

Taylor in 1925 demonstrated that hydrogen atoms generated by the mercury sensitized photodecomposition of hydrogen gas add to ethylene to form ethyl radicals, which were proposed to react with H2 to give the observed ethane and another hydrogen atom. Evidence that polymerization could occur by free radical reactions was found by Taylor and Jones in 1930, by the observation that ethyl radicals formed by the gas phase pyrolysis of diethylmercury or tetraethyllead initiated the polymerization of ethylene, and this process was extended to the solution phase by Cramer. The mechanism of equation (37) (with participation by a third body) was presented for the reaction, - which is in accord with current views, and the mechanism of equation (38) was shown for disproportionation. Staudinger in 1932 wrote a mechanism for free radical polymerization of styrene,but just as did Rice and Rice (equation 32), showed the radical attack on the most substituted carbon (anti-Markovnikov attack). The correct orientation was shown by Flory in 1937. In 1935, O.K. Rice and Sickman reported that ethylene polymerization was also induced by methyl radicals generated from thermolysis of azomethane. 

The peroxide- or light-catalyzed reaction has a free-radical mechanism (anti-Markovnikov) ... 

The addition of hydrogen halides to simple olefins, in the absence of peroxides, takes place by an electrophilic mechanism, and the orientation is in accord with Markovnikov s rule.116 When peroxides are added, the addition of HBr occurs by a free-radical mechanism and the orientation is anti-Markovnikov (p. 751).137 It must be emphasized that this is true only for HBr. Free-radical addition of HF and HI has never been observed, even in the presence of peroxides, and of HCI only rarely. In the rare cases where free-radical addition of HCI was noted, the orientation was still Markovnikov, presumably because the more stable product was formed.,3B Free-radical addition of HF, HI, and HCI is energetically unfavorable (see the discussions on pp. 683, 693). It has often been found that anti-Markovnikov addition of HBr takes place even when peroxides have not been added. This happens because the substrate alkenes absorb oxygen from the air, forming small amounts of peroxides (4-9). Markovnikov addition can be ensured by rigorous purification of the substrate, but in practice this is not easy to achieve, and it is more common to add inhibitors, e.g., phenols or quinones, which suppress the free-radical pathway. The presence of free-radical precursors such as peroxides does not inhibit the ionic mechanism, but the radical reaction, being a chain process, is much more rapid than the electrophilic reaction. In most cases it is possible to control the mechanism (and hence the orientation) by adding peroxides... 

Anti-Markovnikov free-radical-induced addition of HBr to alkenes can be prevented by carrying out the reaction in the presence of small amounts of antioxidants that inhibit the reaction of oxygen with the alkene to form peroxides. 

Reaction 1 has been postulated both in oxidations of alkanes in the vapor phase (29) and in the anti-Markovnikov addition of hydrogen bromide to olefins in the liquid phase (14). Reaction 2 involves the established mechanism for free-radical bromination of aromatic side chains (2). Reaction 4 as part of the propagation step, established in earlier work without bromine radicals (26), was not invoked by Ravens, because of the absence of [RCH3] in the rate equation. Equations 4 to 6, in which Reaction 6 was rate-determining, were replaced by Ravens by the reaction of peroxy radical with Co2+ ... 

Although HI addition to alkenes and alkynes is faster than that of the other hydrohalides and free radical anti-Maikovnikov additions are not a problem, this reaction has received less attention than the others.173 The hydroiodination of alkenes is most commonly run using concentrated HI in water or acetic acid at or below room temperature. While the early literature suggests that simple terminal alkenes afford small amounts of anti-Markovnikov products, only Markovnikov products have been reported in the more recent literature (equations 125-129).67 176-179... 

Reactions of BufOI/BF3, AcOI, IC1 or IBr with 1,3-butadiene give mixtures of Markovnikov 1,2- and 1,4-addition products no anti-Markovnikov 1,2-products have been detected. A radical mechanism was observed for Bu OI. Greater 1,4-addition occurs with reagents containing an anion of lower basicity (IC1 and IBr). These results have been interpreted as reflecting the charge density and ion-pair stability191. 

C is correct. Anti-Markovnikov alkene free radical addition is demonstrated by reaction mechanisms 1 and 2, both of which rely on peroxides as reagents. Based on tine experimental results provided by the question stem, anti-Markovnikov addition only succeeds using HBr. 

Some reactions do not follow Markovnikov s Rule, and anti-Markovnikov products are isolated. This is a feature for example of radical induced additions of HX and of Hydroboration. 

---