Isomers problem solving techniques

In this book, we shall describe algorithms for solving these problems. The techniques are based on the representation of chemical compounds as molecular graphs, i.e. they are mainly applied to constitutional isomers. 

Whilst these two isomers could undoubtedly be differentiated by using HMBC, this is a problem that would be best solved by using an NOE technique. The aryl methyl would provide an ideal target for irradiation. Such an experiment would be expected to give strong enhancements in either case as shown above. As couplings of any enhanced signals are maintained in Overhauser experiments, the distinction between the two would be immediately obvious. 

The structure of bergamotene was, for some years during the 1960s, a matter of debate. The difficult question was the configuration of the chiral centre ringed in black. With modern spectroscopic techniques, we can now solve this type of problem simply, but the only solution then was to synthesise the two isomers and compare them with the natural material. There is more about bergamotene in Chapter 46. 

Separation is required when (1) a mixture is too complex for a direct analytical measurement (e.g., spectroscopy), (2) the materials to be analyzed are very similar, such as isomers, (3) it is necessary to prepare highly purified materials, and (4) a measurement of the amount of a particular material is needed. Filtration, open-column chromatography, and thin-layer chromatography are used for relatively easy separations. Modern HPLC is a technique for making precision separations of complex mixtures and offers high-resolution separating capability to solve problems faster and better. 

Solution of the Kohn-Sham equations as outlined above are done within the static limit, i.e. use of the Born-Oppenheimer approximation, which implies that the motions of the nuclei and electrons are solved separately. It should however in many cases be of interest to include the dynamics of, for example, the reaction of molecules with clusters or surfaces. A combined ab initio method for solving both the geometric and electronic problem simultaneously is the Car-Parrinello method, which is a DFT dynamics method [52]. This method uses a plane wave expansion for the density, and the inner ions are replaced by pseudo-potentials [53]. Today this method has been extensively used for studies of dynamic problems in solids, clusters, fullerenes etc [54-61]. We have recently in a co-operation project with Andreoni at IBM used this technique for studying the existence of different isomers of transition metal clusters [62,63]. 

Gravimetric or manometric techniques have been used to establish adsorption data of gases on zeolites. Both techniques present problems, manometric equipment has an accumulation of the error and data obtained by the gravimetric method are influenced by effects associated with flow patterns, bypassing, and buoyancy. In the mixture s adsorption behaviour, isomers mixtures have the highest degree of difficulty to study. Isomers can not be differentiated in standard commercial adsorption equipment. This problem has been solved in this study by coupling a manometric apparatus with an NIR spectrometer, which allows us to measure the gas phase composition (in time, if necessaiy). In this paper we report this new approach to study the adsorption of mixtures of butane and iso-butane. 

Resolution problems in the GC analysis of FA esters prompted many investigators in the past to develop capillary techniques to search for more selective stationary phases, and ultimately, to combine both approaches whenever required. In fact, FA esters were among the first substances (beyond hydrocarbons) that were successfully chromatographed on stainless steel capillary columns [355]. The most difficult separations involve different geometrical isomers, and the presence and positions of unsaturated carbon-carbon bonds. Such separations are non-trivial and justify the effort of numerous laboratories to solve these problems. 

Specific adsorbents have been prepared for a large number of compound types at the present time. In some cases these adsorbents seem capable of effecting quite difficult separations [e.g., optical isomers (123,131,132) and certain stereoisomers (110,111)]. Despite their unique promise, however, specific adsorbents have not yet been used to any significant extent in solving practical problems. Their preparation is invariably tedious and time consuming, their capacity for selective adsorption is unusually low, nonlinear isotherms are typical, and the specific selectivity is frequently slight. Furthermore, the technique can be applied only to those compounds which are appreciably adsorbed under the conditions of gel preparation. In almost all cases it is more profitable to attempt the chromatographic... 

GC-MS continues to play an important role in the identification and quantification of analytes. Several ionization techniques are also used in GC-MS. Among them, El is the most popular because it often produces both molecular and fragment ions. One important feature of El spectra is that they are highly reproducible, which means that mass spectral libraries can be used for the identification of unknowns. However, in some cases, El does not provide the sensitivity required for the analysis of very small amounts of compounds in environmental samples. To solve this problem, softer ionization techniques such as Cl are applied. Moreover, Cl is the technique of choice for the analysis of isomers, because different isomers have different reactivities toward the reagent gas, resulting in different spectra. With El, very similar spectra are obtained for different isomer compounds. 

In 1951, the Dutch scientist J. M. Bijvoet developed a special x-ray technique that solved the problem. Using this technique on crystals of the sodium rubidium salt of (+)-tartaric acid, Bijvoet showed that it had the (R,R) configuration. So this was the tartaric acid studied by Pasteur, and racemic acid was a 50 50 mixture of the R,R) and (S,S) isomers. The meso form was not studied until later. 

In the Varian series titled NMR at Work, one example cited in which optical spectroscopy is not satisfactory for the analysis is in the study of the conversion of 2-/-butyl-5-methyl cyclohexanone into its enol acetate [ ]. In this reaction an inseparable mixture is formed and it was shown that NMR spectroscopy can be used to obtain the percent of each isomer ptesent in the mixture. The uniqueness of NMR spectroscopy in solving this problem lies in the fact that the intensity of the signal observed by an NMR spectrometer is directly proportional to the number of nuclei contributing to that signal. Thus, if the total number of protons present in the sample are known, it is possible to calculate the number contributing to each signal observed in the spectrum. This technique cannot be utilized in the usual optical spectroscopy methods since an absorptivity constant is required to relate a peak intensity to concentration. 

---