Radical addition polar effects

Rate constants and Arrhenius parameters for the reaction of Et3Si radicals with various carbonyl compounds are available. Some data are collected in Table 5.2 [49]. The ease of addition of EtsSi radicals was found to decrease in the order 1,4-benzoquinone > cyclic diaryl ketones, benzaldehyde, benzil, perfluoro propionic anhydride > benzophenone alkyl aryl ketone, alkyl aldehyde > oxalate > benzoate, trifluoroacetate, anhydride > cyclic dialkyl ketone > acyclic dialkyl ketone > formate > acetate [49,50]. This order of reactivity was rationalized in terms of bond energy differences, stabilization of the radical formed, polar effects, and steric factors. Thus, a phenyl or acyl group adjacent to the carbonyl will stabilize the radical adduct whereas a perfluoroalkyl or acyloxy group next to the carbonyl moiety will enhance the contribution given by the canonical structure with a charge separation to the transition state (Equation 5.24). 

Numerous studies have been devoted to the addition of RSO2X to olefins. The propagation steps for these chain processes are shown in Scheme 13. The main factors controlling the reactivity of sulfonyl radicals are polar effects and the reversibility of the addition. Sulfonyl radicals exhibit an electrophilic character with respect to addition to olefins [98]. Evidence for the reversibility came early from the observation of the isomerization of cis- and rran -2-butenes during their copolymerization with sulfur dioxide and their Cu(I)-mediated reaction with benzenesulfonyl chloride [99]. Therefore, the chain transfer of alky] adduct radica]s has to compete effectively with -elimination of sulfonyl radicals (see Scheme 13). Selenosulfonates, sulfonyl halides, and sulfonyl cyanides are the most popular substrates that meet this property. 

A clear demonstration of the relative importance of steric and resonance factors in radical additions to carbon-carbon double bonds can be found by considering the effect of (non-polar) substituents on the rate of attack of (nonpolar) radicals. Substituents on the double bond strongly retard addition at the substituted carbon while leaving the rate of addition to the other end essentially unaffected (for example, Table 1.3). This is in keeping with expectation if steric factors determine the regiospeeificity of addition, but contrary to expectation if resonance factors are dominant. 

Figure 1.2 Effect of polar factors on regiospecificity of radical addition.

The above argument is also at odds with the conventional wisdom that the well-known tendency for monomer alternation in copolymerization can primarily be attributed to polar factors. It was suggested9 that, in most cases, radical stabilization could provide an alternate explanation. A discussion on the relative importance of steric polar and radical stabilization effects on radical addition appears in Section 2.3. 

Given the important role that stcric and polar factors play in determining the rate and regiospecifieity of radical additions (see 2.3), it might be anticipated that reagents which coordinate with the propagating radical and/or the monomer and thereby modify the effective size, polarity, or inherent stability of that species, could alter the outcome of propagation. 

The mechanism of free-radical addition follows the pattern discussed in Chapter 14 (pp. 894-895). The method of principal component analysis has been used to analyze polar and enthalpic effect in radical addition reactions. A radical is generated by... 

The first step of a free radical aromatic substitution, the formation of the a-com-plex, is also an addition step. The o,m,p-product ratio therefore also responds to steric effects. This is shown for the free radical phenylation and dimethylamination of toluene and r.-butylbenzene in Table 8. The larger the substituent on the aromatic system and the bulkier the attacking radical, the more p-substitution product is obtained at the expense of o-substitution. In the phenylation reaction the yield of m-product also increases in contrast to the dimethylamination reaction. The substitution pattern of this latter reaction is, in addition to the steric effect, governed heavily by polar effects because a radical cation is the attacking species113. ... 

The polar effect involved in radical addition has been repeatedly discussed in the scientific literature. The parabolic model opens up new prospects for the correct estimation of the polar effect (see Section 6.2.7). It permits one to determine the contribution of this effect to the activation energy using experimental data. This contribution (AE ) is estimated by choosing a reference reaction that involves the same reaction center but in which one or both reactants... 

Contribution of the Polar Effect Ato the Activation Energy of the Addition of Polar Radicals to Polar Monomers CH2=CRY (Calculated from the Data of Several Studies [40,51-53])... 

The cumulated Jt-system of allenes has been described as consisting of two comparatively unperturbed double bonds with regard to its reactivity towards nucleophiles or electrophiles [10]. Early reports on radical additions to 1,2-dienes, however, already pointed to peculiarities of the allene system concerning its reactivity towards intermediates with unpaired electrons [11-14], It was soon realized that no such correlation between polar and steric substituent effects existed, similar to what had been uncovered for the reaction of radicals with olefins, in order to predict selectivities in radical additions to cumulated dienes [4, 15],... 

Polar effects appear to be of prime importance in determining the effect of quinones. p-Benzoquinone and chloranil (which are electron-poor) act as inhibitors toward electron-rich propagating radicals (vinyl acetate and styrene) but only as retarders toward the electron-poor acrylonitrile and methyl methacrylate propagating radicals. A further observation is that the inhibiting ability of a quinone toward electron-poor monomers can be increased by the addition of an electron-rich third component such as an amine. Thus the presence of triethylamine converts chloranil from a very weak retarder to an inhibitor toward methyl methacrylate. 

Because the addition steps are generally fast and consequently exothermic chain steps, their transition states should occur early on the reaction coordinate and therefore resemble the starting alkene. This was recently confirmed by ab initio calculations for the attack at ethylene by methyl radicals and fluorene atoms. The relative stability of the adduct radicals therefore should have little influence on reacti-vity 2 ). The analysis of reactivity and regioselectivity for radical addition reactions, however, is even more complex, because polar effects seem to have an important influence. It has been known for some time that electronegative radicals X-prefer to react with ordinary alkenes while nucleophilic alkyl or acyl radicals rather attack electron deficient olefins e.g., cyano or carbonyl substituted olefins The best known example for this behavior is copolymerization This view was supported by different MO-calculation procedures and in particular by the successful FMO-treatment of the regioselectivity and relative reactivity of additions of radicals to a series of alkenes An excellent review of most of the more recent experimental data and their interpretation was published recently by Tedder and... 

Rates of radical additions to alkenes are controlled mainly by the enthalpy of the reaction, which is the origin of regioselectivity in additions to unsymmetrical systems, with polar effects superimposed when there is a favorable match between the electrophilic or nucleophilic character of the radical and that of the radico-phile. For example, in the addition of an alkyl radical to methyl acrylate (2), the nucleophilic alkyl radical interacts favorably with the resonance structure 3. Polar effects are apparent in the representative rate constants shown in Figure 4.14 for additions of carbon radicals to terminal alkenes. Addition of the electron-deficient or electrophilic rert-butoxycarbonylmethyl radical to the electron-deficient molecule methyl acrylate is 10 times as fast as addition of... 

More recently, radical additions to fluoroethenes have attracted attention. Eguchi et al. [125] applied the Barton decarboxylation procedure to add a range of alkyl radicals to l,l-dichloro-2,2-difluoroethene. Addition was regioselective and the terminal carbon could be hydrolysed to a carboxyl group with silver(I) mediation (Eq. 39). The fluoroalkene is effectively an equivalent for either difluoroacetyl anion or cation synthons, because the adding radical can be approached from either polarity manifold. 

---